A26962:252
Naked popery, or, The naked falsehood of a book called The Catholic naked truth,…Naked popery, or, The naked falshood of a book called The Catholick naked truth,…
Naked popery, or, The naked falsehood of a book called The Catholic naked truth, or, The Puritan convert to apostolical Christianity, written by W.H. opening their fundamental error of unwritten tradition, and their unjust description of the Puritans, the prelatical Protestant, and the papist, and their differences, and better acquainting the ignorant of the same difference, especially what a Puritan and what a papist is / by Richard Baxter ...Naked popery, or, The naked falshood of a book called The Catholick naked truth, or, The Puritan convert to apostolical Christianity, written by W.H. opening their fundamental errour of unwritten tradition, and their unjust description of the Puritans, the prelatical Protestant, and the papist, and their differences, and better acquainting the ignorant of the same difference, especially what a Puritan and what a papist is / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed for N. Simmons, 1677
Chapter 5: The true History of the Papacy, its original and growth.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
6. Once more hear their own Confession; Their late English Bishop (of Calcedon, a fatal name) R. Smith in his Survey against Bishop Bromhall saith, cap. 5. [To us it sufficeth, that the Bishop of Rome is S. Peter's Successor, and this all the Fathers testify, and all the Catholic Church believeth: But whether it be jure divino or humano is no point of Faith.]
6. Once more hear their own Confession; Their late English Bishop (of Calcedon, a fatal name) R. Smyth in his Survey against Bishop Bromhall saith, cap. 5. [To us it sufficeth, that the Bishop of Rome is S. Peter's Successor, and this all the Fathers testifie, and all the Catholick Church believeth: But whether it be jure divino or humano is no point of Faith.]
Ans. 1. Is not that a point of your Faith which the General Councils affirm? at least of your Religion? Who can tell then what is your Faith? 2. If an historical point be not to be believed from General Councils, why should the History of Peter's being at Rome, and Bishop there, be believed as from Fathers? (which Nilas hath said so much against.) 3. Do not the Fathers as much agree that Peter was first Bishop of Antioch? If then you have no more to show than they, where is your Title? 4. If your Divine Right of succeeding Peter be no point of Faith, then he that believeth it not, doth not sin against any point that God would have him believe as from him, and therefore is not to be thought erroneous in the Faith. 5. And yet upon this, which is no point of Faith, you build your Faith and Church, and would have all Christians do the like, on pain of damnation.
Ans. 1. Is not that a point of your Faith which the General Councils affirm? at least of your Religion? Who can tell then what is your Faith? 2. If an historical point be not to be believed from General Councils, why should the History of Peter's being at Rome, and Bishop there, be believed as from Fathers? (which Nilas hath said so much against.) 3. Do not the Fathers as much agree that Peter was first Bishop of Antioch? If then you have no more to shew than they, where is your Title? 4. If your Divine Right of succeeding Peter be no point of Faith, then he that believeth it not, doth not sin against any point that God would have him believe as from him, and therefore is not to be thought erroneous in the Faith. 5. And yet upon this, which is no point of Faith, you build your Faith and Church, and would have all Christians do the like, on pain of damnation.