A26974:557
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Whether Works are a Condition of Justification? And so whether we a… › Part
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answer. First, I grant the conclusion, if you had taken Works in Pauls sense, for the works of a hirling, or any that are supposed to justify by their value.
Answer. First, I grant the conclusion, if you had taken Works in Pauls sense, for the works of a hirling, or any that are supposed to justifie by their value.
Secondly, I deny your first consequence: And I give you the reason of my denial (I hope a little better then yours for the proof of it) First, It is not the degree of Repentance or Obedience that is made the Condition of our continued and final Justification: but the Sincerity. Now the sincerity is the same thing in one as in another; therefore one is no more justified hereby then another. Secondly, You might as well say, that different degrees of faith, make different degrees of Justification. But that is not just, because it lies all on the sincerity; therefore it is as unjust here for the same reason.
Secondly, I deny your first consequence: And I give you the reason of my denyal (I hope a little better then yours for the proof of it) First, It is not the degree of Repentance or Obedience that is made the Condition of our continued and final Justification: but the Sincerity. Now the sincerity is the same thing in one as in another; therefore one is no more justified hereby then another. Secondly, You might as well say, that different degrees of faith, make different degrees of Justification. But that is not just, because it lies all on the sincerity; therefore it is as unjust here for the same reason.
Your Reason is such as I expected not from you. [For if Faith (say you) justify as a work] But who saith it doth justify as a work? Your Reader that suspecteth nothing, but fair in your words, may think I do; when I have again and again in terminis disavowed it. And do you think it is a cogent reason indeed, [If works or faith justify as a condition, there will be various degrees of Justification: Because if it justify as a work, there will be various degrees.] The reason of the Consequence is as strange to me, as a baculo ad angulum. Once more: First, Faith doth not justify as a Physical act: Secondly, Nor as a Moral act, or virtue in general. Thirdly, Nor as a mercenary