My task therefore in this conclusion, shall be only to defend the doctrine delivered in this fore-going Treatise, of the Life to come, 1or the Soul's Immortality, against some who call themselves Philosophers. For of men so called, it is but a small part who at all gainsay this weighty truth. The followers of Plato the Divine Philosopher, with the Pythagoreans, the Stoics, the Cynics, and divers other Sects, are so much for it, that indeed the most of them go too far, and make the soul to be eternal both à part art, and à part post: and Cicero doth conclude from its self-moving power, that it is certainly eternal and divine: Insomuch that not only Arnobius, but many other ancient Christians, write so much against Plato for holding the soul to be naturally immortal, and assert themselves, that it is of a middle nature, between that which is naturally immortal, 2and that which is merely mortal, that he that doth not well understand them, may be scandalized at their expressions, and think that he readeth the Philosopher defending the souls immortality, and the Christian opposing it. And though Aristotle's opinion be questioned by many, yet Cicero, who lived in time and places wherein he had better advantage than we to know his meaning, doth frequently affirm, that he was in the main of Plato's mind; and that the Academics, Peripatetics and Stoics differed more in words than sense; chiding the Stoics for their schism or separation, in setting up a School or Sect as new, which had almost nothing new but words. Not only Fernelius (de abditis rerum causis) but many others have vindicated Aristotle, however his obscurity hath given men occasion to keep up that controversy. And if the book de Mundo be undoubtedly his, I see no reason to make any more question of his meaning; much less if that book be his which is entitled, Mystica Egypt. & Chald. Philos. which Aben Ama Arabs translated out of Greek into Arabic, which Franc. Roseus brought from Damascus, and Moses Rovas Medicus Haebr. translated into Italian, and Pet. ⟨p. 493⟩Nicol. Castelinus into Latin, and Patricius thinketh Aristotle took from Plato's mouth.
My task therefore in this conclusion, shall be only to defend the doctrine delivered in this fore-going Treatise, of the Life to come, 1or the Soul's Immortality, against some who call themselves Philosophers. For of men so called, it is but a small part who at all gainsay this weighty truth. The followers of Plato the Divine Philosopher, with the Pythagoreans, the Stoicks, the Cynicks, and divers other Sects, are so much for it, that indeed the most of them go too far, and make the soul to be eternal both à parte arte, and à parte post: and Cicero doth conclude from its self-moving power, that it is certainly eternal and divine: Insomuch that not only Arnobius, but many other ancient Christians, write so much against Plato for holding the soul to be naturally immortal, and assert themselves, that it is of a middle nature, between that which is naturally immortal, 2and that which is meerly mortal, that he that doth not well understand them, may be scandalized at their expressions, and think that he readeth the Philosopher defending the souls immortality, and the Christian opposing it. And though Aristotle's opinion be questioned by many, yet Cicero, who lived in time and places wherein he had better advantage than we to know his meaning, doth frequently affirm, that he was in the main of Plato's mind; and that the Academicks, Peripateticks and Stoicks differed more in words than sense; chiding the Stoicks for their schism or separation, in setting up a School or Sect as new, which had almost nothing new but words. Not only Fernelius (de abditis rerum causis) but many others have vindicated Aristotle, however his obscurity hath given men occasion to keep up that controversie. And if the book de Mundo be undoubtedly his, I see no reason to make any more question of his meaning; much less if that book be his which is entitled, Mystica Aegypt. & Chald. Philos. which Aben Ama Arabs translated out of Greek into Arabick, which Franc. Roseus brought from Damascus, and Moses Rovas Medicus Haebr. translated into Italian, and Pet. ⟨p. 493⟩Nicol. Castelinus into Latine, and Patricius thinketh Aristotle took from Plato's mouth.
- 1Galen is known to speak many objections against Plato, and the Soul's immortality: but in other places he speaketh doubtfully. And if really Ne•esius had those words out of such a book of Galen, as he citeth, de Ani. c. 2. p. 481. he would then seem to have thought better of the Rational Soul.
- 2Plotinus his last words were (as Porphyry saith in his life) [I am now returning that which is Divine in us, to that which is Divine in the Universe.]