§. 44. I have heard many Popish Persons liken the Separatists among us to the Donatists: But so unlike them are they, That, 1. The said Separatists are against all Episcopacy, but the Donatists were Bishops, and contended for the highest Places of Prelacy. 2. The Separatists are confessedly a Minor Part departing from the Major Part. But the Donatists were the Major Part of the Bishops casting out the Minor Part as Delinquents. The Truth is, in those times the Bishops being usually in contention and Church-Wars among themselves, (especially when Constantine had given them peace and prosperity,) the strife was, Who should get the better, and have their will: 1. Sometime the strife was about Opinions, who was in the right, and to be called Orthodox, and who was to be accounted the Heretic. 2. The other part quarrel who should be the Bishop, or who should have the highest places. 3. And the next quarrel was whose side should carry it in setting up any Bishops, or in judging and deposing them, and who should have their Heads or Friends brought in. And the way to get the better, was, 1. At the first, by the majority of the peoples Votes in choosing Bishops, and of the Bishops in deposing them. 2. But after, most went in choosing and deposing by the majority of the Bishops Votes in the greater Seats, (the peoples consent still required,) at least if a Council did interpose. 3. And at last, it went by the favour or displeasure of the Court; either the Emperor, or the Empress, or some great Officers. The African Bishops it seems were far the greatest number against Caecilian, (when 270 met at one Council, and M•lchiades Council at Rome had but 19, and that at Illiberis 19, and that at Ancyra 18 Bishops.) Therefore the Bishops thought that majority of number gave them right to the Title of Catholick•, ⟨p. 41⟩that those Dissenter• must be called Heretics, as was too usual. And seeing they lived in the Country where many Councils under Agrippinus and Cyprian, 1and Firmilian, had voted that Heretics were not of the Church, and those that they had baptized, were to be rebaptized; they thought that they did but keep up this Tradition; and so they said that they were all the Church of Africa, and that the Cecilians were Heretics and Separatists from the Church, and that all that they baptized were to be rebaptized, as was formerly held.
§. 44. I have heard many Popish Persons liken the Separatists among us to the Donatists: But so unlike them are they, That, 1. The said Separatists are against all Episcopacy, but the Donatists were Bishops, and contended for the highest Places of Prelacy. 2. The Separatists are confessedly a Minor Part departing from the Major Part. But the Donatists were the Major Part of the Bishops casting out the Minor Part as Delinquents. The Truth is, in those times the Bishops being usually in contention and Church-Wars among themselves, (especially when Constantine had given them peace and prosperity,) the strife was, Who should get the better, and have their will: 1. Sometime the strife was about Opinions, who was in the right, and to be called Orthodox, and who was to be accounted the Heretick. 2. The other part quarrel who should be the Bishop, or who should have the highest places. 3. And the next quarrel was whose side should carry it in setting up any Bishops, or in judging and deposing them, and who should have their Heads or Friends brought in. And the way to get the better, was, 1. At the first, by the majority of the peoples Votes in chusing Bishops, and of the Bishops in deposing them. 2. But after, most went in chusing and deposing by the majority of the Bishops Votes in the greater Seats, (the peoples consent still required,) at least if a Council did interpose. 3. And at last, it went by the favour or displeasure of the Court; either the Emperour, or the Empress, or some great Officers. The African Bishops it seems were far the greatest number against Caecilian, (when 270 met at one Council, and M•lchiades Council at Rome had but 19, and that at Illiberis 19, and that at Ancyra 18 Bishops.) Therefore the Bishops thought that majority of number gave them right to the Title of Catholick•, ⟨p. 41⟩that those Dissenter• must be called Hereticks, as was too usual. And seeing they lived in the Country where many Councils under Agrippinus and Cyprian, 1and Firmilian, had voted that Hereticks were not of the Church, and those that they had baptized, were to be rebaptized; they thought that they did but keep up this Tradition; and so they said that they were all the Church of Africa, and that the Cecilians were Hereticks and Separatists from the Church, and that all that they baptized were to be rebaptized, as was formerly held.
- 1And no General Council had judged against them, for there had been none.