A26923:1170
An end of doctrinal controversies which have lately troubled the churches
An end of doctrinal controversies which have lately troubled the churches by reconciling explication without much disputing. Written by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for John Salusbury, 1691
Chapter 26: Of Confirmation, Perseverance, and Danger of falling away.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§. 13. Q. VI. Whether it be possible to lose that Holiness which never will be lost?
Ans. The word [Possible] respecteth either a Consequence in Arguing, and is a Logical Possibility; or it respecteth the natural power of Causes, and is called, Physical Possibility. In the first sense it is impossible that any thing should come to pass that doth not; because God knoweth it will not: And it is a good consequence, God knoweth that this will not come to pass; therefore it will not: And it is impossible that this Consequence should be false.
Ans. The word [Possible] respecteth either a Consequence in Arguing, and is a Logical Possibility; or it respecteth the natural power of Causes, and is called, Physical Possibility. In the first sence it is impossible that any thing should come to pass that doth not; because God knoweth it will not: And it is a good consequence, God knoweth that this will not come to pass; therefore it will not: And it is impossible that this Consequence should be false.
But as to the natural Possibility, no doubt but ⟨p. 307⟩of our▪ selves we can sin; nay, it is not an act o• Power, but of Impotency, or from a defect of Power: And the Habit given us is not a sufficient Power to ascertain our Perseverance of it self. But if you speak with respect to the Power of God, by which we are preserved, we must thus answer: That it is impossible for us or any Creature to overcome God's Power or Will: And if it be first proved, that God will cause us to persevere by the way of Physical irresistible determination by Power, then it must be called Impossible to fall away, or commit any Sin which he so saveth us from. But if he keep any as a free Agent by the sapiential disposal of his Free-will, and so procure the event of a contingent action, then it must be said, that this and many things are possible which never come to pass, That God only decreeth, that we shall not fall away, and not, that it shall be impossible: Thus Dr. Twice and the Dominicans themselves use to speak: But for my part I ake God's manner of working on and for us, to be so unsearchable, and this notion of Possibility or Impossibility, of so little moment when we are agreed what will be the event, that I think the Controversy not worth the handling, but made among other snares of Satan, to trouble the Church, and draw us to vain Janglings about words that edify not, from the Simplicity that is in Christ.