Answ. If only Good as such, be the object of Love, then certainly none should be loved but in proportion to his Goodness. But you must distinguish between mere natural and sensitive Love or appetite, and Rational Love; and between Love, and the Effects of Love; and between Natural Goodness in the object and Moral Goodness. And so I further answer, 1. There is in every man a natural and sensitive love of himself and his own pleasure and felicity, and an averseness to death and pain and sorrow, as there is in every Brute: And this God hath planted there for the preservation of the creature. This falleth not under commands or prohibitions directly, because it is not free but necessary: as no man is commanded or forbidden to be hungry, or thirsty, or weary, or the like: It is not this Love which is meant when we are commanded to Love our neighbour as our selves: For I am not commanded to feel hunger and thirst, nor to desire meat or drink by the sensitive appetite for my neighbour: Nor sensitively to feel his pain or pleasure, nor to have that natural aversation from death and pain, nor sensitive desire of life and pleasure, for him as for my self. But the Love here spoken of, is that Volition with the due affection conjunct, which is our Rational Love; as being the act of our highest faculty, and falling under Gods command. As to the sensitive Love, it proceedeth not upon the sense or estimate of Goodness in the person who loveth himself or any other (as Beasts love their young ones without respect to their excellency). But it is Rational Love which is proportioned to the estimated Goodness of the thing beloved. 2. Physical Goodness may be in an object which hath no Moral Goodness; and this may contain a capacity of moral goodness: And each of them is amiable according to its nature and degree. 3. Beneficence is sometimes an effect of Love, and sometime an effect of wisdom only as to the object, and of Love to something else: but it is never Love it self. Usually benevolence is an act of Love, and beneficence an effect, but not always. I may do good to another without any love to him, for some ends of my own, or for the sake of another. And a man may be obliged to greater beneficence, where he is not obliged to greater Love.
Answ. If only Good as such, be the object of Love, then certainly none should be loved but in proportion to his Goodness. But you must distinguish between meer natural and sensitive Love or appetite, and Rational Love; and between Love, and the Effects of Love; and between Natural Goodness in the object and Moral Goodness. And so I further answer, 1. There is in every man a natural and sensitive love of himself and his own pleasure and felicity, and an averseness to death and pain and sorrow, as there is in every Bruit: And this God hath planted there for the preservation of the creature. This falleth not under commands or prohibitions directly, because it is not free but necessary: as no man is commanded or forbidden to be hungry, or thirsty, or weary, or the like: It is not this Love which is meant when we are commanded to Love our neighbour as our selves: For I am not commanded to feel hunger and thirst, nor to desire meat or drink by the sensitive appetite for my neighbour: Nor sensitively to feel his pain or pleasure, nor to have that natural aversation from death and pain, nor sensitive desire of life and pleasure, for him as for my self. But the Love here spoken of, is that Volition with the due affection conjunct, which is our Rational Love; as being the act of our highest faculty, and falling under Gods command. As to the sensitive Love, it proceedeth not upon the sense or estimate of Goodness in the person who loveth himself or any other (as Beasts love their young ones without respect to their excellency). But it is Rational Love which is proportioned to the estimated Goodness of the thing beloved. 2. Physical Goodness may be in an object which hath no Moral Goodness; and this may contain a capacity of moral goodness: And each of them is amiable according to its nature and degree. 3. Beneficence is sometimes an effect of Love, and sometime an effect of wisdome only as to the object, and of Love to something else: but it is never Love it self. Usually benevolence is an act of Love, and beneficence an effect, but not alwayes. I may do good to another without any love to him, for some ends of my own, or for the sake of another. And a man may be obliged to greater beneficence, where he is not obliged to greater Love.