A26962:57
Naked popery, or, The naked falsehood of a book called The Catholic naked truth,…Naked popery, or, The naked falshood of a book called The Catholick naked truth,…
Naked popery, or, The naked falsehood of a book called The Catholic naked truth, or, The Puritan convert to apostolical Christianity, written by W.H. opening their fundamental error of unwritten tradition, and their unjust description of the Puritans, the prelatical Protestant, and the papist, and their differences, and better acquainting the ignorant of the same difference, especially what a Puritan and what a papist is / by Richard Baxter ...Naked popery, or, The naked falshood of a book called The Catholick naked truth, or, The Puritan convert to apostolical Christianity, written by W.H. opening their fundamental errour of unwritten tradition, and their unjust description of the Puritans, the prelatical Protestant, and the papist, and their differences, and better acquainting the ignorant of the same difference, especially what a Puritan and what a papist is / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed for N. Simmons, 1677
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
3. Yea, even as to Christs Promise, we can better prove that the Universal Church, or Body of Christians, shall never lose the Faith, than you can prove it of Rome alone, or the Papal Sect. Bellarmine himself dare not say, that Rome shall not cease to be the feat of the Papacy, or shall not be utterly destroyed. And then how can there be a Bishop of Rome, when there is no Rome? But you'll say, that if he dwell at Avignon, he may be called Bishop of Rome? But if he be called so when he is not so, at least when there is no Rome, or no Christian Church there, sure a false Name is not an Essential part of our Religion. If you say, that at Avignon, or Ravenna, or Vienna, he may be S. Peter's Successor, and so the Universal Monarch still. I answer, Then it seems that the Council of Calcedon, as afore-cited, was in the right, (that Romes Privilege was given by the Fathers, because it was the Imperial Seat:) And so that the Pope is not S. Peter's Successor, eo nomine, because he is Bishop of Rome. But if the Bishop of Avignon, or Vienna, might become S. Peter's Successor (who never was Bishop there,) how shall we know that the Bishop of Rome is his Successor now? We have hitherto had no better means to prove it, and deceive the World, than by saying that S. Peter dyed Bishop ⟨p. 23⟩of Rome, where the Pope is Bishop: But S. Peter dyed not Bishop of Avignon. If the Place prove not the Succession, tell us, if you can, what doth? Is it the Election? By whom? Who are those men that have the Power of choosing S. Peter a Successor? You know, I suppose, that the Pope hath been chosen, 1. Sometime by the People, (witness the blood-shed at the choice of Damasus in the Church:) 2. Sometime by the People, and the Neighbour Ordaining Bishops: 3. Sometime by a Synod: 4. Sometime by the Emperors: 5. And lastly, by the Roman Cardinals. If any of these may choose, then we may have four or five lawful Popes, chosen four or five several ways, at once. If only one of these have the Power, S. Peter had no Successors under all the other Elections. So that the Claim will fall rather to Antioch than to Avignon, or any other Town, because they say it was S. Peter's first Bishopric, from which he removed for a greater. If you are driven with poor Mr. Johnson, alias, Terret, to say, that Any way will serve which serveth for the truth of an Election of Princes, &c.
3. Yea, even as to Christs Promise, we can better prove that the Universal Church, or Body of Christians, shall never lose the Faith, than you can prove it of Rome alone, or the Papal Sect. Bellarmine himself dare not say, that Rome shall not cease to be the feat of the Papacy, or shall not be utterly destroyed. And then how can there be a Bishop of Rome, when there is no Rome? But you'll say, that if he dwell at Avignion, he may be called Bishop of Rome? But if he be called so when he is not so, at least when there is no Rome, or no Christian Church there, sure a false Name is not an Essential part of our Religion. If you say, that at Avignion, or Ravenna, or Vienna, he may be S. Peter's Successor, and so the Universal Monarch still. I answer, Then it seems that the Council of Calcedon, as afore-cited, was in the right, (that Romes Priviledge was given by the Fathers, because it was the Imperial Seat:) And so that the Pope is not S. Peter's Successor, eo nomine, because he is Bishop of Rome. But if the Bishop of Avignion, or Vienna, might become S. Peter's Successor (who never was Bishop there,) how shall we know that the Bishop of Rome is his Successor now? We have hitherto had no better means to prove it, and deceive the World, than by saying that S. Peter dyed Bishop