A26974:693
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
now therefore I might well ask, How saith James true else? Because my supposition cannot be denied: But you suppose that Paul excludeth works under any notion, (which is the very Question, and is denied.) When you ask how saith Paul true? Paul saith true because he speaks of works strictly taken, as is by himself explained: James could not say true, if works under every notion (as you say) be excluded. Next you come to reconcile them by expounding James; where you say, Faith which in respect of its Act ad intra, only justifies, yet it works ad extra: fides quae viva, non qua viva. I answer. Whats this to the Question? The Question is not whether Faith work? Nor whether Faith justify? Nor what Faith justifieth? But in what sense James saith, we are justified by works, and not by Faith only? You answer by a direct contradiction to James, (if I can reach the sense of your Answer) saying, It is by Faith only, and that not as it liveth, &c. So dare not I directly say, it is not by works, when God saith it is: but think I am bound to distinguish, and show in what sense works justify, and in what not; and not to say flatly against God, that we are not justified by works under any notion, but only by the Faith which worketh. A denial of Gods Assertions is an ill expounding of them. To what you say of the judgement of the Orthodox, [that they go eadem via et si non eadem semita] I answer, you may understand your distinction as you please, but I have showed the difference: some understand it of justification before God; others before men, &c. And if you please to make the way wide enough, you may take me among the Orthodox, that go eadem via: if not, I will stand out with James. When you say [they exclude works under any notion in the act of justification.] I answer, 1. Your self include them as antecedents and concomitants (thought I do not,) 2. I have showed before that [in the act, &c.] is ambiguous. If you mean [as Agents of Causes], so do I exclude them. If you mean [as ⟨p. 193⟩conditions required by the new Law to the continuing and consummating our justification] I have showed you that Divines do judge otherwise. My next answer was [If works under any notion be excluded, then faith is excluded] You reply 1. [Thus Bellarmine, &c.] Answ. I knew indeed that Bellarmine saith so.
now therefore I might well ask, How saith James true else? Because my supposition cannot be denyed: But you suppose that Paul excludeth works under any notion, (which is the very Question, and is denyed.) When you ask how saith Paul true? Paul saith true because he speaks of works strictly taken, as is by himself explained: James could not say true, if works under every notion (as you say) be excluded. Next you come to reconcile them by expounding James; where you say, Faith which in respect of its Act ad intra, only justifies, yet it works ad extra: fides quae viva, non qua viva. I answer. Whats this to the Question? The Question is not whether Faith work? Nor whether Faith justifie? Nor what Faith justifieth? But in what sence James saith, we are justified by works, and not by Faith only? You answer by a direct contradiction to James, (if I can reach the sence of your Answer) saying, It is by Faith only, and that not as it liveth, &c. So dare not I directly say, it is not by works, when God saith it is: but think I am bound to distinguish, and shew in what sence works justifie, and in what not; and not to say flatly against God, that we are not justified by works under any notion, but only by the Faith which worketh. A denyal of Gods Assertions is an ill expounding of them. To what you say of the judgement of the Orthodox, [that they go eadem via et si non eadem semita] I answer, you may understand your distinction as you please, but I have shewed the difference: some understand it of justification before God; others before men, &c. And if you please to make the way wide enough, you may take me among the Orthodox, that go eadem via: if not, I will stand out with James. When you say [they exclude works under any notion in the act of justification.] I answer, 1. Your self include them as antecedents and concomitants (thought I do not,) 2. I have shewed before that [in the act, &c.] is ambiguous. If you mean [as Agents of Causes], so do I exclude them. If you mean [as