A27004:2151
The reasons of the Christian religion the first part, of godliness, proving by natural…
The reasons of the Christian religion the first part, of godliness, proving by natural evidence the being of God ... : the second part, of Christianity, proving by evidence supernatural and natural, the certain truth of the Christian belief ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; also an appendix defending the soul's immortality against the Somatists or Epicureans and other pseudo-philosophers.
London: printed by R. White for Fran. Titon, 1667
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. 1. It is easy for men, that set themselves to say all they can, either with Mr. Chamber to extol the brutes as rational, or with Gassendus to talk of the whispers and consultations of the Ants, or with Telesius and Campanella to say that every thing hath sense; or on the other hand with Cartesius, to deny all to a brute which belongeth not to an engine. But our converse with them doth teach all men to judge of their natures, as between both these extremes, unless by study and learning they learn to know less than they did before, and do but study to corrupt their understandings, and obliterate things that are commonly known. I doubt not but the Minerals have something like life, and ⟨p. 524⟩the Vegetatives have something like to sense, and the Sensitives have something like to reason: but it doth not follow that therefore it is the same. But this is so copiously written of by very many, that I supersede my further labour about it.
Answ. 1. It is easie for men, that set themselves to say all they can, either with Mr. Chambre to extol the bruits as rational, or with Gassendus to talk of the whispers and consultations of the Ants, or with Telesius and Campanella to say that every thing hath sense; or on the other hand with Cartesius, to deny all to a bruit which belongeth not to an engine. But our converse with them doth teach all men to judge of their natures, as between both these extremes, unless by study and learning they learn to know less than they did before, and do but study to corrupt their understandings, and obliterate things that are commonly known. I doubt not but the Minerals have something like life, and ⟨p. 524⟩the Vegetatives have something like to sense, and the Sensitives have something like to reason: but it doth not follow that therefore it is the same. But this is so copiously written of by very many, that I supersede my further labour about it.
2. If it were so, that the apprehensions of a brute might be called Reason or Intellection, yet the difference betwixt it and humane Intellection is so great, as may easily prove to those that have their reasons in free use, that they are several species of creatures, made for several uses and ends. And none of the twenty Arguments which I used, are at all debilitated by this. If a bird have reason to build her nest, and to feed her young, yet she hath none to build Cities and Castles, nor to use Navigation, nor any of the Arts: much less to set up Government by Laws, and to write Systems of Philosophy and other Sciences; and least of all to enquire after God, the cause of all things, or to hope for blessedness in another life, or to escape a future misery, or to be ruled in this life by the interest of another. Beasts think not of God, nor of loving him, seeking him, pleasing him or enjoying him, or of being judged by him. I know the perverse wrangler will ask me, How I know this? And I can answer him no better than thus: As I know that a Stone doth not see or feel, or that my Paper doth not talk; because they manifest no such thing: And these are all operations which they that exercise, are apt to manifest; and things that in their nature are unapt to be long hid. Campanella, who hath written de sensu rerum, to prove Brutes Rational, and Plants sensible, hath yet in his Atheismus Triumphatus written more for the excellency of humane nature and the Souls immortality; than any Infidel can soundly answer.