A26959:679
More proofs of infants church-membership and consequently their right to baptism, or, A second…
More proofs of infants church-membership and consequently their right to baptism, or, A second defence of our infant rights and mercies in three parts ... / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for N. Simmons and J. Robinson, 1675
Chapter 4: Of Mr. Danvers's his Witnesses against Infant-Baptism.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§. 23. Reader, the Donatists were so great a party of men and had so great a number of Bishops, and so many wrote against them whose works are yet extant, and their cause had so many public examinations, that I leave it to thee if thou have the brains of a man, to judge whether if they had been against Infant-baptism in a time when Austin said no Christian denied it, neither Optatus, nor Austin, nor any other of their most copious opposers would ever have charged them with such an opinion, nor any examiners, Councils or Historians of their ages; even when the Catalogues of heretics unhappily took in so many little matters as they did, and made heretics some more and worse than ⟨p. 252⟩they were? And now if John Becold will say they were of his side, we must believe him.
§. 23. Reader, the Donatists were so great a party of men and had so great a number of Bishops, and so many wrote against them whose works are yet extant, and their cause had so many publick examinations, that I leave it to thee if thou have the brains of a man, to judge whether if they had been against Infant-baptism in a time when Austin said no Christian denied it, neither Optatus, nor Austin, nor any other of their most copious opposers would ever have charged them with such an opinion, nor any examiners, Councils or Historians of their ages; even when the Catalogues of hereticks unhappily took in so many little matters as they did, and made hereticks some more and worse than ⟨p. 252⟩they were? And now if John Becold will say they were of his side, we must believe him.
§. 24. His dealing with the Novatians is the same or worse: He feared not in the face of the Sun, to write that the Novatians opposed Infant-baptism, and numbereth them also with his party. When it is a falsehood as much aggravated as these particulars import. 1. They were an honest and numerous people, and scattered almost all over the Empire; tolerated till Innocents time in Rome, and long tolerated and much favoured by many Emperors and Patriarchs in Constantinople, because (as Socrates saith) they agreed in Doctrine with the Catholics: And could they have denied Infant-baptism, and not be accused of it? 2. They had many bitter enemies that would soon have cast this in their teeth. 3. Many Councils had to do with them, where multitudes had opportunity to accuse them. 4. They were an ancient Sect, arising even in Cyprian's time, and long continued: And in so many generations it would have been known. 5. They are put in the Catalogues of many Heresiographers that are keen enough, and none of them (that ever I found) accuse them of any such thing: No not Epiphanius himself, who is most copious, and not very backward to accuse. And shall either John of Leiden or any of his party now in the end of the world persuade us, by slandering so many thousands of innocent men, that they were guilty? And can Mr. Danvers now tell us that they held that which for a thousand years hath lain unknown?