Answ. 1The world of learned men do find themselves too much work, and trouble others with controversies about names and words, and especially by confounding words and things, and not discerning when a controversy is only de nomine, and when it is de re. And they have done so about forms as much as any thing. The word form is usually liable to this ambiguity: In compounded beings, it is sometime taken for the active predominant part or principle; and sometimes for the state which resulteth from the contemperation of all the parts. Which is the fittest to be called the form, is but a question de nomine. Gassendus himself confesseth this ambiguity of the word, and having pleaded that all forms, except man's intellectual soul, are but modes or qualities of bodies, and accidents. He addeth, §. 1. l. 6. c. 1. Si formae nomine spiritum quendam & quasi florem materiae intellexeris, cujusmodifere concipimus animam in equo, tum forma dici potest substantia, immo & corpus tenuissimum, quod crassius pervadat, perficiat & regat — At si formae nomine intelligatur dispositio ac modus quo tam substantia illa spirituosior quam crassior reliqua se habet, & ad quam facultates actionesque naturales consequuntur tum posse Qualitatem conseri ac dici. Whether the souls of brutes be only the spirits, or the flos materiae, or not, it is granted by him, and by almost all men, that in mixed bodies there is one part more subtle than the rest, which is the most active, powerful, predominant part, and which doth corpus pervadere, perficere, regere. He thinketh that this is but that subtle matter which others call fire; but others think upon the reasons before given, that it is a superior nature, and that the spirits, or fiery nature, is but its nearest instrument: Because no subtlety will make atoms sensible or appetitive, which in their proper nature have no such thing. But what ever becomes of the controversy, whether the animal principle in brutes be material or immaterial, ⟨p. 536⟩it is granted us, and is certain, that in all mixed beings, there is a difference of the constitutive parts: as the fiery nature (such as the Sun is of) is active in comparison of the other three Elements, which to it are passive; so the vital principle in brutes is active, powerful and regent, as to the rest of the compounding parts.
Answ. 1The world of learned men do find themselves too much work, and trouble others with controversies about names and words, and especially by confounding words and things, and not discerning when a controversie is only de nomine, and when it is de re. And they have done so about forms as much as any thing. The word form is usually liable to this ambiguity: In compounded beings, it is sometime taken for the active predominant part or principle; and sometimes for the state which resulteth from the contemperation of all the parts. Which is the fittest to be called the form, is but a question de nomine. Gassendus himself confesseth this ambiguity of the word, and having pleaded that all forms, except man's intellectual soul, are but modes or qualities of bodies, and accidents. He addeth, §. 1. l. 6. c. 1. Si formae nomine spiritum quendam & quasi florem materiae intellexeris, cujusmodifere concipimus animam in equo, tum forma dici potest substantia, immo & corpus tenuissimum, quod crassius pervadat, perficiat & regat — At si formae nomine intelligatur dispositio ac modus quo tam substantia illa spirituosior quam crassior reliqua se habet, & ad quam facultates actionesque naturales consequuntur tum posse Qualitatem conseri ac dici. Whether the souls of bruits be only the spirits, or the flos materiae, or not, it is granted by him, and by almost all men, that in mixt bodies there is one part more subtil than the rest, which is the most active, powerful, predominant part, and which doth corpus pervadere, perficere, regere. He thinketh that this is but that subtil matter which others call fire; but others think upon the reasons before given, that it is a superiour nature, and that the spirits, or fiery nature, is but its nearest instrument: Because no subtilty will make atoms sensible or appetitive, which in their proper nature have no such thing. But what ever becomes of the controversie, whether the animal principle in bruits be material or immaterial, ⟨p. 536⟩it is granted us, and is certain, that in all mixed beings, there is a difference of the constitutive parts: as the fiery nature (such as the Sun is of) is active in comparison of the other three Elements, which to it are passive; so the vital principle in bruits is active, powerful and regent, as to the rest of the compounding parts.
- 1Lege Plotinum de Anim. En. 4. l. 3. c. 391. sect. 26.