A26923:313
An end of doctrinal controversies which have lately troubled the churches
An end of doctrinal controversies which have lately troubled the churches by reconciling explication without much disputing. Written by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for John Salusbury, 1691
Chapter 6 › An ANSWER TO Mr. Polehill's Exceptions about Futurition.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ad 7. Here you are for yea and nay: you will suppose no Propositions in God, and yet you argue that then, what will remain of a Decree. I said, ⟨p. 60⟩But that God knoweth not by Propositions, b•• yet that he knoweth Propositions. If you hold, That God knoweth by Propositions and Argumentations, say so, that I may know what to speak to. If you hold, That He hath no Decrees, what is it that you plead for? But to answer your Question, God's Decree is not a forming of Propositions in his mind, or any change in himself, or addition to his Being: But it is His simple will that such and such things shall be, emanative, communicative, productive of them in their season. There are some that think, that as Time-Divisions are the measures of imperfect Creatures, and God's Eternity hath none such; so that it is an ascribing Imperfection to God, to say, That he hath Decrees de futuris distinct from a productive Volition, which in the most proper sense should be denominated from the produced Existent as such. But in this I interess not my self, as knowing that we must speak improperly of God or not at all. You say that (It shall be, is a Futurity.) Ans. What's that? A (shall be) is (a Futurity), and (a futurity) is a (shall be.) Ergo a shall be and a futurity is a being. Would I knew what. But to hope for that from you is too great Presumption. You add (A futurity, a nothing, and to decree nothing is not to decree.) Ans. Say you so? I am glad you say no worse: Then if those be in the right (as most) that think Sin is nothing (no more than Death or Darkness) you will grant that God decreed it not. And if I prove that Futurity ex parte rei, is nothing, you will grant that it needeth no Decree as such. But seeing you are so much on my side, I crave your help to confute those, that otherwise you defend, who make innumerable Nothings the Objects ⟨p. 61⟩of God's Decrees. But yet I would not follow you too far: (Not to give Grace to an Infidel) is nothing. (Not to give the Gospel, not to end the World till the time, not to take away Grace, Gospel, Life, &c.) You say here (in your general) that none of these can be decreed. But then prepare an Answer to your Friends that will take this ill of you. I have fully opened my sense of it elsewhere. You say (Abstract futurity from the Decree and it will be nothing.) Ans.
Ad 7. Here you are for yea and nay: you will suppose no Propositions in God, and yet you argue that then, what will remain of a Decree. I said,