Answ. Yes, in some cases: As, 1. When it is necessary to save another that is falsely accused of the crime. 2. Or when the interest of the Common-wealth requireth it. But otherwise, not; Because an offender may lawfully accept of mercy, and nature teacheth him to desire his own preservation: But if the question be, When doth the interest of the Common-wealth require it? I think, much oftener than it is done: As the common-interest requireth that murderers be put to death, when apprehended: So it requireth that they may not frequently and easily be hid, or escape by secrecy or flight: For then it would embolden others to murder: whereas when few escape, it will more effectually deter men: If therefore any murderers conscience, shall constrain him in true repentance, ⟨p. 205⟩voluntarily to come forth and confess his sin, and yield up himself to justice, and exhort others to take heed of sinning as he did, I cannot say that he did any more than his duty in so doing: And indeed I think that it is ordinarily a duty, and that ordinarily the interest of the Common wealth requireth it; though in some cases it may be otherwise. The execution of the Laws against Murder, is so necessary to preserve mens lives, that I do not think that self-preservation alone will allow men to defeat the Common-wealth of so necessary a means of preserving the lives of many, to save the life of one, who hath no right to his own life, as having forfeited it. If to shift away other murderers from the hand of Justice be a sin, I cannot see but that it is so ordinarily, to do it for ones self: Only I think that if a true penitent person have just cause to think that he may do the Common-wealth more service by his life, than by his death, that then he may conceal his crime or fly; But otherwise not.
Answ. Yes, in some cases: As, 1. When it is necessary to save another that is falsly accused of the crime. 2. Or when the interest of the Common-wealth requireth it. But otherwise, not; Because an offender may lawfully accept of mercy, and nature teacheth him to desire his own preservation: But if the question be, When doth the interest of the Common-wealth require it? I think, much ofter than it is done: As the common-interest requireth that murderers be put to death, when apprehended: So it requireth that they may not frequently and easily be hid, or escape by secresie or flight: For then it would embolden others to murder: whereas when few escape, it will more effectually deter men: If therefore any murderers conscience, shall constrain him in true repentance, ⟨p. 205⟩voluntarily to come forth and confess his sin, and yield up himself to justice, and exhort others to take heed of sinning as he did, I cannot say that he did any more than his duty in so doing: And indeed I think that it is ordinarily a duty, and that ordinarily the interest of the Common wealth requireth it; though in some cases it may be otherwise. The execution of the Laws against Murder, is so necessary to preserve mens lives, that I do not think that self-preservation alone will allow men to defeat the Common-wealth of so necessary a means of preserving the lives of many, to save the life of one, who hath no right to his own life, as having forfeited it. If to shift away other murderers from the hand of Justice be a sin, I cannot see but that it is so ordinarily, to do it for ones self: Only I think that if a true penitent person have just cause to think that he may do the Common-wealth more service by his life, than by his death, that then he may conceal his crime or fly; But otherwise not.