A26943:72
Mr. Baxter's judgment and reasons against communicating with the parish-assemblies, as
Mr. Baxter's judgment and reasons against communicating with the parish-assemblies, as by law required, impartially stated and proposed
London : s.n., 1684
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
II. That Mr. Baxter's communion is no more Catholic than theirs; though he talks more of the Name, he has no more of the thing than they have. Doth he hold Catholic Communion mentally with the Universal Church? so do they. Do they with-hold mental communion from Parish-Assemblies, as by Law established (i. e.) as they are parts of the Diocesan institution? So doth Mr. Baxter. Are the Con•••••tions, to which their local Communion is confined, of a Constitution different from, and independent on the Diocesan? So is the Parish Church with which Mr. Baxter communicates, if it be really what he fancieth it to be; so that his Local Communion is as much confined to Dissenting Assemblies as theirs is.
II. That Mr. Baxter's communion is no more Catholick than theirs; though he talks more of the Name, he has no more of the thing than they have. Doth he hold Catholick Communion mentally with the Universal Church? so do they. Do they with-hold mental communion from Parish-Assemblies, as by Law established (i. e.) as they are parts of the Diocesane •nstitution? So doth Mr. Baxter. Are the Con•••••tions, to which their local Communion is confined, of a Constitution different from, and independent on the Diocesane? So is the Parish Church with which Mr. Baxter communicates, if it be really what he fancieth it to be; so that his Local Communion is as much confined to Dissenting Assemblies as theirs is.
This is on a Supposition that Mr. Baxters Imaginations were operative, ad extra, and would make a real change on the Constitution. But if the Parish Assembly continues, de facto, as established, then I must say,
III. That Mr. Baxter holds both those Premises, from which a conclusion (justifying their separation) doth naturally follow. The Premises are these; It is our undoubted Duty to separate from the Corruptions that are in the Parish Assemblies. But the very Constitution of the Parish Assemblies and Ministry, by Law established, are Corruptions. These are Mr. Baxter's Premises. And let the World judge whether this Conclusion [namely, That it is our undoubted Duty to separate from the Parish Assemblies and Ministry, as by Law established] doth not naturally flow from them, justifying a with-holding Communion from the Parish Assemblies. In fine, it must be observed, that if the Parish Assemblies be really de facto, but parts of the Diocesan Church, and no complete Churches, Mr. Baxter must justify the Separation, and that he doth so, I will give you his own words, as I find 'em in his Schism detected, p. 28. Either our Parish Churches (saith he) are true Churches, or not; if not, the Separatists are so far in the Right, and separate not from true Churches, eo nomine, because they separate from them: so far Mr. Baxter; who, if the Parish. Assemblies be but parts of the Diocesan Constitution and not true complete particular Churches, justifies the separation from 'em; And who knows not, that the Parish Assemblies, as by Law established, are but parts of the Diocesan?