A26974:694
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But Sir, you speak to one that is very near Gods tribunal, and therefore is resolved to look after naked truth, and not to be affrighted from it by the name either of Bellarmine or Antichrist; and who is at last brought to wink at prejudice. I am fully resolved by Gods grace to go on in the way of God as he discovereth it to me, and not to turn out of it when Bellarmine stands in it. Though the Devils believe, I will (by Gods help) believe too: and not deny Christ, because the Devils confess him. You say, Non sequitur, I prove the consequence. If all works (or acts) be excluded under any notion whatsoever, and if faith be a work or act then faith is excluded. But, &c. Ergo, &c. By the reason of your denial I understand and nothing that you deny, but [that faith is a work or act] which I never heard denied before, and I hope never shall do again. The common answer to Bellarmine is, that faith which is a work justifieth, but not as it is a work: Which answer I confess to be sound, and subscribe to it. But then according to that, faith which is a work justifieth under some notion (suppose it were under the notion of an instrument) though not under the notion of a work. But you go another way, and say, 1. Faith is passive in its instrumentality, and though to believe, be a grammatical action, its verbum activum, yet its physicè, or huper physice passive. A man by believing doth not operari, but recipere. As videre, audire, are Grammatical actions, but physical or natural passions, &c. Answer. 1. These are very sublime Assertions, quite past the reach of my capacity, and of all theirs that I use to converse with; and I dare say it is no Heresy to deny them, nor can that point be near the foundation that stands upon such props which few men can apprehend. 2. What if Faith were passive in its Instrumentality? Is it not at all an Act therefore? If it be; Then that which is an Act or Work, is not excluded under the notion of a passive Instrument; and so ⟨p. 194⟩not under every notion (I speak on your grounds. But) because you told me before that I should have spent my self against this Instrumentality of Faith if I would hit the mark; I will speak the more largely to it now: And 1. Enquire whether videre, audire, be only Grammatical Actions (as you call them) and natural passions? 2. Whether Believing be so, only verbum activum, but Physically passive?
But Sir, you speak to one that is very neer Gods tribunal, and therefore is resolved to look after naked truth, and not to be affrighted from it by the name either of Bellarmine or Antichrist; and who is at last brought to wink at prejudice. I am fully resolved by Gods grace to go on in the way of God as he discovereth it to me, and not to turn out of it when Bellarmine stands in it. Though the Divels believe, I will (by Gods help) believe too: and not deny Christ, because the Divels confess him. You say, Non sequitur, I prove the consequence. If all works (or acts) be excluded under any notion whatsoever, and if faith be a work or act then faith is excluded. But, &c. Ergo, &c. By the reason of your denyal I understand and nothing that you deny, but [that faith is a work or act] which I never heard denyed before, and I hope never shall do again. The common answer to Bellarmine is, that faith which is a work justifieth, but not as it is a work: Which answer I confess to be sound, and subscribe to it. But then according to that, faith which is a work justifieth under some notion (suppose it were under the notion of an instrument) though not under the notion of a work. But you go another way, and say, 1. Faith is passive in its instrumentality, and though to believe, be a grammatical action, its verbum activum, yet its physicè, or huper physice passive. A man by believing doth not operari, but recipere. As videre, audire, are Grammatical actions, but physical or natural passions, &c. Answer. 1. These are very sublime Assertions, quite past the reach of my capacity, and of all theirs that I use to converse with; and I dare say it is no Heresie to deny them, nor can that point be neer the foundation that stands upon such props which few men can apprehend. 2. What if Faith were passive in its Instrumentality? Is it not at all an Act therefore? If it be; Then that which is an Act or Work, is not excluded under the notion of a passive Instrument; and so