A26962:129
Naked popery, or, The naked falsehood of a book called The Catholic naked truth,…Naked popery, or, The naked falshood of a book called The Catholick naked truth,…
Naked popery, or, The naked falsehood of a book called The Catholic naked truth, or, The Puritan convert to apostolical Christianity, written by W.H. opening their fundamental error of unwritten tradition, and their unjust description of the Puritans, the prelatical Protestant, and the papist, and their differences, and better acquainting the ignorant of the same difference, especially what a Puritan and what a papist is / by Richard Baxter ...Naked popery, or, The naked falshood of a book called The Catholick naked truth, or, The Puritan convert to apostolical Christianity, written by W.H. opening their fundamental errour of unwritten tradition, and their unjust description of the Puritans, the prelatical Protestant, and the papist, and their differences, and better acquainting the ignorant of the same difference, especially what a Puritan and what a papist is / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed for N. Simmons, 1677
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But you tell us, that [Some of the Prelatic Clergy begin to scoff at the Doctrine of Imputative Justice: One of them lately, in a Sermon before his Majesty, called it, and not improperly, the Mummery of Imputative Justice.] I will transcribe no more of your Scoff: It's dangerous mocking at such matters: Imputed Righteousness is oft mentioned by the Holy Ghost in Scripture. It is not some mens mis-exposition that will justify your derision. It's no strange thing for men of undigested thoughts on both sides, publicly and privately to revile at each other as erroneous, when if they had but the skill of speaking distinctly, and understanding one another, they would presently profess that they are agreed; or if it be for want of understanding the matter, it's pity but they should be quiet till they understand it. I am of their mind that think it is here safest to keep close to Scripture phrase; for want of which many wrangle about their own ambiguous or ill made words, that in the matter disagree not.
But you tell us, that [Some of the Prelatick Clergie begin to scoff at the Doctrine of Imputative Justice: One of them lately, in a Sermon before his Majesty, called it, and not improperly, the Mummery of Imputative Justice.] I will transcribe no more of your Scoff: It's dangerous mocking at such matters: Imputed Righteousness is oft mentioned by the Holy Ghost in Scripture. It is not some mens mis-exposition that will justifie your derision. It's no strange thing for men of undigested thoughts on both sides, publickly and privately to revile at each other as erroneous, when if they had but the skill of speaking distinctly, and understanding one another, they would presently profess that they are agreed; or if it be for want of understanding the matter, it's pity but they should be quiet till they understand it. I am of their mind that think it is here safest to keep close to Scripture phrase; for want of which many wrangle about their own ambiguous or ill made words, that in the matter disagree not.
But, Sir, when you say, pag. 6. [An Imputative holy man is a mere Christmas Mummer;] And after your jesting with the Boys and Girls, and the Cobblers and Botchers Regal Attire, and the Daw and her fine Feathers, you conclude [such will be the sad Lot of merely Imputative Saints, who to themselves and their Brethren seem very fine in the extrinsical Righteousness of Christ, put on by their fantastical Faith, whilst God and his Angels under all this conceited assumed Bravery see a lascivious, wanton, covetous Miser.] I must crave leave to call upon your Conscience, to judge whether a man that professeth that while he seemed a Puritan he was but an unholy, lascivious, wanton, and covetous miser, and since his turning Papist tells the World in Print, that he is now a most false calumniator, be a fit person to invite his Relations to such a pitiful change, to save their Souls? While you talked but of [Imputative Justice] some mens ambiguous words gave you an excuse: For some Protestants think that nothing should be called Justifying Righteousness, which is not sinless and perfect: But this is but a Controversy about a Word or Name of Righteousness. But when you here pretend, that they are for merely Imputed Holiness, I must say that I remember not that ever I read a more impudent Slander: And he that will dwell in Gods holy Hill must not receive a false Report, especially in despite of the fullest evidence that man can desire: Are not our Booksellers Shops full of Books for the necessity of personal Holiness? and that none can be saved but Saints? Is it not one of our dislikes of your Way, that Saints must be made rare Canonized Persons, when all Christians hold, that without Holiness none shall see God? When almost all the Sermons that ever I heard […] by any man of sense in my life profest this, and almost