A26974:842
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. W. If nothing ought to be asserted by us which ever-throws Apostolical writings, then the necessity of a two-fold righteousness ought not to be asserted; But — Ergo. — The Sequel is proved by this Dilemma. Apostolical writings are utterly against a two-fold Righteousness in this work; therefore to assert both these kinds is to overthrow their writings. For to what purpose did Paul dispute against Justification by works of the Law, if the righteousness of Faith were not sufficient? And certainly if both were required as absolutely necessary, it would argue extreme ignorance in Paul if he should not have known it, and as great unfaithfulness if, &c.—
Mr. W. If nothing ought to be asserted by us which ever-throws Apostolical writings, then the necessity of a two-fold righteousness ought not to be asserted; But — Ergo. — The Sequel is proved by this Dilemma. Apostolical writings are utterly against a two-fold Righteousness in this work; therefore to assert both these kinds is to overthrow their writings. For to what purpose did Paul dispute against Justification by works of the Law, if the righteousness of Faith were not sufficient? And certainly if both were required as absolutely necessary, it would argue extream ignorance in Paul if he should not have known it, and as great unfaithfulness if, &c.—
Answ. Either this Writer owns the two-fold Righteousness that he disputeth against, or not: If he did not, he were an Infidel or wretched Heretic, directly denying Christ or Faith; For Christ is the one Righteousness, and faith the other. If he do own them (as I doubt not at all but he doth) is it not good service to the Church to pour out this opposition against words not understood, and to make men believe that the difference is so material as to overthrow the Scriptures? But to his Argument, I deny the consequence of the Major; and how is it proved? forsooth by a Dilemma (which other folks call an Enthymeme) Of which the Antecedent (That Apostolical writings are against a two-fold righteousness) is proved by this Writers word. A learned proof I into which this Disputations are ultimately resolved. It is the very work of Pauls Epistles to prove the necessity of this Two-fold Righteousness (unless you will with the Papists call it rather two parts of one Righteousness,) Christs merits and mans faith, one in our surety, the other wrought by him in our selves.