A26974:713
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answer, Scotus gives many senses of the word Instrument, and so doth Aquinas, Schibler, and most Philosophers that meddle with it: and they give some so large, as contain all causes in the world under God the first cause; In so large a sense, if any will call faith an Instrument of Justification, I will not contend with him; though yet I will not say so my self, as judging faith to be no kind of cause of it at all; but in the proper ordinary sense, as an Instrument, signifieth Causam quae influit in effectum per virtutem inferioris rationis, as Suarez, Stierius, Arnisaeus, &c. Vel Instrumentum est quod ex directione alterius principalis agentis influit ad produce•dum effectum se nobiliorem, ut Schibler, &c. So I utterly deny Faith to be an Instrument. But I will first question whether it be a physical Instrument. 2. Whether a moral? 1. And for the first, I have done it already: for seeing our acute Divines have ceased to lay any claim to it as an active Instrument, but only as a Passive; therefore having disproved what they claim, I have done enough to that. 2. Yet I will add some more: And 1. If it be a physical active Instrument, it must have a physical active Influx to ⟨p. 213⟩the producing of the Effect; but so hath not Faith to the producing of our Justification. Ergo &c. The Major is apparent from the common definition of such Instruments: The Minor will be as evident, if we consider but what Gods Act in Justification is, and then it would appear impossible that any act of ours should be such an Instrument. 1. At the great Justification at Judgement Christs act is to sentence us acquit and discharged▪ and doth our Faith activè, sixae influere ad hunc effectum? Doth it intervene between Christ and the effect? and so actively justify us? Who will say so? 2. And the act by which God justifieth us here, is by a Deed of Gift in his Gospel (as I Judge) Now 1. That doth immediately produce the effect (only supposing Faith as a condition.) 2. And it is but a moral Instrumental cause it self, and how faith can be a Physical, I know not. 3. Nay the act is but a moral act, such as a Statute or Bond acteth, and what need Faith to be a physical Instrument? 2. My second Reason is this: It is generally concluded, that Tota instrumenti causalit as est in usu & application; It ceaseth to be an Instrument, when it ceaseth to be used or acted by the principal cause:
Answer, Scotus gives many sences of the word Instrument, and so doth Aquinas, Schibler, and most Philosophers that meddle with it: and they give some so large, as contain all causes in the world under God the first cause; In so large a sence, if any will call faith an Instrument of Justification, I will not contend with him; though yet I will not say so my self, as judging faith to be no kind of cause of it at all; but in the proper ordinary sence, as an Instrument, signifieth Causam quae influit in effectum per virtutem inferioris rationis, as Suarez, Stierius, Arnisaeus, &c. Vel Instrumentum est quod ex directione alterius principalis agentis influit ad producedum effectum se nobiliorem, ut Schibler, &c. So I utterly deny Faith to be an Instrument. But I will first question whether it be a physical Instrument. 2. Whether a moral? 1. And for the first, I have done it already: for seeing our acute Divines have ceased to lay any claim to it as an active Instrument, but only as a Passive; therefore having disproved what they claim, I have done enough to that. 2. Yet I will add some more: And 1. If it be a physical active Instrument, it must have a physical active Influx to