The reasons of the Christian religion the first part, of godliness, proving by natural…
The reasons of the Christian religion the first part, of godliness, proving by natural evidence the being of God ... : the second part, of Christianity, proving by evidence supernatural and natural, the certain truth of the Christian belief ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; also an appendix defending the soul's immortality against the Somatists or Epicureans and other pseudo-philosophers.
Richard Baxter 1615–1691London: printed by R. White for Fran. Titon, 1667
[37], 604 p. : port. · 240k words · Wing B1367 · ESTC R5892
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
6. The wisdom and goodness of God saw it meet, for the right government of this world, to put the threatenings of an everlasting punishment in his Law: (and how can that man have the face to say, it was needless, or too much in the Law, with whom it proved not enough to weigh down the trifling interests of the flesh.) And if it was meet to put that penalty in the Law, it is just and meet to put that Law into execution, how many soever fall under the penalty of it, (as hath been proved.)
6. The wisdom and goodness of God saw it meet, for the right government of this world, to put the threatnings of an everlasting punishment in his Law: (and how can that man have the face to say, it was needless, or too much in the Law, with whom it proved not enough to weigh down the trifling interests of the flesh.) And if it was meet to put that penalty in the Law, it is just and meet to put that Law into execution, how many soever fall under the penalty of it, (as hath been proved.)
7. The goodness of God consisteth not in a Will to make all his creatures as great, or good and happy, as he can: but it is essentially in his infinite perfections; and expressively in the communication of so much to his creatures, as he seeth meet, and in the accomplishment of his own pleasure, by such ways of Benignity and Justice as are most suitable to his Wisdom and Holiness. Man's personal interest is an unfit rule and measure of God's goodness.
8. To recite what I said, and speak it plainlier, I confess it greatly quieteth my mind against this great objection of the numbers that are damned and cast off for ever, to consider how small a part this earth is of God's creation, as well as how sinful and impenitent. Ask any Astronomer, that hath considered the innumerable number of the fixed Stars and Planets, with their distances, and magnitude, and glory,
and the uncertainty that we have whether there be not as many more, or an hundred or thousand times as many, unseen to man, as all those which we see (considering the defectiveness of man's sight, and the Planets about Jupiter, with the innumerable Stars in the Milky way, which the Tube hath lately discovered, which man's eyes without it could not see,) I say, ask any man who knoweth these things, whether all this earth be any more in comparison of
than one Prison is to a Kingdom or Empire, or the paring of one nail, or a little mole, or wart, or a hair, in comparison of the whole body. And if God should cast off all this earth, and use all the sinners in it as they deserve, it is no more sign of a want of benignity or mercy in him, than it is for a King to cast one subject of a million into a Jail, and to hang him for his murder, or treason, or rebellion; or for a man to kill one louse, which is but a molestation to the body which beareth it; or than it is to pare a mans nails, or cut off a wart, or a hair, or to pull out a rotten aching tooth.
I know it is a thing uncertain and unrevealed to us, whether all these Globes be inhabited or not: but he that considereth, that there is scarce any uninhabitable place on earth, or in the water, or air, but men, or beasts, or birds, or fishes, or flies, or worms and moles do take up almost all, will think it a probability so near a certainty, as not to be much doubted of, that the vaster and more glorious parts of the Creation are not uninhabited; but that they have Inhabitants answerable to their magnitude and glory (as Palaces have other inhabitants than Cottages): and that there is a connaturality and agreeableness there as well as here, between the Region or Globe, and the inhabitants. But whether it be the Globes themselves, or only the inter-spaces, or other parts that are thus inhabited, no reason can doubt, but that those more vast and glorious spaces are proportionably possessed:
8. To recite what I said, and speak it plainlier, I confess it greatly quieteth my mind against this great objection of the numbers that are damned and cast off for ever, to consider how small a part this earth is of God's creation, as well as how sinful and impenitent. Ask any Astronomer, that hath considered the innumerable number of the fixed Stars and Planets, with their distances, and magnitude, and glory,1 and the uncertainty that we have whether there be not as many more, or an hundred or thousand times as many, unseen to man, as all those which we see (considering the defectiveness of man's sight, and the Planets about Jupiter, with the innumerable Stars in the Milky way, which the Tube hath lately discovered, which man's eyes without it could not see,) I say, ask any man who knoweth these things, whether all this earth be any more in comparison of ⟨p. 389⟩the whole creation,2 than one Prison is to a Kingdom or Empire, or the paring of one nail, or a little mole, or wart, or a hair, in comparison of the whole body. And if God should cast off all this earth, and use all the sinners in it as they deserve, it is no more sign of a want of benignity or mercy in him, than it is for a King to cast one subject of a million into a Jail, and to hang him for his murder, or treason, or rebellion; or for a man to kill one louse, which is but a molestation to the body which beareth it; or than it is to pare a mans nails, or cut off a wart, or a hair, or to pull out a rotten aking tooth.3 I know it is a thing uncertain and unrevealed to us, whether all these Globes be inhabited or not: but he that considereth, that there is scarce any uninhabitable place on earth, or in the water, or air, but men, or beasts, or birds, or fishes, or flies, or worms and moles do take up almost all, will think it a probability so near a certainty, as not to be much doubted of, that the vaster and more glorious parts of the Creation are not uninhabited; but that they have Inhabitants answerable to their magnitude and glory (as Palaces have other inhabitants than Cottages): and that there is a connaturality and agreeableness there as well as here, between the Region or Globe, and the inhabitants. But whether it be the Globes themselves, or only the inter-spaces, or other parts that are thus inhabited, no reason can doubt, but that those more vast and glorious spaces are proportionably possess'd:
1Of the probability of the habitation of the Planets, see Gassendus, and his reasons, that the inhabitants are not men of our species, but that the inhabitants are diversified as the habitations are, and other things in the universe.
2Though Cicero frequently derideth the superstitious fear of Hell, yet he meaneth not of all future punishment of the wicked, but of the Poets fables of Styt, Cerberus, Tantalus, and Sisyphus kind of penalties, and of Minos and Rhadamanthu• the infernal Judges.Though Cicero frequently derideth the superstitious fear of Hell, yet he meaneth not of all future punishment of the wicked, but of the Poets fables of Styt, Cerberus, Tantalus, and Sysiphus kind of penalties, and of Minos and Rhadamanthu• the infernal Judges.
3Sed Gegenetis Christus humani (inquitis) conservator advenit cur non omnes aequali munifi•entia liberat? Resp. Aequaliter liberat, qui aequa•i•et omnes vocat: Haud ab ind•lgentia principali quemquam repellit, aut respuit: qui sublimibus, infimis, servis, &c. uniformiter potestatem ven•endi ad se facit? Patet omnibus fons vitae, neque ab jure potandi quisquam prohibetur. Si tibi fastidium tantum est, ut oblati respuas beneficium muneris, quinimo si tantum sapientia praevales, ut ea quae offeruntur à Christo ludum & ineptias nomines quid invitans peccat, cujus solum sunt hae partes, ut sub tui juris arbitrio fructum suae benignitatis exponat? —An orandus es ut beneficium salutis à Deo digneris accipere, & tibi aspernanti, fugientique longissime, infundenda est in gremium divinae benevolentiae gratia? Vis sumere quod offertur, & in tuos usus converter consulueris tu tibi. Aspernaris, contemnis & despicis, te muneris commoditate privaveris. Nulli Deus infert necessitatem. Object. Nolo (inquis) & voluntatem non babeo. Resp. Quid ergo criminaris Deum, tanquam tibi desit? Opem desideras tibi ferre, cujus dona & munera non tantum asperneris & fugias, verum in alia verbà cognomines, & jocularibus facetiis prosequaris. Arnob. adv. Gent. l. 2.Sed Gegenetis Christus humani (inquitis) c•nservator advenit cur non omnes aequali munifi•entia liberat? Resp. Aequaliter liberat, qui aequa•i•et omnes vocat: Haud ab ind•lgentia principali quemquam repellit, aut respuit: qui sublimibus, infimis, servis, &c. uniformiter potestatem ven•endi ad se facit? Patet omnibus fons vitae, neque ab jure potandi quisquam prohibetur. Si tibi fastidium tantum est, ut oblati respuas beneficium muneris, quinimo si tantum sapientia praevales, ut ea quae offeruntur à Christo ludum & ineptias nomines quid invitans peccat, cujus solum sunt hae partes, ut sub tui juris arbitrio fructum suae benignitatis exponat? —An orandus es ut beneficium salutis à Deo digneris accipere, & tibi aspernanti, fugientique longissime, infundenda est in gremium divinae benevolentiae gratia? Vis sumere quod offertur, & in tuos usus convertere consulueris tu tibi. Aspernaris, contemnis & despicis, te muneris commoditate privaveris. Nulli Deus infert necessitatem. Object. Nolo (inquis) & voluntatem non babeo. Resp. Quid ergo criminaris Deum, tanquam tibi desit? Opem desideras tibi ferre, cujus dona & munera non tantum asperneris & fugias, verum in alia verbà cognomines, & jocularibus facetiis prosequaris. Arnob. adv. Gent. l. 2.
And whether they are all to be called Angels or Spirits, or by what other name, is unrevealed to us: but what ever they are called, I make no question but our number to theirs is not one to a million at the most.
Now this being so, for ought we know those glorious parts may have inhabitants without any sin or misery; who are filled with their Makers love and goodness; and so are fitter to be the demonstration of that love and goodness, than this sinful mole-hill or dungeon of ignorance is. If I were sure that God would save all mankind, and only leave the devils in their damnation, and forsake no part of his Creation but their Hell, it would not be any great stumbling to my faith: Or if Earth were all God's creation, and I were sure that he would condemn but one man of a hundred thousand, or a million, and that only for final impenitency in the contempt of the mercy which would have saved him; this would be no great difficulty to my faith. Why then should it be an offence to us, if God, for their final refusal of his grace, do for ever forsake and punish the far greater part of this little dark and sinful world, while he glorifieth his Benignity and Love abundantly upon innumerable Angels, and blessed Spirits, and inhabitants of those more large and glorious seats? If you would judge of the Beneficence of a King, will you go to the Jail and the Gallows to discern it, or to his Palace and all the rest of his Kingdom? And will you make a few condemned malefactors the measure of it? or all the rest of his obedient prosperous subjects? If Hell be totally forsaken of God, as having totally forsaken him; and if Earth have made it self next to Hell, and be forsaken as to the far greater part, because that greater part hath forsaken him; as long as there may be millions of blessed ones above, to one of these forsaken ones on earth, it should be no offence to any but the selfish guilty sinner. I confess I rather look on it as a great demonstration of God's holiness and goodness in his Justice, that he will punish the rebellious according to his Laws; and a great demonstration of his Goodness in his Mercy, that he will save any of such a rebellious world, and hath not forsaken it utterly as Hell:1 And when of all the thousands of Worlds or Globes which he hath made, we know of none forsaken by him, but Hell, and part of the Earth, all the Devils, and most of Men; we should admire the glory of his bounty, and be thankful with joy, that we are not of the forsaken number; and that even among sinners, he will cast off none but those that finally reject his mercy.
1Eunomiani minas futuri supplicii & gehennae, non ad veritatem, sed ad metum prolatas aiebant. Hermenopul. de Sectis. Sect. 13.
But selfishness and sense do make men blind, and judge of Good and Evil only by self-interest and feeling; and the malefactor will hardly magnify Justice, nor take it to be a sign of Goodness: But God will be God whether selfish rebels will or not.
But selfishness and sense do make men blinde, and judge of Good and Evil only by self-interest and feeling; and the malefactor will hardly magnifie Justice, nor take it to be a sign of Goodness: But God will be God whether selfish rebels will or not.
Obj. That any thing existeth besides God cannot be known but by sense or history: Have you either of these for those Inhabitants? And if we may go by Conjectures, for ought you know there may as many of those Worlds be damned, as of earthly men.
Ans. 1. Some men are so little conscious of their humanity, that they think that nothing is known at all: But he that knoweth by sense that He is himself, and that there is a World about him, and then by Reason that there is a God, may know also by Reason that there are other Creatures which he never saw: Neither sense nor history told us of the inhabitants of the (then) unknown parts of the World; and yet it had been easy to gather at least a strong probability that there are such. He that knoweth that an intelligent Nature is better than a non-intelligent, and then knoweth that God hath made man intelligent, and then thinketh what difference there is in matter, magnitude and glory, between the dirty body of Man with the Earth he liveth in, and those vast and glorious Ethereal spaces; will quickly judge that it is a thing incredible, that God should have no Creatures nobler than man, nor imprint more of his Image upon any in those more glorious Regions, than on us that dwell as Snails in such a shell; or that there should be such a strange disproportion in the works of God, as that a punctum of dirty earth only should be possessed of the Divine or Intellectual nature, and the vast and glorious Orbs or Spaces be made only to look on, or to serve these mortal Worms: But proofs go according to the preparation of the Receivers mind: Nothing is a proof to the unprepared and prejudiced.
Ans. 1. Some men are so little conscious of their humanity, that they think that nothing is known at all: But he that knoweth by sense that He is himself, and that there is a World about him, and then by Reason that there is a God, may know also by Reason that there are other Creatures which he never saw: Neither sense nor history told us of the inhabitants of the (then) unknown parts of the World; and yet it had been easie to gather at least a strong probability that there are such. He that knoweth that an intelligent Nature is better than a non-intelligent, and then knoweth that God hath made man intelligent, and then thinketh what difference there is in matter, magnitude and glory, between the dirty body of Man with the Earth he liveth in, and those vast and glorious Ethereal spaces; will quickly judge that it is a thing incredible, that God should have no Creatures nobler than man, nor imprint more of his Image upon any in those more glorious Regions, than on us that dwell as Snails in such a shell; or that there should be such a strange disproportion in the works of God, as that a punctum of dirty earth only should be possessed of the Divine or Intellectual nature, and the vast and glorious Orbs or Spaces be made only to look on, or to serve these mortal Worms: But proofs go according to the preparation of the Receivers minde: Nothing is a proof to the unprepared and prejudiced.
2. We have sense by the Telescope to tell us, that the Moon hath parts unequal, and looketh much like the habitable Earth: And we have sense to tell us, that there are Witches and Apparitions, and consequently other kind of intellectual Wights than we. And we have History to tell us ⟨p. 392⟩of the appearances and offices of Angels: And if there be certainly such wights, our eyes may help us to conjecture at their Numbers (compared to us) by the spaces which they inhabit.
2. We have sense by the Telescope to tell us, that the Moon hath parts unequal, and looketh much like the habitable Earth: And we have sense to tell us, that there are Witches and Apparitions, and consequently other kinde of intellectual Wights than we. And we have History to tell us ⟨p. 392⟩of the appearances and offices of Angels: And if there be certainly such wights, our eyes may help us to conjecture at their Numbers (compared to us) by the spaces which they inhabit.
3. There is a proportion and harmony in all the works of God: And therefore we that see how much the superior Orbs do in glory excel this dirty Earth, have reason to think that the nature of the Inhabitants is suited to their Habitations; and consequently that they are more excellent Creatures than we, and therefore less sinful, and therefore more happy.
3. There is a proportion and harmony in all the works of God: And therefore we that see how much the superiour Orbs do in glory excell this dirty Earth, have reason to think that the nature of the Inhabitants is suited to their Habitations; and consequently that they are more excellent Creatures than we, and therefore less sinfull, and therefore more happy.
4. Yet after all this, I am neither asserting that all this is so, nor bound to prove it. I only argue, that you who are offended at the numbers that sin and perish, do wrangle in the dark, and speak against you know not what. Conjecture is enough for me, to prove that you do foolishly to argue against experience (of the sin and misery of the most) upon mere uncertainties. You will not censure the actions of a Prince or General, when your ignorance of their Counsels maketh you uncertain of the cause; yea and of the matter of fact it self. The proof lieth on your part, and not on mine: You say, our doctrine is incredible, because so few are saved, and yet confess that for ought you know, taking all together it may be many millions for one that perisheth. I think by proving you uncertain of this, I prove you foolish in your Infidelity. And if you will conjecture then, that there may as many of those other Regions be damned, 1. You show your selves much more harsh in your censures than the Christians are, whose harshness you are now reproving: Yea you conjecture this without all ground or probability. And will you say then, For ought I know it may be so, Ergo, Christianity is incredible? Can a groundless conjecture allow any rational man such a Conclusion?
4. Yet after all this, I am neither asserting that all this is so, nor bound to prove it. I only argue, that you who are offended at the numbers that sin and perish, do wrangle in the dark, and speak against you know not what. Conjecture is enough for me, to prove that you do foolishly to argue against experience (of the sin and misery of the most) upon meer uncertainties. You will not censure the actions of a Prince or Generall, when your ignorance of their Counsels maketh you uncertain of the cause; yea and of the matter of fact it self. The proof lyeth on your part, and not on mine: You say, our doctrine is incredible, because so few are saved, and yet confess that for ought you know, taking all together it may be many millions for one that perisheth. I think by proving you uncertain of this, I prove you foolish in your Infidelity. And if you will conjecture then, that there may as many of those other Regions be damned, 1. You shew your selves much more harsh in your censures than the Christians are, whose harshness you are now reproving: Yea you conjecture this without all ground or probability. And will you say then, For ought I know it may be so, Ergo, Christianity is incredible? Can a groundless conjecture allow any rational man such a Conclusion?
Answ. But we say not how many: we never said that it is the whole number of the Glorious Inhabitants of all the superior World, who are called Angels, as Messengers or Officers about man: we know not how small a part of them comparatively it may be: And of them we know not ⟨p. 393⟩how few fell. Augustine conjectured that it was the tenth part; but we have no ground for any such conjecture.
Answ. But we say not how many: we never said that it is the whole number of the Glorious Inhabitants of all the superiour World, who are called Angels, as Messengers or Officers about man: we know not how small a part of them comparatively it may be: And of them we know not ⟨p. 393⟩how few fell. Augustine conjectured that it was the tenth part; but we have no ground for any such conjecture.
Ans. 1. To them that know what Generation is, and what the Son is to the Father, it is not incredible at all that the unholy Parents do not beget holy Children, nor convey to them that which they have not themselves: nor yet that God should hate the unholy: Nor that the Parents choice should signify much for their Children's state, who have no wills of their own fit for actual choice; nor that restored imperfect holiness should not be conveyed to Children by natural propagation; which came to the Parents by Regeneration: nor that the Children of Traitors should be disinherited for their Fathers faults: nor that the Children of Drunkards and Gluttons should be naturally diseased.
Ans. 1. To them that know what Generation is, and what the Son is to the Father, it is not incredible at all that the unholy Parents do not beget holy Children, nor convey to them that which they have not themselves: nor yet that God should hate the unholy: Nor that the Parents choice should signifie much for their Childrens state, who have no wills of their own fit for actual choice; nor that restored imperfect holiness should not be conveyed to Children by natural propagation; which came to the Parents by Regeneration: nor that the Children of Traytors should be disinherited for their Fathers faults: nor that the Children of Drunkards and Gluttons should be naturally diseased.
2. No man in the World doth perish for Adams sin alone without his own: (Though we judge the case of Infants to allow you no exception, yet to carry the controversy to them into the dark, and to argue à minus notis, is not the property of such as seek impartially for truth.) Christ hath procured a new Covenant upon which all those that hear the Gospel, shall again be tried for life or death: And those that hear it not, have divers means which have a tendency to their recovery, and are under undeniable Obligations to use those means in order to their recovery: which if they do not faithfully, they perish for their own sin. Should it not make Christianity the more easily credible, when certain experience assureth us, how prone even Infants are to sin, and how universally the World is drowned in wickedness; and then to find so admirable and suitable a Remedy revealed?
2. No man in the World doth perish for Adams sin alone without his own: (Though we judge the case of Infants to allow you no exception, yet to carry the controversie to them into the dark, and to argue à minus notis, is not the property of such as seek impartially for truth.) Christ hath procured a new Covenant upon which all those that hear the Gospel, shall again be tryed for life or death: And those that hear it not, have divers means which have a tendency to their recovery, and are under undenyable Obligations to use those means in order to their recovery: which if they do not faithfully, they perish for their own sin. Should it not make Christianity the more easily credible, when certain experience assureth us, how prone even Infants are to sin, and how universally the World is drown'd in wickedness; and then to finde so admirable and suitable a Remedy revealed?