A26974:836
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. W. I now come to show that both these kinds of Righteousness, Legal and Evangelical, are not absolutely necessary to Justification. — I do not undertake the Negative, and will endeavour to prove it by these demonstrations. Argument 1. If things in themselves contradictory cannot be ascribed to the same person or action, then both these kinds of Righteousness are not absolutely necessary to make up our Justification: But things in themselves contradictory cannot be ascribed to the same person or actions, Therefore—The sequel is thus proved by Paul. If it be of works, it is no more of Grace: if of Grace, then it is no more of works. What are therefore these two kinds of Righteousness, but contradictory to each other? And therefore it seemeth illogical Theology to predicate them of the same person or act, c. 12. pag. 154.
Mr. W. I now come to shew that both these kinds of Righteousness, Legal and Evangelical, are not absolutely necessary to Justification. — I do not undertake the Negative, and will endeavour to prove it by these demonstrations. Argument 1. If things in themselves contradictory cannot be ascribed to the sme person or action, then both these kinds of Righteousness are not absolutely necessary to make up our Justification: But things in themselves contradictory cannot be ascribed to the same person or actions, Therefore—The sequell is thus proved by Paul. If it be of works, it is no more of Grace: if of Grace, then it is no more of works. What are therefore these two kinds of Righteousness, but contradictory to each other? And therefore it seemeth illogical Theologie to predicate them of the same person or act, c. 12. pag. 154.
Answ. Reader, I crave thy pardon for troubling thee with the Confutation of such Impertinences, that are called Demonstrations: It is I that have the bigger part of the trouble: But how should I avoid it without wrong to the Truth? Seeing (would you think it!) there are some Readers that cannot discern the vanity of such Arguings without Assistance. 1. What a gross abuse is this to begin with, to conclude that these two sorts of Righteousness are not necessary [to make up] our Justification, when the Question was only whether they are necessary [to] our Justification. [Making up] expresseth the proper causality of the constitutive causes, (matter and form,) and not of the efficient or final; much less the Interest of all other means, such as a condition is. So that I grant him his conclusion, taking Justification as we now do Our Faith or Repentance goeth not to make it up. And yet on the by, I shall add, that if any man will needs take Justification for Sanctification, or as the Papists do comprehensively for Sanctification and Pardon both (as some Protestant