A26963:137
The nature and immortality of the soul proved in answer to one who professed…
The nature and immortality of the soul proved in answer to one who professed perplexing doubtfulness / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for B. Simmons, 1682
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. The certain effect of natural necessary Causes hath natural necessary evidence of Truth.
But when all knowing men of contrary Dispositions and Interests▪ acknowledge a thing true, this is the effect of natural necessary Causes.
But when all knowing men of contrary Dispositions and Interests▪ acknowledg a thing true, this is the effect of natural necessary Causes.
Ergo it hath natural necessary evidence of Truth.
2. It is impossible there should be an Effect without a sufficient Cause.
But that a thing should be false which all knowing men of contrary Dispositions and Interests acknowledge to be true, would be an Effect without a Cause▪ for there is no Cause ⟨p. 65⟩in nature to effect it. It is impossible in nature that all men in England should agree to say, There was a King James, K. Edward, Q. Mary, or that these Statutes were made by them, if it were false. This is infallible Historical Testimony. It were not so strong if it were only by one Party, and not by Enemies also, or men of contrary Minds and Interests. And thus we know the History of the Gospel; and this Tradition is naturally infallible.
But that a thing should be false which all knowing men of contrary Dispositions and Interests acknowledg to be true, would be an Effect without a Cause▪ for there is no Cause ⟨p. 65⟩in nature to effect it. It is impossible in nature that all men in England should agree to say, There was a King James, K. Edward, Q. Mary, or that these Statutes were made by them, if it were false. This is infallible Historical Testimony. It were not so strong if it were only by one Party, and not by Enemies also, or men of contrary Minds and Interests. And thus we know the History of the Gospel; and this Tradition is naturally infallible.
II. But all the Testimony which dependeth on humane Acts, not necessary, but free, have but an uncertain moral humane Credibility. For so all men are Liars; i. e. fallible, and not fully to be trusted.
II. But all the Testimony which dependeth on humane Acts, not necessary, but free, have but an uncertain moral humane Credibility. For so all men are Lyars; i. e. fallible, and not fully to be trusted.
And I. Those Testimonies which depend on mens Honesty, are no farther credible, than we know the Honesty of the men: which in some is great, in some is none, in most is mixed, and lubricous, and doubtful, Alas! what abundance of false History is in the world! Who can trust the Honesty of such men, as multitudes of Popes, Prelates, and Priests have been? Will they stick at a Lye, that stick not at Blood, or any wickedness? Besides, the ignorance which invalidates their Testimony.
And I. Those Testimonies which depend on mens Honesty, are no farther credible, than we know the Honesty of the men: which in some is great, in some is none, in most is mixt, and lubricous, and doubtful, Alas! what abundance of false History is in the world! Who can trust the Honesty of such men, as multitudes of Popes, Prelates, and Priests have been? Will they stick at a Lye, that stick not at Blood, or any wickedness? Besides, the ignorance which invalidates their Testimony.
II. And to pretend Authority to rule our Faith, is the most unsatisfactory way of all. ⟨p. 66⟩For before you can believe that Jesus is the Christ, and his Word true, how many impossibilities have you to believe? 1. You must believe that Christ hath a Church. 2. And hath authorized them to determine what is to be believed, before you believe that he is Christ. 3. You must know who they be whom you must believe; whether all, or some, or a major vote. Whether out of all▪ the world, or a party. 4. And how far their Authority extendeth? Whether to judg whether there be a God, or no God; a Christ, or no Christ; a Heaven, or none; a Gospel, or none: or what. 5. And how their determinations out of all the world may come with certainty to us: and where to find them. 6. And when Countries and Councils contradict and condemn each other, which is to be believed. Many such impossibilities in the Roman way, must be believed, before a man can believe that Jesus is the Christ. In a word, you must not puzzle your head to know what a man is, or whether he have an immortal soul; but you must, 1. believe the Church of Believers, before you are a Believer in Christ. 2. And you must believe, that Christ was God and Man, and came to save man, before you believe that there is such a creature as man, or what he is, and whether he have a soul capable of salvation. But I have oft elsewhere opened these Absurdities and Contradictions; ⟨p. 67⟩where you may see them confuted, if you are willing.
II. And to pretend Authority to rule our Faith, is the most unsatisfactory way of all. ⟨p. 66⟩For before you can believe that Jesus is the Christ, and his Word true, how many impossibilities have you to believe? 1. You must believe that Christ hath a Church. 2. And hath authorized them to determine what is to be believed, before you believe that he is Christ. 3. You must know who they be whom you must believe; whether all, or some, or a major vote. Whether out of all▪ the world, or a party. 4. And how far their Authority extendeth? Whether to judg whether there be a God, or no God; a Christ, or no Christ; a Heaven, or none; a Gospel, or none: or what. 5. And how their determinations out of all the world may come with certainty to us: and where to find them. 6. And when Countreys and Councils contradict and condemn each other, which is to be believed. Many such impossibilities in the Roman way, must be believed, before a man can believe that Jesus is the Christ. In a word, you must not puzzle your head to know what a man is, or whether he have an immortal soul; but you must, 1. believe the Church of Believers, before you are a Believer in Christ. 2. And you must believe, that Christ was God and Man, and came to save man, before you believe that there is such a creature as man, or what he is, and whether he have a soul capable of salvation. But I have oft elsewhere opened these Absurdities and Contradictions; ⟨p. 67⟩where you may see them confuted, if you are willing.
§. 36. Your question about the souls nature, existence, and Individuation, may be resolved by a surer and easier way as followeth:
I. By your own certain experience.
1. You perceive that you see, feel, understand, will and execute. 2. You may know, as is oft said, that therefore you have an active power to do these. 3. You may thence know, that it is a substance which hath that power. Nothing can do nothing. 4. You may perceive, that it is not the terrene substance, but an invisible substance, actuating the body. 5. You may know, that there is no probability, that so noble a substance should be annihilated. 6. Or that a pure and simple substance should be dissolved by the separation of parts (or if that were every part would be a spirit still). 7. You have no cause to suspect, that this substance should lose those powers or faculties which are its essential form, and be turned into some other species, or thing. 8. And you have as little cause to suspect, that an essential vital intellective power, will not be active, when active inclination is its Essence. 9. You have no cause to suspect, that it will want Objects to action in a World of such variety of Objects. 10. And you have as little cause to ⟨p. 68⟩suspect, that it will be unactive, for want of Organs, when God hath made its Essence active; and either can make new Organs; or that which can act on matter, can act without, or on other matter. He that can play on a Lute, can do somewhat as good, if that be broken. 11. And experience might satisfy you, that several men have several souls, by the several and contrary Operations. 12. And you have no reason to suspect, that God will turn many, from being many, into one; or that unity should be any of their loss. All this, Reason tells you, beginning at your own experience, as I have (and elsewhere more fully) opened.
1. You perceive that you see, feel, understand, will and execute. 2. You may know, as is oft said, that therefore you have an active power to do these. 3. You may thence know, that it is a substance which hath that power. Nothing can do nothing. 4. You may perceive, that it is not the terrene substance, but an invisible substance, actuating the body. 5. You may know, that there is no probability, that so noble a substance should be annihilated. 6. Or that a pure and simple substance should be dissolved by the separation of parts (or if that were every part would be a spirit still). 7. You have no cause to suspect, that this substance should lose those powers or faculties which are its essential form, and be turned into some other species, or thing. 8. And you have as little cause to suspect, that an essential vital intellective power, will not be active, when active inclination is its Essence. 9. You have no cause to suspect, that it will want Objects to action in a World of such variety of Objects. 10. And you have as little cause to ⟨p. 68⟩suspect, that it will be unactive, for want of Organs, when God hath made its Essence active; and either can make new Organs; or that which can act on matter, can act without, or on other matter. He that can play on a Lute, can do somewhat as good, if that be broken. 11. And experience might satisfie you, that several men have several souls, by the several and contrary Operations. 12. And you have no reason to suspect, that God will turn many, from being many, into one; or that unity should be any of their loss. All this, Reason tells you, beginning at your own experience, as I have (and elsewhere more fully) opened.
§. 37. II. And you have at hand sensible proof of the individuation of spirits, by Witches, Contracts, and Apparitions: of which the world has unquestionable proof, tho there be very many Cheats. Read Mr. Glanvill's new Book, published by Dr. Moore, Lavater de Spectris, Zanchy de Angilii, Manlii Collect. Bodin's Daemonolog. Remigius of Witches, besides all the Mallei Malificorum, and doubt if you can. If you do, I can give you yet more, with full proof.
§. 38. III. But all that I have said to you, is but the least part, in comparison of the assurance which you may have by the full ⟨p. 69⟩revelation of Jesus Christ, who hath brought life and immortality to light in the Gospel, where the state, the doom, the rewards and punishment of souls is asserted.
§. 38. III. But all that I have said to you, is but the least part, in comparison of the assurance which you may have by the full ⟨p. 69⟩revelatson of Jesus Christ, who hath brought life and immortality to light in the Gospel, where the state, the doom, the rewards and punishment of souls is asserted.
And without dark and long Ambages, or Roman Juggles, we prove the truth of this Gospel, briefly and infallibly thus:
I. The History of Christ's Life, Miracles, Doctrine, Death, Resurrection, Ascension, the Apostles Miracles, &c. is proved by such forementioned evidence, as hath physical certainty: Not such as dependeth only on mens honesty, or moral argument, much less on a pretended determining authority; but such as dependeth on necessary acts of man, even the consent of all sorts of contrary minds and interests, as we know the Statutes of the Land, or other certain History. But we are so far from needing to ask, which part of Christians it is that is this Church, that is to be believed, that it tendeth to the ascertaining of us, that all the Christian World, Papists, Protestants, Greeks, Muscovites, Armenians, Jacobites, Nestorians, &c. herein agree, even while they oppose each other. To know whether there was a Julius, or Augustus Caesar, a Virgil, Ovid Cicero, and which are their Works; yea, which are the Acts of Councils, no man goeth to an authorized determining ⟨p. 70⟩Judg for the matter of Fact, but to historiCal proof. And this we have most full.
I. The History of Christ's Life, Miracles, Doctrine, Death, Resurrection, Ascension, the Apostles Miracles, &c. is proved by such forementioned evidence, as hath physical certainty: Not such as dependeth only on mens honesty, or moral argument, much less on a pretended determining authority; but such as dependeth on necessary acts of man, even the consent of all sorts of contrary minds and interests, as we know the Statutes of the Land, or other certain History. But we are so far from needing to ask, which part of Christians it is that is this Church, that is to be believed, that it tendeth to the assertaining of us, that all the Christian World, Papists, Protestants, Greeks, Moscovites, Armenians, Jacobites, Nestorians, &c. herein agree, even while they oppose each other. To know whether there was a Julius, or Augustus Caesar, a Virgil, Ovid Cicero, and which are their Works; yea, which are the Acts of Councils, no man goeth to an authorized determining ⟨p. 70⟩Judg for the matter of Fact, but to historiCal proof. And this we have most full.
II. And if the History be true, the Doctrine must needs be true, seeing it is fully proved by the matters of Fact. Christ being proved to be Christ, all his words must •eeds be true.