A26974:246
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Thirdly, But I perceive how you would take it if I had applied this to your self. And what is this, but plainly to forbid me to dispute with you? (which I had never done on other terms then for Defence.) Can I not tell you that your Argument is a Fallacy, but you will thus exclaim of me, as making you an Impostor? why then if you be so tender, who may deal with you? On the same grounds, if I say that your Major or Minor is false▪ you may tell the world I make you a Liar; and I must either say as you say, or let you alone; lest by contradiction I make you a Liar or an Impostor. Prove that ever I blamed Mr. Crandon for such a passage as this, if you can. It is not [this word] thus applied, but other words that I excepted against; I will not yet believe it all one to call an Argument or distinction a cheat or fallacy, and to call the person a Cheater and Deceiver, and that designedly, as purposely dissembling his Religion.
Thirdly, But I perceive how you would take it if I had applyed this to your self. And what is this, but plainly to forbid me to dispute with you? (which I had never done on other terms then for Defence.) Can I not tell you that your Argument is a Fallacy, but you will thus exclaim of me, as making you an Impostor? why then if you be so tender, who may deal with you? On the same grounds, if I say that your Major or Minor is false▪ you may tell the world I make you a Lyar; and I must either say as you say, or let you alone; lest by contradiction I make you a Lyar or an Impostor. Prove that ever I blamed Mr. Crandon for such a passage as this, if you can. It is not [this word] thus applyed, but other words that I excepted against; I will not yet believe it all one to call an Argument or distinction a cheat or fallacy, and to call the person a Cheater and Deceiver, and that designedly, as purposely dissembling his Religion.
Mr. Blake proceeds. [And I much marvel that this distinction, that everywhere else would pass, and be confessed to be of necessity, to avoid confusion in those distinct capacities in which men usually act, should here not alone be questioned, but thus branded. Does not every man that undergoes various relations, variously act according to them? And do not men that make address, address themselves in like variety? He that is at once a Husband, a Parent, a Master, a School-master, a Physician, acts variously according to all of these capacities. Some come to him as a Father, some as a Master, some as a Teacher; all of them come to him as a Physician: But only they that come to him as a Physician are cured by him. Believers through faith go to Christ that hears all the Relations mentioned. But as they seek satisfaction in his blood-shedding, which is an act of his Priesthood, they are justified.]