A26898:563
Church-history of the government of bishops and their councils abbreviated including the chief part…
Church-history of the government of bishops and their councils abbreviated including the chief part of the government of Christian princes and popes, and a true account of the most troubling controversies and heresies till the Reformation ... / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by B. Griffin for Thomas Simmons, 1680
Church-History OF BISHOPS And their COUNCILS ABRIDGED, &c. › Chapter 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§. 2. Reader, It is useful to thee, to know truly the state of this Tragical Controversy, which had more dividing and direful effects than the former. The Eutychians say, that Christ before their Union by incarnation had two natures, 1that is, considered mentally, as not united; but after the union had but one nature. They took up this as against Nestorianism. The truth is, Though they still go for desperate Heretics, I verily believe that all the quarrel was but about ambiguous words: some of them understood the word [Nature] in the same sense as their Adversaries took the word [Hypostasis] or [Person.] And (it's sad that it should be true, but) most of them confounded [Unity undistinguished] and [Uniting undivided.] The Eutychians thought, How can that be called Unity which maketh not one of two? And no doubt the Natures are One; But One what? Not One Nature, but One Person; Yet (to bring off Cyril) it may be said that even the Natures are One, in opposition to Division or Separation, but not One in opposition to distinction. He that had but distinguished these two clearly to them, and explained the word [Nature] clearly, had better ended all the Controversy than it was ended. It's plain that Cyril and the Eutychians allowed mental distinction, though not that the Mind should suppose them divided: And it's certain that the Orthodox meant no more.
§. 2. Reader, It is useful to thee, to know truly the state of this Tragical Controversie, which had more dividing and direful effects than the former. The Eutychians say, that Christ before their Vnion by incarnation had two natures, 1that is, considered mentally, as not united; but after the union had but one nature. They took up this as against Nestorianisme. The truth is, Though they still go for desperate Hereticks, I verily believe that all the quarrel was but about ambiguous words: some of them understood the word [Nature] in the same sense as their Adversaries took the word [Hypostasis] or [Person.] And (it's sad that it should be true, but) most of them confounded [Vnity undistinguished] and [Vniting undivided.] The Eutychians thought, How can that be called Vnity which maketh not one of two? And no doubt the Natures are One; But One what? Not One Nature, but One Person; Yet (to bring off Cyril) it may be said that even the Natures are One, in opposition to Division or Separation, but not One in opposition to distinction. He that had but distinguished these two clearly to them, and explained the word [Nature] clearly, had better ended all the Controversie than it was ended. It's plain that Cyril and the Eutychians allowed mental distinction, though not that the Mind should suppose them divided: And it's certain that the Orthodox meant no more.