A26911:34
The defence of the nonconformists plea for peace, or, An account of the matter…
The defence of the nonconformists plea for peace, or, An account of the matter of their nonconformity against Mr. J. Cheney's answer called The conforming nonconformist, and The nonconforming conformist : to which is added the second part in answer to Mr. Cheney's Five undertakings / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Benjamin Alsop, 1680
A DEFENCE OF THE NON-CONFORMIST'S Plea for Peace, AGAINST Mr. J. CH… › Chapter 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§ 2. Had you heard as great a Man as I have done, declare that he could not take them for Ministers, or take the Sacrament of them that had not Episcopal Ordination; and had you heard my L. Chancellor Hide give such Reasons openly for Reordination as I did; and had you seen the Writings of so Learned a Bishop as I have seen, to prove such no Ministers as are Ordained but by Presbyters, and heard such Men, and so many Argue for it as I have done, you could not have thought that the judgment of those that impose Reordination, was, or is, that Men are true Ministers of Christ that are Ordained by Presbyters only? So that your sense of the Imposition is feigned.
§ 3. It is a known thing that the Church of England is not of your singular opinion for Reordination: You may as well feign them to be for Rebaptizing: They all renounce it with our Consent: Therefore they that require Men to be Ordained by Bishops, must needs hold that they had no true Ordination before; or else they should be for that which they abhor. So that it's past doubt, you talk of you know not what, when you make this to be but the singular Opinion of one Mr. Dodwel, disowned by all; though much in his Book besides, be by most disowned: And it is not every later Bishop that made the Law, or altered the Liturgy,
§ 4. You say that [ Ordination once validly done by eminent Presbyters, and grave substantial ⟨p. 8⟩Ministers, it doth to all intents and purposes make him a complete Minister. ] And elsewhere you maintain the Validity of Presbyters Ordination: and say, That it is a taking God's Name in vain, when it is done without urgent Reasons.] I have moved to you, that the present Imposers suppose the contrary, (and I think, considering how much the King and Parliament left to the judgment of the Convocation) the present Settlement proveth what was the Convocations judgment, who are the present Church of England's representative.) They that are against Reordaining, and yet call men to be ordained, certainly judge them unordained before: And you are to take your Ordination, and speak the words in the known sense of the Imposers; or else you equivocate: And what Reasons have you to deceive them? At least it is notorious scandal to seem to do it in an ill sense. And when you pretend that your Ministry else must be forsaken, we say, No: It is but to save you from suffering for your Ministration, as long as you can use it on suffering terms: And you have not escaped suffering, nor saved your Ministry by Conforming. If you would rather suffer, than not Preach to Non-Conformists when you had an allowed Church of Conformists, should not we rather suffer than by our Reordination submit to that which is the Churches or Laws public professing that we were no Ordained Ministers of Christ before? when after that we have never the more liberty for our Ministry, unless we conform to all the rest. I remember three Worthy men reordained one fourteen, and two seventeen years ago, that had never the more liberty to Preach.