§. 33. But I must here tell the Reader, that I mention not these instances to breed ill thoughts in him of these African and Numidian Bishops: For as far as I can discern by their Writings and by History, they were the Godliest, Faithful, Peaceable company of Bishops that were found in any part of the World since the Apostles times: Cyprian's style and the testimony of all just History which concerneth him, as well as his Martyrdom, declare him to be a Saint indeed. (Nazianzen declareth the strange occasion of his Conversion; viz. That he loved or lusted after a Christian Virgin, and when he could not obtain his will, being given to Magic, he agreed with the Devil to procure his desire; but when he saw that the Devil confessed himself unable to do it, and so that he was too weak for Christ, he forsook the Devil and turned Christian:) The Papists (Binnius, Baronius, &c.) conjecture that Cyprian before his death reformed this Error, but their conjecture merely tells us what they wish, without any reason, but that he dyed a Martyr and his Successors honoured him. As if none might so die and be honoured that had any error, which no man living is without. 2. And this may be said to excuse their error. 1. That the strictest men oftener err on the stricter side against sin, than the complying Carnal Clergy. 2. That they thought it the safer way to baptize such again, (on the same reason as we do in case of uncertain baptism, with a si non baptizatus es, baptizo te;) not knowing why there should be any danger in the mistake: Much like as in England now, the Bishops are for the re-Ordaining of all such as were Ordained by others that were not Diocesans, and yet do not call it re-Ordaining. 3. That in those times of Heathenism and persecution, the Christians had no way to maintain their strength but by the Churches Concord; nor could they otherwise have kept up so strict a discipline as they did, having no forcing power of Christian•Magistrates: Therefore they were necessitated to be severe with dividers. 4. And the ambiguity of the word [Heresy] was not the least occasion of their error. The Nicene Council afterward rebaptized such as those Heretics ⟨p. 38⟩Baptized, who corrupted the substance of baptism it self, but not others. And Christians at first had more wit and charity than to call every error a Heresy, (else there had been none but Heretics:)
§. 33. But I must here tell the Reader, that I mention not these instances to breed ill thoughts in him of these African and Numidian Bishops: For as far as I can discern by their Writings and by History, they were the Godliest, Faithful, Peaceable company of Bishops that were found in any part of the World since the Apostles times: Cyprian's style and the testimony of all just History which concerneth him, as well as his Martyrdome, declare him to be a Saint indeed. (Nazianzen declareth the strange occasion of his Conversion; viz. That he loved or lusted after a Christian Virgin, and when he could not obtain his will, being given to Magick, he agreed with the Devil to procure his desire; but when he saw that the Devil confest himself unable to do it, and so that he was too weak for Christ, he forsook the Devil and turned Christian:) The Papists (Binnius, Baronius, &c.) conjecture that Cyprian before his death reformed this Errour, but their conjecture meerly tells us what they wish, without any reason, but that he dyed a Martyr and his Successours honoured him. As if none might so die and be honoured that had any errour, which no man living is without. 2. And this may be said to excuse their errour. 1. That the strictest men oftner erre on the stricter side against sin, than the complying Carnal Clergy. 2. That they thought it the safer way to baptize such again, (on the same reason as we do in case of uncertain baptisme, with a si non baptizatus es, baptizo te;) not knowing why there should be any danger in the mistake: Much like as in England now, the Bishops are for the re-Ordaining of all such as were Ordained by others that were not Diocesanes, and yet do not call it re-Ordaining. 3. That in those times of Heathenisme and persecution, the Christians had no way to maintain their strength but by the Churches Concord; nor could they otherwise have kept up so strict a discipline as they did, having no forcing power of Christian•Magistrates: Therefore they were necessitated to be severe with dividers. 4. And the ambiguity of the word [Heresie] was not the least occasion of their errour. The Nicene Council afterward rebaptized such as those Hereticks ⟨p. 38⟩Baptized, who corrupted the substance of baptisme it self, but not others. And Christians at first had more wit and charity than to call every errour a Heresie, (else there had been none but Hereticks:)