Church-history of the government of bishops and their councils abbreviated including the chief part…
Church-history of the government of bishops and their councils abbreviated including the chief part of the government of Christian princes and popes, and a true account of the most troubling controversies and heresies till the Reformation ... / by Richard Baxter ...
Richard Baxter 1615–1691London: printed by B. Griffin for Thomas Simmons, 1680
[44], 488 p. · 238k words · Wing B1224 · ESTC R229528
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. Yea, if any man bring not the doctrine of Christ, we must not receive him into our houses, or bid him God speed, lest we be partakers of his evil deeds, for he that abideth not in this doctrine hath not God, 2 John 9. 10, 11. Gal. 1. 8. 9. [Though we or an Angel from heaven, preach any other Gospel to you, then that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed. As we said before, so say I now again: If any man preach any other Gospel to you then that ye have received, let him be accursed.] And Rom. 16. 17, 18. Now I beseech you Brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences, contrary to the Doctrine which ye have learned, and avoid them] 1 Tim. 6. 3. If any man teach otherwise, and consent not to wholesome words, the words of our Lord Jesus Christ, and to the Doctrine which is according to Godliness, he is proud, knowing nothing, but doting.—]
3. Yea, if any man bring not the doctrine of Christ, we must not receive him into our houses, or bid him God speed, lest we be partakers of his evil deeds, for he that abideth not in this doctrine hath not God, 2 John 9. 10, 11. Gal. 1. 8. 9. [Though we or an Angel from heaven, preach any other Gospel to you, then that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed. As we said before, so say I now again: If any man preach any other Gospel to you then that ye have received, let him be accursed.] And Rom. 16. 17, 18. Now I beseech you Brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences, contrary to the Doctrine which ye have learned, and avoid them] 1 Tim. 6. 3. If any man teach otherwise, and consent not to wholsome words, the words of our Lord Iesus Christ, and to the Doctrine which is according to Godliness, he is proud, knowing nothing, but doating.—]
4. And if all Ministers must be receivers of new Doctrines, the Church would never know when it hath all, but would be still obeying an imperfect Law. 5. And it would be an oppression to the Church instead of a Direction, to be so overwhelmed with new Doctrines and Precepts. 6. And it would accuse Christ, the Lawgiver, of such mutability, as wise Princes are not guilty of; to be still changing or adding to his Laws. 7. There was great occasion for the New Testament or Gospel, upon the great work of our Redemption: but there is no such cause for alterations since. 8. The Priests before Christ were not to receive new Laws, as is said. 9. The Companions of the Apostles that wrought Miracles, had not all new Revelations; but did it to seal up this Gospel. 10. What need we more then actual experience, that God doth not give New Revelations to the world, and none since the Scripture times, have sealed any other by Miracles.
And thus I have proved to you the two sorts of Ministers: as Paul plainly distinguisheth them, 1 Cor. 3. 10, 11, 12. Eph 2. 20. There are Planters and Waterers, Master builders that lay the foundation, and others that build thereon: Other foundation can no man lay then that which is laid: but every man that buildeth hay or stubble and loseth his work, doth not nullify the Ministry. We are built on the foundation of the Apostles and Prophets, Jesus Christ being the head corner-stone: but we are not built on the foundation of every Pastor, Teacher, Elder, Bishop or Deacon: Though both in their places (Apostles, Prophets, Evangelists, Pastors and Teachers) are given for the perfecting of the Saints, for the work of the Ministry, for the Edifying of the body of Christ, Eph. 4. 11, 12. That we might be one united Body, having one fixed standing doctrine, ver. 14, 15, 16. And how shall we escape if we neglect so great salvation; which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed unto us by them that heard him: (mark whence the Church receiveth it) God also bearing them witness (but not every Elder or Teacher) both with signs and wonders, and with divers Miracles, and gifts of the Holy Ghost according to his own will, Heb. 2. 3, 4.
And thus I have proved to you the two sorts of Ministers: as Paul plainly distinguisheth them, 1 Cor. 3. 10, 11, 12. Eph 2. 20. There are Planters and Waterers, Master builders that lay the foundation, and others that build thereon: Other foundation can no man lay then that which is laid: but every man that buildeth hay or stuble and loseth his work, doth not nullifie the Ministry. We are built on the foundation of the Apostles and Prophets, Iesus Christ being the head corner-stone: but we are not built on the foundation of every Pastor, Teacher, Elder, Bishop or Deacon: Though both in their places (Apostles, Prophets, Evangelists, Pastors and Teachers) are given for the perfecting of the Saints, for the work of the Ministry, for the Edifying of the body of Christ, Eph. 4. 11, 12. That we might be one united Body, having one fixed standing doctrine, ver. 14, 15, 16. And how shall we escape if we neglect so great salvation; which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord, and was confirmed unto us by them that heard him: (mark whence the Church receiveth it) God also bearing them witness (but not every Elder or Teacher) both with signs and wonders, and with divers Miracles, and gifts of the Holy Ghost according to his own will,
Prop. 2. And now that these later Ministers need not prove their calling by Miracles, I prove thus: 1. God never imposed such a task upon them, nor commanded the people to require such a proof, and not to believe any but worker of Miracles. 2. God gave not all the gift of Miracles, that were employed in his work even in the Apostles days: Are all workers of Miracles? saith Paul; some had by the Spirit, the word of wisdom, and of knowledge, and others Tongues, and others Interpretation, and others Miracles, 1 Cor. 12 29, 7, 8, 9, 10. 3. They that have the Holy Ghost are owned by Christ; and so have many without working Miracles. See Rom. 8. 9. 1 Cor. 12. 3. Gal. 5. 18, 22, 23, 24. 1 Cor. 6. 11. Eph. 3. 16. & 5. 9, 18. 1 Pet. 1. 2, 22. Rom. 15. 13, 16. Tit. 3. 5. 4. The Law of Moses was kept and taught by Priests and Levites that wrought not Miracles. 5. If the Laws of all Nations may be kept without Miracles, so may the Laws of Christ. 6. If humane writings are kept without Miracles, (as Homer, Virgil, Ovid, Cicero, Livy, &c.) so may the Laws of God much more, as being the daily subject of the belief, meditation, conference, preaching, controversies, devotions of Christians through the world, and translated into so many Tongues. 7. There is nothing in the Nature of the thing that requireth ordinary Miracles. Cannot men sufficiently prove without Miracles, that there have been such men as Caesar, Pompey, Aristotle, or which be Calvins or Bellarmines writings, &c. Much more evidently may they prove what doctrine is essential to Christianity, and the Scripture that contains the whole. 8. Else Parents could not teach their children, nor bring them up in the Nurture and admonition of the Lord,
Then if Christ had done Miracles before all Jerusalem, save one man, that one man should not be bound to believe: Or if I could do miracles in this Town or Country, none must believe me ever the more but those that see it. And so you may as well say, I should not believe that there is any Sea or Land, City or Kingdom, France, Spain, Rome, &c. but what I see. Are these men worthy to be talked with? that believe no body, and confess themselves such Liars that they would have no body believe them. It was not all that saw Christs Miracles or Resurrection, or the Apostles miracles! It seems the rest were not bound to be Christians? Even as Clem: Writer told me, that no man is bound to believe that Christ did Rise again, or the rest of Christianity, that seeth not Miracles himself to prove it: adding withal, that indeed Antichrist may do Miracles; and so it seems for all the talk, miracles themselves would not serve if they saw them. 11. Is it not to put a scorn on God Almighty, to lay that the Glory of all his most miraculous ⟨p. 478⟩works should be buried to all that saw them not; and that Parents should not tell them to their Children, or Children should not believe them if they do? 12. Its injurious to Posterity, that the knowledge of the most wonderful works of God shall be only for the good of them that see them, and that all ages after shall be never the better. 13. It tends to make men mad and as Idiots, that must know and believe no more then they see: what kind of folks must these be, that know not that there is either Prince or Parliament, City or Country, or any folks in the world but those they have seen? This will stand with trading, converse, Subjection, Societies; and its doubtful whether such are capable of managing estates; or should not be put under others as Idiots? 14. Children cannot learn to read nor speak without some kind of belief of them that teach them: nor can they obey their parents nor learn any trade, nor obey Physicians: so that this conceit of incredulity is against the Nature, livelihood, and life of man. 15. And they would tie God to be at the beck of every unreasonable Infidel; that shall say, [Though all the Town have seen thy Miracles, yet I will see my self, or else I will not believe.] 16. They expect that God should overturn the course of Nature: for if Miracles be as ordinary as the operations of Nature, they are confounded.
Then if Christ had done Miracles before all Ierusalem, save one man, that one man should not be bound to believe: Or if I could do miracles in this Town or Country, none must believe me ever the more but those that see it. And so you may as well say, I should not believe that there is any Sea or Land, City or Kingdom, France, Spain, Rome, &c. but what I see. Are these men worthy to be talkt with? that believe no body, and confess themselves such Lyars that they would have no body believe them. It was not all that saw Christs Miracles or Resurrection, or the Apostles miracles! It seems the rest were not bound to be Christians? Even as Clem: Writer told me, that no man is bound to believe that Christ did Rise again, or the rest of Christianity, that seeth not Miracles himself to prove it: adding withall, that indeed Antichrist may do Miracles; and so it seems for all the talk, miracles themselves would not serve if they saw them. 11. Is it not to put a scorn on God Almighty, to lay that the Glory of all his most miraculous
17. And by this they would cross themselves, and make Miracles uneffectual: For if they were ordinary; few would be moved by them as any proof of a Divine Testimony: were it as ordinary for the Sun to go backward as forward, who would take it for a Miracle? To this Clem: Writer answers me, that [Miracles were convincing in the first Age when they were common] Answ. How common? Not as natural operations: Nor so as for all Countries or persons to see them; 500 saw Christ at once after his Resurrection: 5000. were once miraculously fed: but as this was not every days work, so what was this to others? And in that it was but for an age, and rarely in after ages, shows that they were not for every mans eyes. 18. What need we more proof then actual experience, that God doth not often now work miracles! And he that saith the Gospel, and Christian faith, and Church, and Ministry are therefore ceased, its like will not take it ill to be taken himself for an Heathen or Infidel. 19. And we have experience of millions that still do actually and steadfastly believe in Christ without Miracles: and many have laid down their lives on that belief: therefore without miracles men may believe. But to this Clem: Writer saith to me, [These believers of all sorts condemn each other as Heretics.] Answ. But not as Infidels. None but the ignorant or passionate condemn all other sorts as Heretics. The sober do not. And it is not enough to prove you a bastard, if an angry Brother call you so. 20. Because this sheet alloweth me not room, I entreat the Reader to peruse these Texts, which tell him aloud that the word and works of God must be believed by Tradition, though without Miracles, Exod. 10. 1, 2. & 12. 14, 17, 26, 27, 42. Deut. 11. 2. to the 22. & 29. 22. to 28. Josh. 4. 6, 7. & 22. 24. to 32. Psalm. 48. 13. & 78. 1. to 9. & 102. 18. & 145. 4. & 89. 1. Joel. 1. 2, 3, 4.
Proposition 3. This ordinary Ministry for teaching, ruling, and public worship, was ordained by Christ to continue till his coming, and doth yet continue, and did not cease when the extraordinary Ministry ceased. I prove it, Matth. 16. 18. Upon this Rock will I build my Church, and the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against it.] The Church never did nor can subsist without its Officers, who are an Essential part of it, as it is a Political Body, and the first and most eminent part, as it is a Community. And therefore if the Ministry be extinct, the Gates of Hell have prevailed against the Church: And then Christ is overcome, or hath broke his promise; and then he were not Christ: So that if Christ be Christ, the Church and Ministry continue. So Luke 1. 33. He shall reign over the House of Jacob for ever, and of his Kingdom there shall be no end, Isa. 9. 6, 7. Of the increase of his government and peace there shall be no end, Psalm 145. 13. Thy Kingdom is an everlasting Kingdom, and thy Dominion endureth throughout all Generations. Christ ruleth by his Officers in his Church; if Church or Ministry had an end, his Kingdom had an end, and he reigned not for ever, Matth. 28 20. Lo, I am with you alway, even to the end of the world. To this express promise, Clem. Writer hath no wiser an answer, but that, [it is conditional. If they teach men to observe all things that Christ hath commanded, then he will be with them, else not.] Repl. This is your forgery: here is no such words, but an absolute promise. His being with them, is to support and help them in his work: And will you feign Christ to promise them help on condition they do it without? The further Cavils against this Text and others, the London Ministers in their Vindication have answered at large, Eph. 4. 11, 12, 13. The Pastors and Teachers are given to the Church for the perfecting of the Saints for the work of the Ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ, till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God to a perfect man, &c.] Extraordinary and ordinary Officers are here conjoined, who between them are to perfect the building, the first laying the foundation, and the others building thereon,
I give thee charge in the sight of God— that thou keep this Commandment without spot, unrebukable, unto the appearing of our Lord Jesus Christ] which must needs extend to his Successors. The faithful and wise Stewards that give the children their meat in due season, will be found so doing by the Lord at his coming, Luke 12. 42, 43. And it is not till the last day that Christ will give up the Kingdom to the Father, 1 Cor. 15. 25. 2. The Apostles actually settled an ordinary Ministry in their time, as is proved. 3. There are Commands for settling Successors of these, as 2 Tim. 2. 2. Tit. 1. 5. as is proved. 4. These Ministers are described, and the way of their Ordination settled by Canons, 1 Tim. 3. Tit. 1. 5. We had the several Angels of the Churches in their places, Revel. 2. & 3. and promises to some of them for the future, with a Command [Hold fast till I come, 2. 23.] and ⟨p. 472⟩3. 10. [I will keep thee from the hour of temptation which shall come on all the world: Behold, I come quickly.] 6. Christ hath commanded the Ministerial work to continue to the end: As the Preaching of the Word must be to all Nations, and every Creature, Matth. 28. 19. Mark 16. 15. And these most cruel men would have all the Preachers give over their work, and leave the world to perish in Infidelity. So for the assembling of our selves together, and exhorting one another, we are commanded not to forsake it, as is the manner of some; and so much the more, as we see the day approaching, Heb. 10. 23, 24, 25. So that the nearer we are to Christs coming, the closer must we stick to Church-Communion, and holy Assemblies; considering, that its but a little while, and he that comes will come, and shall not tarry, ver. 37. God doth on purpose forbear his coming, because he is long-suffering, and will continue the means to call men to repentance, and then the day of the Lord will come suddenly,
and for our need it is Instituted till the Church be perfect, that we be not as children tossed up and down, Eph. 4. 13, 14. What enemies to us, and to the love and mercy of God are they that would persuade men, that he so quickly withdrew so great a mercy, when the gifts and calling of God are without repentance? 8. The Law and its Priesthood was not removed but by the glory of a better Law and Ministry: And Christ is the Mediator of a better Covenant and Promises, Heb. 7. 22. & 8. 7, 8. Therefore he will not deal so much worse. 9. Christ telleth us that a wise man will consider whether he can go through with it, before he build or make War: Therefore he would not himself begin to build his Church, and enter himself the Captain of our Salvation, and presently let his Enterprise fall. 10. If the Ministry continue not, then the Church continueth not; for as the Head, Liver, and Stomach, or Lungs are to the Body, so is the Ministry to the Church, 1 Cor. 12. 13, 19, 20, 28, 29. They plant and water it, 1 Cor. 3. 6. and build it, ver. 10. For how shall we believe on him of whom we have not heard? and how shall we hear without a Preacher? and hew shall they preach unless they be sent? Rom. 10. 14. But the Church doth continue: for first, else Christ were no longer the Head of it, the King, Prophet, or Priest, and so not Christ: But he is a Priest for ever, abiding continually: he continueth ever, and hath an unchangeable Priesthood; he ever liveth to make intercession for those that come to God by him, Heb. 7. 3. 22, 24, 25. 2. Those that deny the Church, must needs deny themselves Christians and Members of that Church. 3. There is no Salvation promised but to the Church, Eph. 5. 23, 25, 26, 27. Mark 16. 16
If nothing can separate us from the love of God, no not any distress or tribulation, then are not all the Ministers and Church cut off, Rom. 8. 34. to 39. Yea, those that in all Ages suffer for his sake, are not cut off from him; but so many faithful Ministers do. 8. But what should I say any more against that Assertion which carrieth stark Heathenism or Infidelity in its Forehead, reproaching Christ as no Christ, and teaching men that they are not bound to be Christians, and believe the Gospel, and persuading the world to despise Christs Messengers and Ordinances; and Ministers to cast off their Masters work; which in two words is, to turn Infidels, or Apostates. I must refer you for my fuller answer to such men, to my Book against Infidelity.
If nothing can separate us from the love of God, no not any distress or tribulation, then are not all the Ministers and Church cut off, Rom. 8. 34. to 39. Yea, those that in all Ages suffer for his sake, are not cut off from him; but so many faithful Ministers do. 8. But what should I say any more against that Assertion which carrieth stark Heathenism or Infidelity in its Forehead, reproaching Christ as no Christ, and teaching men that they are not bound to be Christians, and believe the Gospel, and perswading the world to despise Christs Messengers and Ordinances; and Ministers to cast off their Masters work; which in two words is, to turn Infidels, or Apostates. I must refer you for my fuller answer to such men, to my Book against Infidelity.
Prop. 4. God hath in his Law appointed a standing way for the calling of these ordinary Teaching, Ruling, worshipping Ministers, in all Ages; and doth himself call them in this way. 1. He instituteth the Office. 2. He commandeth that fit persons be ordained to this Office. 3. He describeth them by their necessary Qualifications. All this is at large, 1 Tim. 3. Tit. 1. Act. 20. 1 Pet. 5. &c. This is his work by his standing Law: By which also he commandeth the people to choose, consent to, or accept the fit, and to hear and obey them, Act. 14. 23. 2 Thes. 5. 12. Act. 6. 3, 5. Heb. 13. 7, 17. And then by Providence, 1. He giveth them those gifts of the Spirit that may competently qualify them for their Office. 2. He assisteth the Choosers and Ordainers to discern those Qualifications, and do their duties. 3. He causeth some special fitness of a Minister to the special Province or Charge which he is to undertake, and special inviting occasions and opportunities, and ofttimes causeth Necessity to make the choice. 4. He boweth the heart of the person called to consent, and usually to desire the work (for the right ends.) 5. And if he be called to be the Pastor of a particular Church, he moveth the people to consent or accept him. And thus God according to his appointed Order doth call his Ministers: Besides which, he afterward 1. Helps them in his work: 2. And procureth them liberty, and often furtherance from Christian Magistrates. 3. And giveth them success.
Prop. 4. God hath in his Law appointed a standing way for the calling of these ordinary Teaching, Ruling, worshipping Ministers, in all Ages; and doth himself call them in this way. 1. He instituteth the Office. 2. He commandeth that fit persons be ordained to this Office. 3. He describeth them by their necessary Qualifications. All this is at large, 1 Tim. 3.
Proposition 5. The faithful Pastors of the Reformed Churches, are these ordinary Ministers of Christ, approved by him, and given in great mercy to his people, who are bound to know▪ honour, and obey them in the Lord.
I exclude not all others, but I now prove that these are true Ministers. Argument 1. They that have all that is essential to true Ministers are true Ministers: But such are these Pastors of the Reformed Churches; as I prove thus: If the Office it self be of Gods Institution, and their Qualifications competent, and their entrance right in every point of flat Necessity, then they ⟨p. 482⟩have all that is essential to true Ministers: But the former is true, as I shall prove in the three several parts. 1. That the Office it self is of Gods appointment, is proved fully before, and confessed by all Christians that ever I knew, Acts 14. 23. 1 Tim. 3. Tit. 1. 1 Pet. 5. 1, 2. 1 Thes. 5. 12. Heb. 13. 7, 17, 24. Acts 20. 28. 2. For Qualifications, they have 1. competent Knowledge, 2. and Utterance, 3. and Godliness: and these are the Qualifications that God accepteth. 1 Cor. 12. 8. 1 Tim. 2. 15. 1 Tim. 5. 17. Mark the Canons of the Holy Ghost, 2 Tim. 2. 2. They must be 1. Faithful men, 2. Able to teach others: But such are those in question, 1 Tim. 3. A Bishop must be blameless (that is, not scandalous) the husband of one Wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach, not given to Wine, no striker, not greedy of filthy lucre, but patient, not a brawler, not covetous, one that ruleth well his own house having his children in subjection, with all gravity.] To which is added,
so that their standing justifies them before the world: Or, if any will yet deny them the necessary Qualifications, I here challenge and provoke them to accuse all that are guilty, and cast them out; or else to confess themselves mere slanderers, and back-biters, and learn more truth and modesty hereafter. 3. And for the third point, their entrance into the Office: They have all that God hath made necessary to a just entrance, as I prove: They that have a true Ordination, and the Peoples consent, and the Magistrates allowance, have all that God hath made necessary to a just entrance, and more than all: But the said Pastors of the Reformed Churches have true Ordination, and the Peoples consent, and the Magistrates allowance: That they have true Ordination, I shall show anon in answering all that can be said against it. The Peoples consent, by Electing, or Accepting, is known by the fact; and so is the Magistrates by Law and fact: I put in all this, though more than necessary, that all Objections may be satisfied at once: So that the Enumerations being unquestionable, the Conclusion is so to. In short; All those are true Ministers, that are in an Office of Gods own Institution, and are competently fitted for that Office by Knowledge, Godliness, and Utterance, and have all, and more than all that God hath made necessary to a right entrance or admission, even true Ordination, consent of the Flock, and the Magistrates allowance. But such are the said Pastors of the Reformed Churches, therefore they are true Ministers of Christ.
so that their standing justifies them before the world: Or, if any will yet deny them the necessary Qualifications, I here challenge and provoke them to accuse all that are guilty, and cast them out; or else to confess themselves meer slanderers, and back-biters, and learn more truth and modesty hereafter. 3. And for the third point, their entrance into the Office: They have all that God hath made necessary to a just entrance, as I prove: They that have a true Ordination, and the Peoples consent, and the Magistrates allowance, have all that God hath made necessary to a just entrance, and more than all: But the said Pastors of the Reformed Churches have true Ordination, and the Peoples consent, and the Magistrates allowance: That they have true Ordination, I shall shew anone in answering all that can be said against it. The Peoples consent, by Electing, or Accepting, is known by the fact; and so is the Magistrates by Law and fact: I put in all this, though more than necessary, that all Objections may be satisfied at once: So that the Enumerations being unquestionable, the Conclusion is so to. In short; All those are true Ministers, that are in an Office of Gods own Institution, and are competently fitted for that Office by Knowledge, Godliness, and Vtterance, and have all, and more than all that God hath made necessary to a right entrance or admission, even true Ordination, consent of the Flock, and the Magistrates allowance. But such are the said Pastors of the Reformed Churches, therefore they are true Ministers of Christ.
Argument 2. Those that have not only the Essentials, but excel all other Ministers on Earth (that are known to the world) are certainly the true Ministers of Christ. But such are the Ministers before-mentioned of the Reformed Churches; Ergo. This will be proved at once with the next, which is,
Argument 3. Either these Pastors of the Reformed Churches are the true Ministers of Christ, or else there are none such visible in the world: But there are such visibly and certainly in the world, as was proved; else there is no Church, no Ordinances, no Christianity, no Christ: For he can be no King without Subjects and Laws; no Master without a School and Scholars; no Physician without Patients; no Husband without his Spouse; no Head without a Body; no Intercessor without a Church to intercede for. And to believe the holy Catholic Church, and the Communion of Saints, is part of our Belief; and therefore the Christian Faith is gone, if these be gone: And that either we, or None are Christs true Ministers, I prove thus: 1. We challenge the Adversary to name us the true Church and Ministry; if these be none of them, where be they, and who are they? speak out, or give up your wicked Cause. If you know not who they be, or where, then how know you that there are any such? True Ministers are like a light that shineth to all the house, even the lights of the world, and like a City on a Hill that cannot be hid, Mat. 5. 14, 15, 16. 2. But let us try the particulars: 1. The Seekers have no Church or Ministry. 2. The Quakers have no Ordination, that we know of, and are every way so unworthy, and had no being in the world till a few years ago, that he is either no Christian, or of a crazed brain, that thinks Christ hath no Church or Ministry but them. 3. The Anabaptists, Socinians, Swenlfeldians, Familists, Paracelsians, Weigelians, and such like, have no more to show for their Ministry and Churches than we, but their Errors; and are so few, and so lately sprung up, that of them also I may say, that he that takes them for the only Church, or Ministers, is either out of the Faith, or much out of his wits. 4. The Eastern and Southern Churches have no more to show for their Ministry and Churches than we; but are incomparably more ignorant, and erroneous: few of them doing more than read their Liturgies and Homilies, and so administer the Sacraments. 5. All the Controversy therefore lieth between us and the Papists; either they are true Ministers, and a Church, or not; if not, then its left to us: if they are, then we are so much more; for we have much more unquestionable Evidence of our Title. 1.
Argument 3. Either these Pastors of the Reformed Churches are the true Ministers of Christ, or else there are none such visible in the world: But there are such visibly and certainly in the world, as was proved; else there is no Church, no Ordinances, no Christianity, no Christ: For he can be no King without Subjects and Laws; no Master without a School and Scholars; no Physitian without Patients; no Husband without his Spouse; no Head without a Body; no Intercessor without a Church to intercede for. And to believe the holy Catholick Church, and the Communion of Saints, is part of our Belief; and therefore the Christian Faith is gone, if these be gone: And that either we, or None are Christs true Ministers, I prove thus: 1. We challenge the Adversary to name us the true Church and Ministry; if these be none of them, where be they, and who are they? speak out, or give up your wicked Cause. If you know not who they be, or where, then how know you that there are any such? True Ministers are like a light that shineth to all the house, even the lights of the world, and like a City on a Hill that cannot be hid,
. Must no Parents teach their Children to know Christ, but such as can work Miracles? 9. The Doctrine which we preach is fully confirmed by Miracles already, by Christ and his Apostles: There needs no greater then Christs own Resurrection, nor more then were done; which Universal unquestionable History and Tradition hath brought down to our hands. 10. It is a ridiculous expectation, that every person should see the Miracles before they do believe.
Prop. 2. And now that these later Ministers need not prove their calling by Miracles, I prove thus: 1. God never imposed such a task upon them, nor commanded the people to require such a proof, and not to believe any but worker of Miracles. 2. God gave not all the gift of Miracles, that were employed in his work even in the Apostles daies: Are all workers of Miracles? saith Paul; some had by the Spirit, the word of wisedom, and of knowledge, and others Tongues, and others Interpretation, and others Miracles, 1 Cor. 12 29, 7, 8, 9, 10. 3. They that have the Holy Ghost are owned by Christ; and so have many without working Miracles. See Rom. 8. 9. 1 Cor. 12. 3. Gal. 5. 18, 22, 23, 24. 1 Cor. 6. 11. Eph. 3. 16. & 5. 9, 18. 1 Pet. 1. 2, 22. Rom. 15. 13, 16. Tit. 3. 5. 4. The Law of Moses was kept and taught by Priests and Levites that wrought not Miracles. 5. If the Laws of all Nations may be kept without Miracles, so may the Laws of Christ. 6. If humane writings are kept without Miracles, (as Homer, Virgil, Ovid, Cicero, Livy, &c.) so may the Laws of God much more, as being the daily subject of the belief, meditation, conference, preaching, controversies, devotions of Christians through the world, and translated into so many Tongues. 7. There is nothing in the Nature of the thing that requireth ordinary Miracles. Cannot men sufficiently prove without Miracles, that there have been such men as Caesar, Pompey, Aristotle, or which be Calvins or Bellarmines writings, &c. Much more evidently may they prove what doctrine is essential to Christianity, and the Scripture that contains the whole. 8. Else Parents could not teach their children, nor bring them up in the Nurture and admonition of the Lord, Eph. 6. 4. Nor teach them with Timothy, from a child to know the Scriptures, which are able to make men wise to salvation through faith in Christ, 2. Tim. 3. 15. Must no Parents teach their Children to know Christ, but such as can work Miracles? 9. The Doctrine which we preach is fully confirmed by Miracles already, by Christ and his Apostles: There needs no greater then Christs own Resurrection, nor more then were done; which Universal unquestionable History and Tradition hath brought down to our hands. 10. It is a ridiculous expectation, that every person should see the Miracles before they do believe.
⟨p. 478⟩
works should be buried to all that saw them not; and that Parents should not tell them to their Children, or Children should not believe them if they do? 12. Its injurious to Posterity, that the knowledge of the most wonderful works of God shall be only for the good of them that see them, and that all ages after shall be never the better. 13. It tends to make men mad and as Ideots, that must know and believe no more then they see: what kind of folks must these be, that know not that there is either Prince or Parliament, City or Countrey, or any folks in the world but those they have seen? This will stand with trading, converse, Subjection, Societies; and its doubtful whether such are capable of managing estates; or should not be put under others as Ideots? 14. Children cannot learn to read nor speak without some kind of belief of them that teach them: nor can they obey their parents nor learn any trade, nor obey Physitians: so that this conceit of incredulity is against the Nature, livelihood, and life of man. 15. And they would tie God to be at the beck of every unreasonable Infidel; that shall say, [Though all the Town have seen thy Miracles, yet I will see my self, or else I will not believe.] 16. They expect that God should overturn the course of Nature: for if Miracles be as ordinary as the operations of Nature, they are confounded.
30, 31. & 1. 22. & 4. 33. & 22. 15. & 26. 16. & 23. 11. 2 Tim. 2. 2. John 20. 29. & 19. 35. & 15. 27. & 12. 17. & 5. 33. & 1. 15, 32, 34 Luke 4. 22. 1 Pet. 5. 1. And that you would read my Determination of this very Question in my Book against Infidelity: I proceed to the next.
17. And by this they would cross themselves, and make Miracles uneffectual: For if they were ordinary; few would be moved by them as any proof of a Divine Testimony: were it as ordinary for the Sun to go backward as forward, who would take it for a Miracle? To this Clem: Writer answers me, that [Miracles were convincing in the first Age when they were common] Answ. How common? Not as natural operations: Nor so as for all Countreys or persons to see them; 500 saw Christ at once after his Resurrection: 5000. were once miraculously fed: but as this was not every days work, so what was this to others? And in that it was but for an age, and rarely in after ages, shews that they were not for every mans eyes. 18. What need we more proof then actual experience, that God doth not often now work miracles! And he that saith the Gospel, and Christian faith, and Church, and Ministry are therefore ceased, its like will not take it ill to be taken himself for an Heathen or Infidel. 19. And we have experience of millions that still do actually and stedfastly believe in Christ without Miracles: and many have laid down their lives on that belief: therefore without miracles men may believe. But to this Clem: Writer saith to me, [These believers of all sorts condemn each other as Hereticks.] Answ. But not as Infidels. None but the ignorant or passionate condemn all other sorts as Hereticks. The sober do not. And it is not enough to prove you a bastard, if an angry Brother call you so. 20. Because this sheet alloweth me not room, I intreat the Reader to peruse these Texts, which tell him aloud that the word and works of God must be believed by Tradition, though without Miracles, Exod. 10. 1, 2. & 12. 14, 17, 26, 27, 42. Deut. 11. 2. to the 22. & 29. 22. to 28. Iosh. 4. 6, 7. & 22. 24. to 32. Psalm. 48. 13. & 78. 1. to 9. & 102. 18. & 145. 4. & 89. 1. Ioel. 1. 2, 3, 4. Acts 1. 8. & 2. 32. & 5. 30, 31, 32. & 10. 38. to 42. & 13. ⟨p. 479⟩30, 31. & 1. 22. & 4. 33. & 22. 15. & 26. 16. & 23. 11. 2 Tim. 2. 2. Iohn 20. 29. & 19. 35. & 15. 27. & 12. 17. & 5. 33. & 1. 15, 32, 34 Luke 4. 22. 1 Pet. 5. 1. And that you would read my Determination of this very Question in my Book against Infidelity: I proceed to the next.
Proposition 3. This ordinary Ministry for teaching, ruling, and publick worship, was ordained by Christ to continue till his coming, and doth yet continue, and did not cease when the extraordinary Ministry ceased. I prove it, Matth. 16. 18. Vpon this Rock will I build my Church, and the Gates of Hell shall not prevail against it.] The Church never did nor can subsist without its Officers, who are an Essential part of it, as it is a Political Body, and the first and most eminent part, as it is a Community. And therefore if the Ministry be extinct, the Gates of Hell have prevailed against the Church: And then Christ is overcome, or hath broke his promise; and then he were not Christ: So that if Christ be Christ, the Church and Ministry continue. So Luke 1. 33. He shall reign over the House of Jacob for ever, and of his Kingdome there shall be no end, Isa. 9. 6, 7. Of the encrease of his government and peace there shall be no end, Psalm 145. 13. Thy Kingdome is an everlasting Kingdome, and thy Dominion endureth throughout all Generations. Christ ruleth by his Officers in his Church; if Church or Ministry had an end, his Kingdome had an end, and he reigned not for ever, Matth. 28 20. Loe, I am with you alway, even to the end of the world. To this express promise, Clem. Writer hath no wiser an answer, but that, [it is conditional. If they teach men to observe all things that Christ hath commanded, then he will be with them, else not.] Repl. This is your forgery: here is no such words, but an absolute promise. His being with them, is to support and help them in his work: And will you feign Christ to promise them help on condition they do it without? The further Cavils against this Text and others, the London Ministers in their Vindication have answered at large, Eph. 4. 11, 12, 13. The Past•rs and Teachers are given to the Church for the perfecting of the Saints for the work of the Ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ, till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God to a perfect man, &c.] Extraordinary and ordinary Officers are here conjoyned, who between them are to perfect the building, the first laying the foundation, and the others building thereon, 1 Tim. 6. 13, 14.
. And if the work continue, the workmen must continue. 7. The mercy of God, and the Efficacy of Christs Blood, and the necessities of the Church continue: we still need a Teaching Ministry,
I give thee charge in the sight of God— that thou keep this Commandment without spot, unrebukable, unto the appearing of our Lord Iesus Christ] which must needs extend to his Successors. The faithful and wise Stewards that give the children their meat in due season, will be found so doing by the Lord at his coming, Luke 12. 42, 43. And it is not till the last day that Christ will give up the Kingdome to the Father, 1 Cor. 15. 25. 2. The Apostles actually setled an ordinary Ministry in their time, as is proved. 3. There are Commands for setling Successors of these, as 2 Tim. 2. 2. Tit. 1. 5. as is proved. 4. These Ministers are described, and the way of their Ordination setled by Canons, 1 Tim. 3. Tit. 1. 5. We had the several Angels of the Churches in their places, Revel. 2. & 3. and promises to some of them for the future, with a Command [Hold fast till I come, 2. 23.] and ⟨p. 472⟩3. 10. [I will keep thee from the hour of temptation which shall come on all the world: Behold, I come quickly.] 6. Christ hath commanded the Ministerial work to continue to the end: As the Preaching of the Word must be to all Nations, and every Creature, Matth. 28. 19. Mark 16. 15. And these most cruel men would have all the Preachers give over their work, and leave the world to perish in Infidelity. So for the assembling of our selves together, and exhorting one another, we are commanded not to forsake it, as is the manner of some; and so much the more, as we see the day approaching, Heb. 10. 23, 24, 25. So that the nearer we are to Christs coming, the closer must we stick to Church-Communion, and holy Assemblies; considering, that its but a little while, and he that comes will come, and shall not tarry, ver. 37. God doth on purpose forbear his coming, because he is long-suffering, and will continue the means to call men to repentance, and then the day of the Lord will come suddenly, 2 Pet. 3. 9, 10. [The Word of the Lord endureth for ever: and this is the word which by the Gospel is preached to you, 1 Pet. 1. 25. The Lords Supper is Instituted to be used to shew the Lords death till he come, 1 Cor. 11. 26. Church-government or Discipline is a fixed Ordinance, Mat. 18. 15, 16, 17. And if the work continue, the workmen must continue. 7. The mercy of God, and the Efficacy of Christs Blood, and the necessities of the Church continue: we still need a Teaching Ministry, Heb. 5. 11.
. 4. Blindness is on the Jews but till the fullness of the Gentiles be come in, and so all Israel shall be saved: Therefore it is most evident that the Gentile Church shall not cease
⟨p. 481⟩
till the fullness have prepared for the re-engrafting of the Jews, Rom. 11. 25, 26. 5. It is an everlasting Kingdom, which cannot be moved, and the City of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem, whereof even the Angels and perfected Spirits of the Just are a part, to which we come by Faith: therefore it ceaseth not, Heb. 12. 22, 23, 28. 6. When that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away, 1 Cor. 13. 10. but not before. 7.
and for our need it is Instituted till the Church be perfect, that we be not as children toss'd up and down, Eph. 4. 13, 14. What enemies to us, and to the love and mercy of God are they that would perswade men, that he so quickly withdrew so great a mercy, when the gifts and calling of God are without repentance? 8. The Law and its Priesthood was not removed but by the glory of a better Law and Ministry: And Christ is the Mediator of a better Covenant and Promises, Heb. 7. 22. & 8. 7, 8. Therefore he will not deal so much worse. 9. Christ telleth us that a wise man will consider whether he can go through with it, before he build or make War: Therefore he would not himself begin to build his Church, and enter himself the Captain of our Salvation, and presently let his Enterprize fall. 10. If the Ministry continue not, then the Church continueth not; for as the Head, Liver, and Stomack, or Lungs are to the Body, so is the Ministry to the Church, 1 Cor. 12. 13, 19, 20, 28, 29. They plant and water it, 1 Cor. 3. 6. and build it, ver. 10. For how shall we believe on him of whom we have not heard? and how shall we hear without a Preacher? and hew shall they preach unless they be sent? Rom. 10. 14. But the Church doth continue: for first, else Christ were no longer the Head of it, the King, Prophet, or Priest, and so not Christ: But he is a Priest for ever, abiding continually: he continueth ever, and hath an unchangeable Priesthood; he ever liveth to make intercession for those that come to God by him, Heb. 7. 3. 22, 24, 25. 2. Those that deny the Church, must needs deny themselves Christians and Members of that Church. 3. There is no Salvation promised but to the Church, Eph. 5. 23, 25, 26, 27. Mark 16. 16. 4. Blindness is on the Jews but till the fulness of the Gentiles be come in, and so all Israel shall be saved: Therefore it is most evident that the Gentile Church shall not cease ⟨p. 481⟩till the fulness have prepared for the re-ingraffing of the Iews, Rom. 11. 25, 26. 5. It is an everlasting Kingdome, which cannot be moved, and the City of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem, whereof even the Angels and perfected Spirits of the Iust are a part, to which we come by Faith: therefore it ceaseth not, Heb. 12. 22, 23, 28. 6. When that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away, 1 Cor. 13. 10. but not before. 7.
. And then by Providence, 1. He giveth them those gifts of the Spirit that may competently qualifie them for their Office. 2. He assisteth the Chusers and Ordainers to discern those Qualifications, and do their duties. 3. He causeth some special fitness of a Minister to the special Province or Charge which he is to undertake, and special inviting occasions and opportunities, and ofttimes causeth Necessity to make the choice. 4. He boweth the heart of the person called to consent, and usually to desire the work (for the right ends.) 5. And if he be called to be the Pastor of a particular Church, he moveth the people to consent or accept him. And thus God according to his appointed Order doth call his Ministers: Besides which, he afterward 1. Helps them in his work: 2. And procureth them liberty, and often furtherance from Christian Magistrates. 3. And giveth them success.
. A lover of good men, sober, just, holy temperate, holding fast the faithful word as he hath been taught, that he may be able by sound Doctrine both to exhort, and to convince the gain-sayers.] Let all here note: 1. That here is not only the mention of the Virtues necessary to the Being, but to the well-being also of a Minister: 2. And yet through the great mercy of God, all these are the qualifications of multitudes of the Pastors of the Reformed Churches, as malice it self must be forced to confess: But if any deny it of any particular men, as that is nothing to the rest; so an unproved accusation is not by honest men to be believed. The world knows that the Act for rejecting scandalous, insufficient, negligent Ministers is very strict, and Commissioners in each County forward to execute it, and Ministers have enemies enough to search out their faults, and yet none are more forward than Ministers themselves to have the Act put in execution;
I exclude not all others, but I now prove that these are true Ministers. Argument 1. They that have all that is essential to true Ministers are true Ministers: But such are these Pastors of the Reformed Churches; as I prove thus: If the Office it self be of Gods Institution, and their Qualifications competent, and their entrance right in every point of flat Necessity, then they ⟨p. 482⟩have all that is essential to true Ministers: But the former is true, as I shall prove in the three several parts. 1. That the Office it self is of Gods appointment, is proved fully before, and confessed by all Christians that ever I knew, Acts 14. 23. 1 Tim. 3. Tit. 1. 1 Pet. 5. 1, 2. 1 Thes. 5. 12. Heb. 13. 7, 17, 24. Acts 20. 28. 2. For Qualifications, they have 1. competent Knowledge, 2. and Vtterance, 3. and Godliness: and these are the Qualifications that God accepteth. 1 Cor. 12. 8. 1 Tim. 2. 15. 1 Tim. 5. 17. Mark the Canons of the Holy Ghost, 2 Tim. 2. 2. They must be 1. Faithful men, 2. Able to teach others: But such are those in question, 1 Tim. 3. A Bishop must be blameless (that is, not scandalous) the husband of one Wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach, not given to Wine, no striker, not greedy of filthy lucre, but patient, not a brawler, not covetous, one that ruleth well his own house having his children in subjection, with all gravity.] To which is added, Tit. 1. 8, 9. A lover of good men, sober, just, holy temperate, holding fast the faithful word as he hath been taught, that he may be able by sound Doctrine both to exhort, and to convince the gain-sayers.] Let all here note: 1. That here is not only the mention of the Vertues necessary to the Being, but to the well-being also of a Minister: 2. And yet through the great mercy of God, all these are the qualifications of multitudes of the Pastors of the Reformed Churches, as malice it self must be forced to confess: But if any deny it of any particular men, as that is nothing to the rest; so an unproved accusation is not by honest men to be believed. The world knows that the Act for rejecting scandalous, insufficient, negligent Ministers is very strict, and Commissioners in each County forward to execute it, and Ministers have enemies enough to search out their faults, and yet none are more forward than Ministers themselves to have the Act put in execution;
. 2. But let us try the particulars: 1. The Seekers have no Church or Ministry. 2. The Quakers have no Ordination, that we know of, and are every way so unworthy, and had no being in the world till a few years ago, that he is either no Christian, or of a crazed brain, that thinks Christ hath no Church or Ministry but them. 3. The Anabaptists, Socinians, Swenlfeldians, Familists, Paracelsians, Weigelians, and such like, have no more to shew for their Ministry and Churches than we, but their Errours; and are so few, and so lately sprung up, that of them also I may say, that he that takes them for the only Church, or Ministers, is either out of the Faith, or much out of his wits. 4. The Eastern and Southern Churches have no more to shew for their Ministry and Churches than we; but are incomparably more ignorant, and erroneous: few of them doing more than read their Liturgies and Homilies, and so administer the Sacraments. 5. All the Controversie therefore lieth between us and the Papists; either they are true Ministers, and a Church, or not; if not, then its left to us: if they are, then we are so much more; for we have much more unquestionable Evidence of our Title. 1.