A26974:965
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions…
Of justification four disputations clearing and amicably defending the truth against the unnecessary oppositions of divers learned and reverend brethren / by Richard Baxter ...
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1658
Letter: To my Reverend Brother Mr. John Warner, Preacher of the Gospel at Christs Church in Han…
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In your Preface I find a Law imposed by you on your Answerer, which I have not fully observed: 1. Because I had written my Reply to your Arguments a considerable time before I saw your Preface; For it fell out that I first saw your Book without the Epistle and Preface. 2. Because I thought it fittest to follow the Method that my Subject and the Readers ••dification did require. 3. Yet did I once purpose to have answered all that was of moment in your Book against the Truth: but upon trial I found your Reasons so inconsiderable, that weariness interrupted me and put an end to my Reply, and withal I grew confident that my labour would be to little purpose. For I dare venture any Judicious Divine upon your Book without the help of a Reply: And for the rest, it is not replying that will serve turn: but either prejudice will hold them to the side that they have taken, or else they will think him in the right that hath the last word: when they have read mine, they will think that I am in the right; and when they have again read yours, they will think that you carry the cause: and when they read my Reply again they will say, you were mistaken; but usually they will go with the party that is in greatest credit, or hath most interest in them, or advantage on them. But yet I think you will find that none of your strength against me is neglected: For I can truly say, that when I think not meet to Answer all that a man hath said, I never pass by that which I take to be his strength, but purposely call out that, and leave that which I think is so grossly weak as to need no answer: So much of your ten Demands or Laws as I apprehended necessary, I have ⟨p. 315⟩here answered; supposing what I had said of the same points in my first Disputation, which I saw no Reason too often to Repeat.
In your Preface I find a Law imposed by you on your Answerer, which I have not fully observed: 1. Because I had written my Reply to your Arguments a considerable time before I saw your Preface; For it fell out that I first saw your Book without the Epistle and Preface. 2. Because I thought it fittest to follow the Method that my Subject and the Readers ••dification did require. 3. Yet did I once purpose to have answered all that was of moment in your Book against the Truth: but upon trial I found your Reasons so inconsiderable, that weariness interrupted me and put an end to my Reply, and withal I grew confident that my labour would be to little purpose. For I dare venture any Judicious Divine upon your Book without the help of a Reply: And for the rest, it is not replying that will serve turn: but either prejudice will hold them to the side that they have taken, or else they will think him in the right that hath the last word: when they have read mine, they will think that I am in the right; and when they have again read yours, they will think that you carry the cause: and when they read my Reply again they will say, you were mistaken; but usually they will go with the party that is in greatest credit, or hath most interest in them, or advantage on them. But yet I think you will find that none of your strength against me is neglected: For I can truly say, that when I think not meet to Answer all that a man hath said, I never pass by that which I take to be his strength, but purposely call out that, and leave that which I think is so grosly weak as to need no answer: So much of your ten Demands or Laws as I apprehended necessary, I have