An end of doctrinal controversies which have lately troubled the churches
An end of doctrinal controversies which have lately troubled the churches by reconciling explication without much disputing. Written by Richard Baxter.
Richard Baxter 1615–1691London: printed for John Salusbury, 1691
[14], xxxiv, 320 p. · 102k words · Wing B1258AA · ESTC R2853
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sect. I. Experience assuring all Men, that we are born without actual Knowledge, and yet with Faculties made to Know, obliged to Learn, desiring Knowledge, needing it, and delighting in it, •o wonder if Men be inquisitive after the surest •nd easiest way to attain it; and if they be unwilling to be deceived, no wonder they love Truth as Truth, and hate Lies as Lies; though, being deceived, they hate that which is Truth, and love that which is a Lye.
Sect. I. EXperience assuring all Men, that we are born without actual Knowledg, and yet with Faculties made to Know, obliged to Learn, desi•ing Knowledg, needing it, and delighting in it, •o wonder if Men be inquisitive after the surest •nd easiest way to attain it; and if they be unwil•ing to be deceived, no wonder they love Truth as Truth, and hate Lyes as Lyes; though, being de•eived, they hate that which is Truth, and love that which is a Lye.
§. 2. Therefore the first Apprehensions of the mind do greatly tend to the introduction of those that follow, to make them such as shall agree with these: And here, 1. Sense, and 2. Education have the great advantage. 1. We exercise Sense before Reason, and therefore, at first, without the government of our own Reason, and this necessarily, strongly, and constantly, as the Brutes do. 2. And being therefore governed by the Reason of our Parents, we learn Knowledge of them, and from sensible Objects, •ut drop by drop, by slow degrees; and Sense being strong, inclineth Children strongly to desire ⟨p. 2⟩that sort of Knowledge, which will most serve the pleasure of Sense and Fleshly Appetite: And so they easily learn how to sport, and after how to seek Pro••ssion (by Labour and Trades, and Fla• terry▪ […].) t• satisfy the Desires of the Flesh. But the […]dg of things spiritual and everlasting which are beyond the reach of Sight and all the Se ses, cometh not in so soon▪ nor till Parents o• other Teachers tell them of such, or Reason grow up to maturity, by Experience and serious Exercise, and withal, the Grace of God to bless such Help•, and overcome the contrary fleshly inclinations, which original Pravity and customary Sensuality, raise up against the Desires of, Endeavours for, and Obedience to a spiritual and more excellent Knowledge. Where God giveth, 1. A Body moderately temperated as to Sensuality and Ingenuity; 2. And Parents, or first-Teachers, wise and faithful, to teach Children that spiritual Knowledge which they have learn• themselves; and, 3. by His Grace exciteth Children's Minds to love, learn, and obey the Truth, there enter the beginnings of truest Wisdom: But where these are wanting, they grow up, instead of saving Wisdom, to the craftiness of a Fo•, to get, keep, and devour his Prey, and to the valour and felicity of the Mastiff, to be Master of the little Dogs; and at last, to the subtlety of Devils, to oppose and destroy as a hated thing the Holy Wisdom and Practice that should have saved them.
§. 2. Therefore the first Apprehensions of the mind do greatly tend to the introduction of those that follow, to make them such as shall agree with these: And here, 1. Sense, and 2. Education have the great advantage. 1. We exercise Sense before Reason, and therefore, at first, without the government of our own Reason, and this necessarily, strongly, and constantly, as the Bruites do. 2. And being therefore governed by the Reason of our Parents, we learn Knowledg of them, and from sensible Objects, •ut drop by drop, by slow degrees; and Sense being strong, inclineth Children strongly to desire ⟨p. 2⟩that sort of Knowledg, which will most serve the pleasure of Sence and Fleshly Appetite: And so they easily learn how to sport, and after how to seek Pro••ssion (by Labour and Trades, and Fla• tery▪〈…〉.) t• s•tisfi the Desires of the Flesh. But the 〈…〉dg of things spiritual and everlastin• which are beyond the reach of Sight and all the Se ses, cometh not in so soon▪ nor till Parents o• other Teachers tell them of such, or Reason grow up to m•turity, by Experience and serious Exercise, and withal, the Grace of God to bless such Help•, and overcome the contrary fleshly inclinations, which original Pravity and customary Sensuality, raise up against the Desires of, Endeavours for, and Obedience to a spiritual and more excellent Knowledg. Where God giveth, 1. A Body moderately temperated as to Sensuality and Ingenuity; 2. And Parents, or first-Teachers, wise and faithful, to teach Children that spiritual Knowledg which they have learn• themselves; and, 3. by His Grace exciteth Childrens Minds to love, learn, and obey the Truth, there enter the beginnings of truest Wisdom: But where these are wanting, they grow up, instead of saving Wisdom, to the craftiness of a Fo•, to get, keep, and devour his Prey, and to the valour and felicity of the Mastisse, to be Master of the little Dogs; and at last, to the subtilty of Devils, to oppose and destroy as a hated thing the Holy Wisdom and Practice that should have saved them.
§. 3. As Knowledge cometh in by slow degree•▪ so there are as many degrees or differences of it, in the World, as there are Men; it being not probable that any two men on Earth have just the same apprehensions and degrees of Knowledge; but that ⟨p. 3⟩all mens mental Complexions differ far more than their Visages do. So that if the same degree were •he measure of necessary Church-Concord, and •alvation, there should but one in the World be ••e Church or be saved. The question then is not, What measure is desirable, but what is necessary to Church-Unity and Communion, and to Salvation. And what God will do with those that have not the Gospel, and are not of the Christian Church, but only believe that God is, and that he is the Re••rder of them that […]tly seek him, and that in every Nation do fear God, and work righteousness] belongeth not to our present question; but only what is necessary to the Christian State and Hope.
§. 3. As Knowledg cometh in by slow degree•▪ so there are as many degrees or differences of it, in the World, as there are Men; it being not probeble that any two men on Earth have just the same apprehensions and degrees of Knowledg; but that ⟨p. 3⟩all mens mental Complexions differ far more than their Vis•ges do. So that if the same degree were •he measure of necessary Church-Concord, and •alvation, there should but one in the World be ••e Church or be saved. The question then is not, What measure is desireable, but what is necessary to Church-Unity and Communion, and to Salvation. And what God will do with those that have not the Gospel, and are not of the Christian Church, but only believe that God is, and that he is the Re••rder of them that 〈…〉tly seek him, and that in every Nation do fear God, and work righteousness] belongeth not to our present question; but only what is necessary to the Christian State and Hope.
§. 4. And here it is first to be decided, Whether God hath by •y fixed Law or Revelation determined so •f the Measure of Christian Knowledge and Faith, as •hat thereby men may know who are to be taken as Christians and of the Church? To which I say, 1. We •ust distinguish of Faith as objective and as Active, •r as to the matter believed, and as to the Act of •elieting or knowing. 2. Between the Inward Sincerity and the Outward Profession: And remember •hat though God judge of Men according 1. to inward Sincerity, and 2. expect that degree of Knowing and Faith in Act and Habit suitable to means enjoyed, without which the man and his Faith are •ot indeed sincere; yet the Church (and all Men) •an judge of others, but 1. By outward Profession, •. extended to that degree of Objective Faith, which God hath made commonly necessary to Christianity or to the acceptance of the Church
§. 4. And here it is first to be decided, Whether God hath by •y fixed Law or Revelation determined so •f the Measure of Christian Knowledg and Faith, as •hat thereby men may know who are to be taken as Christians and of the Church? To which I say, 1. We •ust distinguish of Faith as objective and as Active, •r as to the matter believed, and as to the Act of •elieting or knowing. 2. Between the Inward Sincerity and the Outward Profession: And remember •hat though God judge of Men according 1. to inward Sincerity, and 2. expect that degree of Knowe••g and Faith in Act and Habit suitable to means •njoyed, without which the man and his Faith are •ot indeed sincere; yet the Church (and all Men) •an judge of others, but 1. By outward Profession, •. extended to that degree of Objective Faith, which God hath made commonly necessary to Christianity or to the acceptance of the Church
It is therefore here a deceiving Confusion, to confound the two cases, what is necessary to God's acceptance into Heaven, and what is necessary to a ⟨p. 4⟩Man's acceptance into the Church. And thence some conclude that no man can tell just what is necessary to Individuals.
It is therefore here a deceiving Consusion, to •onfound the two cases, what is necessary to God's acceptance into Heaven, and what is necessary to a ⟨p. 4⟩Man's acceptance into the Church. And thence some conclude that no man can tell just what is necessary to Individuals.
§. 5. That Christ hath stated the Essentials of Christianity, taken objectively should be so far past question, as our Christianity it self is, at least. For if he have not, then he is not the Author and Finisher of our Faith: And if he be not who is▪ The Apostles delivered it as received from him. If it were not then made and determined by Christ, then there was then no Christianity, and so no Christians. And if it was made since then, who wa• the Maker of Objective Christianity? No Man o• Company of Men dare or do pretend to it. If they should, whence had they that Power? And did •• die with them? Or may others after them make also a new Christianity? Paul pronounceth Angel or Man accursed that should bring another Gospel than that which he had received and preached Gal. 1. 7, 8. 1 Cor. 15. 3, 4. &c.
2. And if the Essentials of Christianity and Church-relation and Communion were not determined of by Christ, and notified in the Holy Scriptures, then there could be then no Christian Church, for want of Church-Essentials. And then when began that Church, and who made it.
3. But the Gospel hath put the matter out of doubt, telling us that Christ hath actually declared and determined the Essentials of Objective Christianity and the Church: even in his Institution o• Baptism, which is our Christening, which in his preaching he expounded, and so did his Apostles. 2. And as his Baptized Disciples were called Christians, so he commanded them to Love one another and live in Concord and Communion a•⟨p. 5⟩Christians: and could any obey this Command, of Christianity was then either unmade or a thing that could not be known?
§. 6. And if it was then made by Christ, it was sur•ly anchangeable: else men might be still making a new Christianity, from Age to Age, and when should we have an end? And who hath power or skill to make a better than Christ made […] that attempted it, thereby is an accursed Antichrist?
§. 6. And if it was then made by Christ, it was sur•ly anchangeable: else men might be still making a new Christianity, from Age to Age, and when should we have an end? And who hath power or skill to make a better than Christ made 〈…〉 that attempted it, thereby is an accursed Antichrist?
§. 7. And now we come next to enquire, I. What are the Church-Controversies to be decided. II. And who are the Dissenters that differ herein. III. And then we shall easily find who it is that must be the Judge of them.
§. 8. And 1. it is supposed that it is no one essential part o• Objective Christianity that is in Controversy. 2. And that it is not among Christians that any such point is controverted. For he that denieth any essential part, denieth Christianity and the Church; and therefore is no Christian (whatever he may be called by himself or others.) And though Confounders make a great Controversy of it, whether a Heretic be a Christian and a part of the Church, it's easily resolved; if we dally not with an ambiguous word: If by a Heretic be meant one that professeth not, or denied any essential part of Christianity or the Church, he is no Christian nor part of that Church which he denied: But if by a Heretic be meant one that professeth not, or denieth only something that is of the melius esse of Christianity and the Church, he is a Member though a faulty one.
§. 8. And 1. it is supposed that it is no one essential part o• Objective Christianity that is in Controversie. 2. And that it is not among Christians that any such point is controverted. For he that denyeth any essential part, denyeth Christianity and the Church; and therefore is no Christian (whatever he may be called by himself or others.) And though Confounders make a great Controversie of it, whether a Heretick be a Christian and a part of the Church, it's easily resolved; if we dally not with an ambiguous word: If by a Heretick be meant one that professeth not, or deny•d any essential part of Christianity or the Church, he is no Christian nor part of that Church which he denyed: But if by a Heretick be meant one that professeth not, or denyeth only something that is of the melius esse of Christianity and the Church, he is a Member though a faulty one.
§. 9. But it will be said, that more than the Essentials of Christianity is necessary to Church-Communion: ⟨p. 6⟩else we must receive Drunkards, Fornicators, Extortioners, Railers, with whom, saith St. Paul, we must net eat.