A26974:692
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answer, I doubt not but that God is the only Principal efficient Cause, and his Promise or Covenant the Instrumental: therefore I cannot think as others, that man is the efficient Instrumental by believing, or that Faith is such: But what Is all therefore attributed to God? Even the performance of the Conditions on mans part? Or are there no such conditions which man must perform himself or perish? God only covereth sin, imputeth Righteousness, &c. but to none who have not performed the Conditions. Is Believing attributed to God, or is it an act of man? Or is it excluded? When will you prove the Consequence of this Argument? Your fifth Argument is, [because the Assertion is universal without works in general] Answer, 1. Doth not the Apostle contradict you by expounding himself in the very next verse before those you cite? Rom. 4.4. That by works he means not simply good Actions, as James doth, but such as make the reward to be of debt and not of Grace? Indeed such works are universally excluded. 2. Therefore he excludes the very presence of works, and saith, to him that worketh not, &c. ver. 5. But the presence of good actions you say is not excluded. Your last Argument seems to me the same with the fourth, and it forceth me to admire that you should think the consequence good. Blessedness is when sin is forgiven; therefore no work or good act performed by man is the condition of forgiveness, either as begun or continued, or consummate] If this be not your consequence, you say nothing against me: if it be, I assure you it is not in my Power to believe it, nor to discern the least shadow of probability of truth in it, nor to free it from the charge of being the grossest Antinomianism (si pace tui ità dicam.) And here I must needs tell you also my utter disability to reconcile you with your self; for you before say, they are media ordinata, and here you say, They are excluded under any notion: As if to be a medium were no notion; or the medium did nothing in or to the very justifying of the person. To my next Answer. If works be excluded under any notion, then James his words cannot be true, that we are justified by works. ⟨p. 192⟩You reply, If there be justifying works, how saith Paul true? I answer. This is a most evident Petitio principii. It is undeniable that James includeth works under some notion: and that Paul excludeth them under some other notion:
Answer, I doubt not but that God is the only Principal efficient Cause, and his Promise or Covenant the Instrumental: therefore I cannot think as others, that man is the efficient Instrumental by believing, or that Faith is such: But what Is all therefore attributed to God? Even the performance of the Conditions on mans part? Or are there no such conditions which man must perform himself or perish? God only covereth sin, imputeth Righteousness, &c. but to none who have not performed the Conditions. Is Believing attributed to God, or is it an act of man? Or is it excluded? When will you prove the Consequence of this Argument? Your fifth Argument is, [because the Assertion is universal without works in general] Answer, 1. Doth not the Apostle contradict you by expounding himself in the very next verse before those you cite?