A26974:728
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And now I shall proceed to the rest of your exceptions. My next answer to you was, that [If works under every notion are excluded (as you say they are) then repentance is excluded under the notion of a condition or preparative: But repentance under that notion is not excluded: Therefore not works under every notion. To this you reply, that [Repentance is not excluded as qualifying, but as recipient,] which what is it but a plain yielding my Minor, and so the cause: For this is as much as I say. If repentance be a work or act of ours, and not excluded under the notion of a qualification, (or as you elsewhere yield) a Medium ordinatum, and a condition, then works are not under every notion excluded. And that repentance is not recipient, how easily do I yield to you? But do you indeed think that when Paul excludeth the works of the Law, that he excludeth them only as Recipient? and not as qualifying? If so, (as this answer seems to import, seeing you will not have me here distinguish between works of Law, and of Gospel, or New Covenant) then you give abundance more to works of the Law then I do or dare: For I aver that Paul excludeth them even as qualifications, yea and the very presence of them: and that the Jews never dreamt of their works being Recipient. ⟨p. 228⟩To my next you say, [Whether Paul dispute what is our righteousness, or upon what terms it is made ours it doth not much matter] But I think it of very great moment; they being Questions so very much different, both in their sense, and importance. And whereas you think Paul speaks chiefly of the manner, I think he speaks of both, but primarily of the (quasi) materia; and of the manner or means thereto, but secondarily in reference to that. So that I think the chief Question which Paul doth debate, was, Whether we are Justified by our own works or merits, or by Another's, viz. the satisfaction of a surety? which yet because it is no way made ours but by believing, therefore he so puts the Question, whether by works of the Law, or by faith? and so that he makes them two immediate opposites not granting any tertium, I easily yield. (But of that before.) To the next you say, that [I cannot find such a figure for faith Relatively in my sense.] Answ.
And now I shall proceed to the rest of your exceptions. My next answer to you was, that [If works under every notion are excluded (as you say they are) then repentance is excluded under the notion of a condition or preparative: But repentance under that notion is not excluded: Therefore not works under every notion. To this you reply, that [Repentance is not excluded as qualifying, but as recipient,] which what is it but a plain yielding my Minor, and so the cause: For this is as much as I say. If repentance be a work or act of ours, and not excluded under the notion of a qualification, (or as you elsewhere yield) a Medium ordinatum, and a condition, then works are not under every notion excluded. And that repentance is not recipient, how easily do I yeild to you? But do you indeed think that when Paul excludeth the works of the Law, that he excludeth them only as Recipient? and not as qualifying? If so, (as this answer seems to import, seeing you will not have me here distinguish between works of Law, and of Gospel, or New Covenant) then you give abundance more to works of the Law then I do or dare: For I aver that Paul excludeth them even as qualifications, yea and the very presence of them: and that the Jews never dreamt of their works being Recipient.