A27006:1829
Reliquiæ Baxterianæ, or, Mr. Richard Baxters narrative of the most memorable passages of his…
Reliquiæ Baxterianæ, or, Mr. Richard Baxters narrative of the most memorable passages of his life and times faithfully published from his own original manuscript by Matthew Sylvester.Reliquiæ Baxterianæ, or, Mr. Richard Baxters narrative of the most memorable passages of his life and times faithfully publish'd from his own original manuscript by Matthew Sylvester.
London: printed for T. Parkhurst, 1696
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But such is the commanding that now you are supposed to speak of—Ergo—So still your distinguishing toucheth not our Argument: no more than if you had distinguished of the Instructed and Uninstructed, and said Paul speaketh of those that were uninstructed only, Ergo he is not alleged to the purpose. Whereas you say [That this penalty, that the Minister be enjoined not to administer the Communion to those that disobey such command, is no ways inconsistent with the Receiving, and all the Indulgences of that Truth] We shall prove the contrary anon in due place. For appellation to indifferent persons, we also are willing such shall judge, whether if your Distinction speak of no commanding but such as is consistent with this [Receiving, Forbearing, &c.] it leave us not in possession of the force of our Argument? and if it speak de jure, that there should be no other, whether it yield not up the Cause? It seems our very phrase of begging the Question being misunderstood by you, hath been taken as your greatest occasion of insulting: But if we used an unusual Phrase, if that occasioned your mistake, we can beg your pardon, and explain it, with less wrong to our Cause or our selves, than you can make such use of it, as to yours. We did not dream of charging you with that begging of the Question which is the fallacy and fault of the Opponent, as it is the begging of a Principle undertaken to be proved: we know this is not incident ot the Respondent, nor to be imputed to him: we charged you with no such thing: though we confess our Phrase was liable to your misinterpretation: But we crave your willingness to understand, that we were proving that such things may not be by Rulers enjoined or commanded under the penalty of Exclusion from Communion! and that the latter Branch of your Distinction hath the nature of a Reason of your denial of the Proposition denied, viz. because the things are commanded; and that by our telling you of begging the Question, we mean but this much; 1. That you give us a Reason implied in a Distinction, which is but equal to a simple Negation, and is not (we say not the giving a sufficient Reason, but) the giving of a Reason indeed at all. 2. That it is but equal to an unsavoury Denial of the mere Conclusion. 3. Yea, that it is a preposterous Reduction of the Rule to the Action; and of the former to the latter.
But such is the commanding that now you are supposed to speak of—Ergo—So still your distinguishing toucheth not our Argument: no more than if you had distinguished of the Instructed and Uninstructed, and said Paul speaketh of those that were uninstructed only, Ergo he is not alledged to the purpose. Whereas you say [That this penalty, that the Minister be enjoyned not to administer the Communion to those that disobey such command, is no ways inconsistent with the Receiving, and all the Indulgences of that Truth] We shall prove the contrary anon in due place. For appellation to indifferent persons, we also are willing such shall judge, whether if your Distinction speak of no commanding but such as is consistent with this [Receiving, Forbearing, &c.] it leave us not in possession of the force of our Argument? and if it speak de jure, that there should be no other, whether it yield not up the Cause? It seems our very phrase of begging the Question being misunderstood by you, hath been taken as your greatest occasion of insulting: But if we used an unusual Phrase, if that occasioned your mistake, we can beg your pardon, and explain it, with less wrong to our Cause or our selves, than you can make such use of it, as to yours. We did not dream of charging you with that begging of the Question which is the fallacy and fault of the Opponent, as it is the begging of a Principle undertaken to be proved: we know this is not incident ot the Respondent, nor to be imputed to him: we charged you with no such thing: though we confess our Phrase was liable to your misinterpretation: But we crave your willingness to understand, that we were proving that such things may not be by Rulers enjoyned or commanded under the penalty of Exclusion from Communion! and that the latter Branch of your Distinction hath the nature of a Reason of your denial of the Proposition denied, viz. because the things are commanded; and that by our telling you of begging the Question, we mean but this much; 1. That you give us a Reason implied in a Distinction, which is but equal to a simple Negation, and is not (we say not the giving a sufficient Reason, but) the giving of a Reason indeed at all. 2. That it is but equal to an unsavoury Denial of the meer Conclusion. 3. Yea, that it is a preposterous Reduction of the Rule to the Action; and of the former to the latter.