A27004:2290
The reasons of the Christian religion the first part, of godliness, proving by natural…
The reasons of the Christian religion the first part, of godliness, proving by natural evidence the being of God ... : the second part, of Christianity, proving by evidence supernatural and natural, the certain truth of the Christian belief ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; also an appendix defending the soul's immortality against the Somatists or Epicureans and other pseudo-philosophers.
London: printed by R. White for Fran. Titon, 1667
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
OBJECTION XVI.
Both Soul and Body are like a Candle in fluxu continuo; and we have not the same substance this Week or Year as we had the last, there being a continual consumption or transition and accretion: Ergo, being not the same, we are uncapable of a Life of future Retribution. Will you reward and punish the man that is, or the man that was?
BOth Soul and Body are like a Candle in fluxu continuo; and we have not the same substance this Week or Year as we had the last, there being a continual consumption or transition and accretion: Ergo, being not the same, we are uncapable of a Life of future Retribution. Will you reward and punish the man that is, or the man that was?
Answ. It is a foolish thing to carry great and certain Truths into the dark, and to argue against them à minus notis, from mere uncertainties. As to your simile, I confess that the Oil of your Candle is still wasting, so is the wick; but not that new is added to make it another thing, unless it be a Lamp. I confess, that the lucid fume which we call the flame is still passing away. But whether the fiery Principle (in its essence not visible, but only in its Light) be not still the same till all the passive matter be consumed, is more ⟨p. 570⟩than you know. So also if you argue from the Vegetative life of a Tree: Whether the same Principle of Vegetation (enlarging it self) continue not to the end to individuate the Tree, though all the passive Elements (Earth, Water, and Air) may be in fluxu and a transient state? It is certain, that some fixed Principle of Individuation there is, from whence it must be denominated the same. The water of the hasty River would not be called the same River, if the Channel which it runs in were not the same: Nor your Candle be called the same Candle, if some of the first Wick or Oil at least did not remain, or the same fire continue it, or the same Candlestick hold it. And what is it in the Tree which is still the same? or what in the Bird that flieth about, which is still the same? when you have searched all, you will find nothing so likely as the vital Principle, and yet that something there must be.