A26974:68
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To the proving of the Proposition, it must be observed, First, that the Affirmers do yield, that it is not the Doctrine or Government of Christ, but his blood that is the Ransom for one sins, and his Righteousness that is the sole Meritorious Cause of our Justification: and that believing in Christ as Prophet and King, is not a proper Instrument of our Justification; and that Christ as a Ransom for us, and a deserver of our Justification, is the formal Object of that other act (which accordingly believeth in him) and not of this act of believing in him as Prophet and King.
To the proving of the Proposition, it must be observed, First, that the Affirmers do yield, that it is not the Doctrine or Government of Christ, but his blood that is the Ransome for one sins, and his Righteousness that is the sole Meritorious Cause of our Justification: and that believing in Christ as Prophet and King, is not a proper Instrument of our Justification; and that Christ as a Ransome for us, and a deserver of our Justification, is the formal Object of that other act (which accordingly believeth in him) and not of this act of believing in him as Prophet and King.
On the other side, it is granted by them that are for the Negative, that it is our duty to believe in Christ as a Prophet and King and that it is of necessity to salvation, yet to Justification it self; For they yield that it is the Fides quae Justificat, the faith ⟨p. 3⟩by which we are Justified, but not qu• Justificat, or that it Justifieth not quà talis, as such: They yield also that it is a Condition of Justification, for so they confess that Repentance it self is; but they only say, that it is not the Instrument of Justification, as they think the other act is. So that the difference is here: They yield all that we affirm (if I can understand them;) but they affirm somewhat more themselves, which we do not yield: They grant that believing in Christ as our Teacher and Lord is a Condition of our Justification, and the •ides quae Justificat; which is all that I desire: But then they add, that the Belief in Christs blood and Righteousness is the Instrument of our Justification, and that it justifieth qu talis; which we utterly deny, if the words be properly taken; and Tropes should not upon choice be made the terms of our Question, while there are plainer to be had. So that by this time its easy to see that neither of these opinions are such as must unchurch or damn us, or make us Heretics. First, We that are for the Affirmative are out of that danger; for we hold no more positively then is yielded us by the other. All that they can charge us with; is this Negative, that [believing in Christs blood doth not properly Justify as an Instrument (that is, as an efficient Instrumental Cause of our Justification) nor yet qu talis:] And I think they will not lay our salvation on the Affirmative, when they consider what we yield (of which more anon) And on the other side, we are far from passing any damning sentence on them that are for the said Instrumentality; especially as we perceive it commonly held. Let no Papist therefore insult over us and say, we are disagreed in our fundamentals, unless he be resolved to do it in design against the light of his own conscience. I the rather premise this Caution, because I hear that the Papists do mutter thus against us already to silly people that cannot see their deceit: They say, [Is not the death of Christ a fundamental? and yet some say that he died for All, and some say he died only for the Elect;