A27006:2385
Reliquiæ Baxterianæ, or, Mr. Richard Baxters narrative of the most memorable passages of his…
Reliquiæ Baxterianæ, or, Mr. Richard Baxters narrative of the most memorable passages of his life and times faithfully published from his own original manuscript by Matthew Sylvester.Reliquiæ Baxterianæ, or, Mr. Richard Baxters narrative of the most memorable passages of his life and times faithfully publish'd from his own original manuscript by Matthew Sylvester.
London: printed for T. Parkhurst, 1696
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
nor will we contract that odium with the People, nor contribute so much to betray them by deceiving them! And if we should do it, we are assured we shall be never the better for it: for the Toleration shall be clogged with the Renunciation of all Obligations from the Covenant, or some one other particular Condition, which shall seem no matter of Religion, which they know we will not conform to, and the Papists will; and so when we have petitioned for a Common Liberty, we shall have the odium, and they only the Liberty. And thus they sate still, and meddled not with that Business.
nor will we contract that odium with the People, nor contribute so much to betray them by deceiving them! And if we should do it, we are assured we shall be never the better for it: for the Toleration shall be clogged with the Renunciation of all Obligations from the Covenant, or some one other particular Condition, which shall seem no matter of Religion, which they know we will not conform to, and the Papists will; and so when we have petitioned for a Common Liberty, we shall have the odium, and they only the Liberty. And thus they sate still, and medled not with that Business.
§ 427. For my own part, I meddled but little with any such Business since the failing of […] at which incurred so much displeasure; and the rather because, though the Brethren Commissioned with me stuck to me as to the Cause, yet they were not forward enough to bear their part of the ungrateful part in the management, nor of the consequent displeasure: But yet when an Honourable Person was earnest with me, to give him my Judgment, Whether the way of Indulgence or Comprehension was more desirable, that he might discern which way to go in Parliament himself; I gave him my Thoughts in the following Paper, though I thought it was to little purpose.
§ 427. For my own part, I medled but little with any such Business since the failing of 〈…〉 at which incurred so much displeasure; and the rather because, though the Brethren Commissioned with me stuck to me as to the Cause, yet they were not forward enough to bear their part of the ungrateful part in the management, nor of the consequent displeasure: But yet when an Honourable Person was earnest with me, to give him my Judgment, Whether the way of Indulgence or Comprehension was more desirable, that he might discern which way to go in Parliament himself; I gave him my Thoughts in the following Paper, though I thought it was to little purpose.
SIR, Your first Question is, Whether the way of Comprehension or Indulgence be more desirable? Answ. If the Comprehension were truly Charitable and Catholic, upon the Terms of the Primitive Simplicity in Doctrine, Discipline and Worship, extending to all that the Apostolic Churches in their times received; it would end all our Differences and Miseries, except what in this imperfect state of the Church Militant must be still expected: and it would prevent the sin and everlasting woe of multitudes of Souls. But because there is no hope of this, by reason of the ignorance, impiety, uncharitableness, malice and factiousness of the Times; rebus sic stantibus, it is most evident that no Friend of the Church should be for Comprehension without Indulgence; nor for Indulgence without the Enlargement of the Act of Uniformity to a greater Comprehension; but for the Conjunction of both: which will attain the ends of both, and avoid the chief Inconveniences of either alone. 1. The way of Comprehension alone is not sufficient (on Terms not Catholic, which must be expected): 1. Because such Comprehension will still leave out many worthy Persons, whose Gifts God would have exercised for his Churches Service. And he that rightly valueth the preaching of the Gospel, and the saving of Souls, would rather choose to have a Millstone hanged about his Neck, and be cast into the Sea, than unnecessarily to silence any faithful Ministers of Christ. 2. Because even the Culpable should be punished but according to the measure of their offence: Those therefore whose Labours are like to do more good in the Church than their Faults to do harm, should be Corrected for those Faults, with such personal gentle Chastisement, as may not take them off their Labours for the Church. It is a lighter Punishment to honest Ministers, to make Brick as the Israelites in Egypt, so they may withal but preach the Gospel, than to be forbidden to preach for the Saving of the People. See 1 Thess. 2. 14, 15, 16. 3. Especially considering that the loss by silencing them redoundeth to the Souls of others, especially the ignorant and profane: and why should other Men be denied the Means of their Salvation, and so perish, because a Minister differeth from the State in some lesser things? 4. Considering also that there are not competent Men enough to do the Work of the Gospel without them:
SIR, YOur first Question is, Whether the way of Comprehension or Indulgence be more desirable? Answ. If the Comprehension were truly Charitable and Catholick, upon the Terms of the Primitive Simplicity in Doctrine, Discipline and Worship, extending to all that the Apostolick Churches in their times received; it would end all our Differences and Miseries, except what in this imperfect state of the Church Militant must be still expected: and it would prevent the sin and everlasting woe of multitudes of Souls. But because there is no hope of this, by reason of the ignorance, impiety, uncharitableness, malice and factiousness of the Times; rebus sic stantibus, it is most evident that no Friend of the Church should be for Comprehension without Indulgence; nor for Indulgence without the Enlargement of the Act of Uniformity to a greater Comprehension; but for the Conjunction of both: which will attain the ends of both, and avoid the chief Inconveniencies of either alone. 1. The way of Comprehension alone is not sufficient (on Terms not Catholick, which must be expected): 1. Because such Comprehension will still leave out many worthy Persons, whose Gifts God would have exercised for his Churches Service. And he that rightly valueth the preaching of the Gospel, and the saving of Souls, would rather choose to have a Milstone hang'd about his Neck, and be cast into the Sea, than unnecessarily to silence any faithful Ministers of Christ. 2. Because even the Culpable should be punished but according to the measure of their offence: Those therefore whose Labours are like to do more good in the Church than their Faults to do harm, should be Corrected for those Faults, with such personal gentle Chastisement, as may not take them off their Labours for the Church. It is a lighter Punishment to honest Ministers, to make Brick as the Israelites in Egypt, so they may withal but preach the Gospel, than to be forbidden to preach for the Saving of the People. See 1 Thess. 2. 14, 15, 16. 3. Especially considering that the loss by silencing them redoundeth to the Souls of others, especially the ignorant and prophane: and why should other Men be denied the Means of their Salvation, and so perish, because a Minister differeth from the State in some lesser things? 4. Considering also that there are not competent Men enough to do the Work of the Gospel without them:
Nay, there will be much want when all are employed. 5. It is desirable that his Majesty have Power to indulge the Peaceable, and abate Penalties, as in his Wisdom he shall see most conducible to the Peace of Church and State, and not to be too much tied up by an indispensable Establishment. These Reasons (and many more) are considerable for the way of Indulgence. 2. The way of Indulgence alone is not sufficient; but first, the Law should be made more Comprehensive: 1. Because indeed the present Impositions and Restrictions of the Law (considering also the direful Penalty) are such (especially the Declaration and Subscription required), as the Age that is further from the heels of Truth, will so describe and denominate, as will make our Posterity wish too late that the good of Souls, the welfare of the Church, and the Honour of our Nation had been better provided for. 2. Because it is exceeding desirable that as much strength and unity as may be, may be found in the established Body of the Clergy: which will be the glory of the Church, the advantage of the Gospel, the prevention of many sins of Uncharitableness, and the great safety and ease of his Majesty and the Realm: When as mere Indulgence, (if frustrated by Restrictions, will be unsatisfactory, and not attain its ends; but if any thing large and full) will drain almost all the established Churches, of a more considerable part of the People than I will now mention; and will keep much disunion among the Ministers. 3. If there be no way but that of Indulgence, it will load his Majesty with too much of the••ffence and murmur of the People. If he indulge but few, those that expected it […] lay all the blame on him: If he indulge all or most that are meet for it, he will much offend the Parliament and Prelates, who will think the Law is vain: But a power of indulging a small Number, when the most are embodied by a Comprehension, will be serviceable to God and the King, and the Common Peace, and justly offensive unto none. 4. The Indulgence will be hardly attained by so many as need it, and are meet for it; most being distant, many friendless and moneyless, and too many misrepresented by their Adversaries as unworthy. 5. If the Indulgence be for private Meetings only, it will occasion such Jealousies that they preach Sedition, ⟨p. 435⟩&c. as will not permit them long to enjoy it in peace.
Nay, there will be much want when all are employed. 5. It is desirable that his Majesty have Power to indulge the Peaceable, and abate Penalties, as in his Wisdom he shall see most conducible to the Peace of Church and State, and not to be too much tied up by an indispensable Establishment. These Reasons (and many more) are considerable for the way of Indulgence. 2. The way of Indulgence alone is not sufficient; but first, the Law should be made more Comprehensive: 1. Because indeed the present Impositions and Restrictions of the Law (considering also the direful Penalty) are such (especially the Declaration and Subscription required), as the Age that is further from the heels of Truth, will so describe and denominate, as will make our Posterity wish too late that the good of Souls, the welfare of the Church, and the Honour of our Nation had been better provided for. 2. Because it is exceeding desirable that as much strength and unity as may be, may be found in the established Body of the Clergy: which will be the glory of the Church, the advantage of the Gospel, the prevention of many sins of Uncharitablness, and the great safety and ease of his Majesty and the Realm: When as meer Indulgence, (if frustrated by Restrictions, will be unsatisfactory, and not attain its ends; but if any thing large and full) will drain almost all the established Churches, of a more considerable part of the People than I will now mention; and will keep much disunion among the Ministers. 3. If there be no way but that of Indulgence, it will load his Majesty with too much of the••ffence and murmur of the People. If he indulge but few, those that expected it 〈…〉 lay all the blame on him: If he indulge all or most that are meet for it, he will much offend the Parliament and Prelates, who will think the Law is vain: But a power of indulging a small Number, when the most are embodied by a Comprehension, will be serviceable to God and the King, and the Common Peace, and justly offensive unto none. 4. The Indulgence will be hardly attained by so many as need it, and are meet for it; most being distant, many friendless and moneyless, and too many misrepresented by their Adversaries as unworthy. 5. If the Indulgence be for private Meetings only, it will occasion such Jealousies that they preach Sedition, ⟨p. 435⟩&c. as will not permit them long to enjoy it in peace.
These and many more Reasons are against the way of Indulgence alone. It is therefore most evident that the way desirable, is first a Comprehension of as many fit Persons as may be taken in by Law; and then a power in his Majesty to indulge the Remnant so far as conduceth to the Peace and Benefit of Church and State. Your second Question is, What abatement is desirable for Comprehension? I answer; Suppose there is no hope of the Terms of Primitive Simplicity and Catholicism, but that we speak only of what might now be hoped for. 1. It is most needful that the old and new Subscriptions and Professions of Assent and Consent to all things in the Book of Ordination, Liturgy, and the two Articles concerning them be abated. 2. That the Declaration be abated; especially as to the disobliging all other Persons in the Three Kingdoms from the endeavouring in their places any lawful Alterations of the Government of the Church: And that the Oaths of Allegiance and Supremacy be the Test of Mens subjection: 3. That the Minister be not bound to use the Cross and Surplice, and read the Liturgy himself, if another (by whomsoever) be procured to do it: So be it he preach not against them. 4. That (according to Pope Leo III. determination in such a Case) the Bishops do by a general Confirmation (in which each Man approvable to have his part, upon due trial) confirm the Ordination formerly made by lawful Pastors without Diocesans, without reordaining them. 5. That what the Courts will do about Kneeling at the Receiving of the Lord's Supper may be done by others, and not the Minister forced to refuse Men merely on that account. 6. It is very desirable that Oaths of Obedience to the Diocesan be forborne, as long as Men may be punished for Disobedience. 7. It is exceeding desirable that Reformation of Church Government (by Suffragans, and the Rural Deanries, &c.) be made according to his Majesty's Will expressed in his Declaration concerning Ecclesiastical Affairs. To your third question, Of the Extent and Terms of the Indulgence, it being to be left to his Majesty's Wisdom, I shall not presume to give you my Answer.
These and many more Reasons are against the way of Indulgence alone. It is therefore most evident that the way desirable, is first a Comprehension of as many fit Persons as may be taken in by Law; and then a power in his Majesty to indulge the Remnant so far as conduceth to the Peace and Benefit of Church and State. Your second Question is, What abatement is desirable for Comprehension? I answer; Suppose there is no hope of the Terms of Primitive Simplicity and Catholicism, but that we speak only of what might now be hoped for. 1. It is most needful that the old and new Subscriptions and Professions of Assent and Consent to all things in the Book of Ordination, Liturgy, and the two Articles concerning them be abated. 2. That the Declaration be abated; especially as to the disobliging all other Persons in the Three Kingdoms from the endeavouring in their places any lawful Alterations of the Government of the Church: And that the Oaths of Allegiance and Supremacy be the Test of Mens subjection: 3. That the Minister be not bound to use the Cross and Surplice, and read the Liturgy himself, if another (by whomsoever) be procured to do it: So be it he preach not against them. 4. That (according to Pope Leo III. determination in such a Case) the Bishops do by a general Confirmation (in which each Man approveable to have his part, upon due trial) confirm the Ordination formerly made by lawful Pastors without Diocesans, without reordaining them. 5. That what the Courts will do about Kneeling at the Receiving of the Lord's Supper may be done by others, and not the Minister forced to refuse Men meerly on that account. 6. It is very desirable that Oaths of Obedience to the Diocesan be forborn, as long as Men may be punished for Disobedience. 7. It is exceeding desirable that Reformation of Church Government (by Suffragans, and the Rural Deanries, &c.) be made according to his Majesty's Will expressed in his Declaration concerning Ecclesiastical Affairs. To your third question, Of the Extent and Terms of the Indulgence, it being to be left to his Majesty's Wisdom, I shall not presume to give you my Answer.
§ 428. Instead of Indulgence and Comprehension, on the last day of June 1663. the Act against Private Meetings for Religious Exercises past the House of Commons, and shortly after was made a Law. The Sum of it was, That [every Person above sixteen years old, who is present at any Meeting under colour or pretence of any Exercise of Religion, in other manner than is allowed by the Liturgy or Practice of the Church of England, where there are five Persons more than that Household, shall for the first Offence by a Justice of Peace be Recorded, and sent to Jail three Months till he pay five pound; and for the second Offence six Months till he pay ten pound; and the third time, being convicted by a July, shall be banished to same of the (American) Plantations, excepting New-England or Virginia. The Calamity of the Act, besides the main Matter was, 1. That it was made so ambiguous, that no man that ever I met with, could tell what was a violation of it, and what not; not knowing what was [allowed by the Liturgy or Practise of the Church of England in Families], because the Liturgy meddleth not with Families, and among the diversity of Family Practice, no man knoweth what to call the Practice of the Church. 2. Because so much Power was given to the Justices of Peace, to record a man an Offender without a Jury, and if he did it causelessly, we are without any remedy, seeing he was made a Judge: According to the plain words of the Act, if a man did but preach and pray, or read some licensed Book and sing Psalms he might have more than four present, because these are allowed by the practice of the Church in the Church; and the Act seemeth to grant an Indulgence for […] and number, so be it the quality of the Exercise be allowed by the Church; which must be meant [publicly] because it meddleth with no private Exercise. But when it cometh to the trial, these Pleas with the Justice are vain: and life men do but […], it is taken for granted, that it is […] Exercise not allowed by the Church of England and to Jail they go.
§ 428. Instead of Indulgence and Comprehension, on the last day of Iune 1663. the Act against Private Meetings for Religious Exercises past the House of Commons, and shortly after was made a Law. The Sum of it was, That [every Person above sixteen years old, who is present at any Meeting under colour or pretence of any Exercise of Religion, in other manner than is allowed by the Liturgy or Practice of the Church of England, where there are five Persons more than that Household, shall for the first Offence by a Iustice of Peace be Recorded, and sent to Iail three Months till he pay five pound; and for the second Offence six Months till he pay ten pound; and the third time, being convicted by a Iuly, shall be banished to same of the (American) Plantations, excepting New-England or Virginia. The Calamity of the Act, besides the main Matter was, 1. That it was made so ambiguous, that no man that ever I met with, could tell what was a violation of it, and what not; not knowing what was [allowed by the Liturgy or Practise of the Church of England in Families], because the Liturgy medleth not with Families, and among the diversity of Family Practice, no man knoweth what to call the Practice of the Church. 2. Because so much Power was given to the Justices of Peace, to record a man an Offender without a Jury, and if he did it causelesly, we are without any remedy, seeing he was made a Judge: According to the plain words of the Act, if a man did but preach and pray, or read some licensed Book and sing Psalms he might have more than four present, because these are allowed by the practice of the Church in the Church; and the Act seemeth to grant an Indulgence for 〈…〉 and number, so be it the quality of the Exercise be allowed by the Church; which must be meant [publickly] because it medleth with no private Exercise. But when it cometh to the trial, these Pleas with the Justice are vain: and life men do but 〈…〉, it is taken for granted, that it is 〈…〉 Exercise not allowed by the Church of England and to Jail they go.
§ 429. And now came in the Peoples Trial, as well as the Ministers: While the Danger and Sufferings lay on the Ministers alone, the People were very courageous, and exhorted them to stand it out, and Preach till they went to Prison: But when it came to be their own Case, they were as venturous till they were once Surprised and Imprisoned; but then their Judgments were much altered, and they that censured Ministers before as Cowardly, because they preached not publicly whatever followed, did now think that it was better to preach often in secret to a few, than but once or twice in public to many; and that Secrecy was no sin when it tended to the furtherance of the Work of the Gospel, and to the Churches Good: Especially the Rich were as cautelous as the Ministers. But yet their Meetings were so ordinary, and so well known, that it greatly tended to the Jailer's Commodity.
§ 429. And now came in the Peoples Trial, as well as the Ministers: While the Danger and Sufferings lay on the Ministers alone, the People were very couragious, and exhorted them to stand it out, and Preach till they went to Prison: But when it came to be their own Case, they were as venturous till they were once Surprized and Imprisoned; but then their Judgments were much altered, and they that censured Ministers before as Cowardly, because they preached not publickly whatever followed, did now think that it was better to preach often in secret to a few, than but once or twice in publick to many; and that Secrecy was no sin when it tended to the furtherance of the Work of the Gospel, and to the Churches Good: Especially the Rich were as cautelous as the Ministers. But yet their Meetings were so ordinary, and so well known, that it greatly tended to the Jailor's Commodity.
§ 430. It was a great Strait that People were in, especially that dwell near any busy Officer, or malicious Enemy (as who doth not?) Many durst not pray in their Families, if above four Persons came in to dine with them. In a Gentleman's House it is ordinary for more than four, of Visitors, Neighbours, Messengers, or one sort or other, to be most or many days at Dinner with them: and then many durst not go to Prayer, and some durst scarce crave a Blessing on their Meat, or give God thanks for it: Some thought they might venture if they withdrew into another Room, and left the Strangers by themselves: But others said, It is all one if they be but in the same House, though out of hearing, when it cometh to the Judgment of the Justices. In London, where the Houses are contiguous, some thought if they were in several Houses, and heard one another through the Wall or a Window, it would avoid the Law: But others said, It is all in vain whilst the Justice is Judge whether it was a Meeting or no. Great Lawyers said, If you come on a visit or business, though you be present at Prayer or Sermon, it is no breach of the Law, because you met not [on pretence of a Religious Exercise]: But those that tried them said, Such Words are but Wind when the Justices come to judge you.
§ 430. It was a great Strait that People were in, especially that dwell near any busie Officer, or malicious Enemy (as who doth not?) Many durst not pray in their Families, if above four Persons came in to dine with them. In a Gentleman's House it is ordinary for more than four, of Visitors, Neighbours, Messengers, or one sort or other, to be most or many days at Dinner with them: and then many durst not go to Prayer, and some durst scarce crave a Blessing on their Meat, or give God thanks for it: Some thought they might venture if they withdrew into another Room, and left the Strangers by themselves: But others said, It is all one if they be but in the same House, though out of hearing, when it cometh to the Judgment of the Justices. In London, where the Houses are contiguous, some thought if they were in several Houses, and heard one another through the Wall or a Window, it would avoid the Law: But others said, It is all in vain whilst the Justice is Judge whether it was a Meeting or no. Great Lawyers said, If you come on a visit or business, though you be present at Prayer or Sermon, it is no breach of the Law, because you met not [on pretence of a Religious Exercise]: But those that tried them said, Such Words are but Wind when the Justices come to judge you.
§ 431. And here the Fanatics called Quakers did greatly relieve the sober People for a time: for they were so resolute, and gloried in their Constancy and Sufferings, that they assembled openly (at the Bull and Mouth near Aldersgate) and were dragged away daily to the Common Jail; and yet desisted not, but the rest came the next day nevertheless: So that the Jail at Newgate was filled with them. Abundance of them died in Prison, and yet they continued their Assemblies still! And the poor deluded Souls would sometimes meet only to sit still in Silence (when, as they said, the Spirit did not speak): And it was a great Question, Whether this Silence was a Religious Exercise not allowed by the Liturgy, &c. And once upon some such Reasons as these, when they were tried at the Sessions in order to a Banishment, the Jury acquitted them; but were grievously threatened for it. After that another Jury did acquit them, and some of them were fined and imprisoned for it. But thus the Quakers so employed Sir R. B. and the other Searchers and Prosecutors, that they had the less leisure to look after the Meetings of Soberer men; which was much to their present ease.
§ 431. And here the Fanaticks called Quakers did greatly relieve the sober People for a time: for they were so resolute, and gloried in their Constancy and Sufferings, that they assembled openly (at the Bull and Mouth near Aldersgate) and were dragged away daily to the Common Jail; and yet desisted not, but the rest came the next day nevertheless: So that the Jail at Newgate was filled with them. Abundance of them died in Prison, and yet they continued their Assemblies still! And the poor deluded Souls would sometimes meet only to sit still in Silence (when, as they said, the Spirit did not speak): And it was a great Question, Whether this Silence was a Religious Exercise not allowed by the Liturgy, &c. And once upon some such Reasons as these, when they were tried at the Sessions in order to a Banishment, the Jury acquitted them; but were grievously threatned for it. After that another Jury did acquit them, and some of them were fined and imprisoned for it. But thus the Quakers so employed Sir R. B. and the other Searchers and Prosecutors, that they had the less leisure to look after the Meetings of Soberer men; which was much to their present ease.
§ 432. And now the Divisions, or rather the Censures of the Non-conforming People against their Ministers and one another, began to increase: which was long foreseen, but could not be avoided, and I that had incurred so much the displeasure of the Prelates, and all their Party, by pleading for the Peace of the Non-conformists, did fall under more of their displeasure than any one man besides, as far as I could learn: And with me they joined Dr. Bates, because we went to the Public Assemblies, and also to the Common Prayer, even to the beginning of it: Not that they thought worse of us than of others; but that they thought that our Example would do more harm: For I must bear them witness, that in the midst of all their Censures of my Judgment and Actions, they never Censured my Affections and Intentions, nor abated their Charitable Estimation of me in the main. And of the leading Prelates I had so much favour in their hottest Indignation, that they thought what I did against their Interest was only in obedience to my Conscience. So that I see by experience, that he that is impartially and sincerely for Truth and Peace and Piety, against all Factions, shall have his Honesty acknowledged by the several Factions, whilst his Actions, as cross to their Interest, are detested: Whereas he that joineth with one of the Factions, shall have both his Person and Actions condemned by the other, though his Party may applaud both.
§ 432. And now the Divisions, or rather the Censures of the Non-conforming People against their Ministers and one another, began to increase: which was long foreseen, but could not be avoided, and I that had incurred so much the displeasure of the Prelates, and all their Party, by pleading for the Peace of the Non-conformists, did fall under more of their displeasure than any one man besides, as far as I could learn: And with me they joyned Dr. Bates, because we went to the Publick Assemblies, and also to the Common Prayer, even to the beginning of it: Not that they thought worse of us than of others; but that they thought that our Example would do more harm: For I must bear them witness, that in the midst of all their Censures of my Judgment and Actions, they never Censured my Affections and Intentions, nor abated their Charitable Estimation of me in the main. And of the leading Prelates I had so much favour in their hottest Indignation, that they thought what I did against their Interest was only in obedience to my Conscience. So that I see by experience, that he that is impartially and sincerely for Truth and Peace and Piety, against all Factions, shall have his Honesty acknowledged by the several Factions, whilst his Actions, as cross to their Interest, are detested: Whereas he that joyneth with one of the Factions, shall have both his Person and Actions condemned by the other, though his Party may applaud both.
§ 433. My Judgment was for the holding of Communion with Assemblies of both Parties; and ordinarily I went to some Parish Church, where I heard a Learned Minister that had not obtruded himself upon the People, but was chosen by them, and preached well, (as Dr. Wilkins, Dr. Tillotson, Mr. Nest, &c.) and I joined also in the Common Prayers of the Church: And as oft else as I had fit opportunity, I privately preached and prayed my self, either with Independents or Presbyterians that desired me! And I professed to all upon all occasions, that though I justified not all things which they held or did in any of their Churches, yet as long as they made not any Sin of mine a Condition of my Communion with them, I would occasionally join with any true Church in public or private; so be it they preached not for Heresy, nor against a holy and peaceable Life, nor turned not their Strain to Sedition or uncharitable Reviling one another: Even as I would hold occasional Communion with a Church of Lutherans, or Greeks, or Abassines, if I passed through their Countries. Though caeteris paribus I preferred Public Assemblies, which have the Magistrates Countenance, before Private; yet I more preferred those that have pure Worship and Discipline and powerful Preaching, before the scandalous, undisciplined, ignorant Churches, of ignorant and formal lifeless Ministers. And so far as I had my choice, my most usual Communion should be with those Assemblies that I thought the best; yet would I have occasional Communion with others, as Members of the Catholic Church, to show my Catholic Communion with all the Body of Christ. Yea, and my ordinary Communion should be with a Church that used the Common Prayer, rather than with none, or with a worse: And the Lord's Day I would spend in Church Communion (it being principally appointed to that end), and not in any mere Family Worship, or Meetings with a few Christians occasionally which met not as a Church. This was my Resolution: But the confidence of many on the other side was as great as mine could be: And their Arguments as many (though I thought not so good): Many Books came out against hearing Common Prayer, and against hearing any of the present Parish Ministers: One said to be by Mr. John Godwin, and another by one Mr.
§ 433. My Judgment was for the holding of Communion with Assemblies of both Parties; and ordinarily I went to some Parish Church, where I heard a Learned Minister that had not obtruded himself upon the People, but was chosen by them, and preached well, (as Dr. Wilkins, Dr. Tillotson, Mr. Nest, &c.) and I joyned also in the Common Prayers of the Church: And as oft else as I had fit opportunity, I privately preached and prayed my self, either with Independents or Presbyterians that desired me! And I professed to all upon all occasions, that though I justified not all things which they held or did in any of their Churches, yet as long as they made not any Sin of mine a Condition of my Communion with them, I would occasionally joyn with any true Church in publick or private; so be it they preached not for Heresie, nor against a holy and peaceable Life, nor turned not their Strein to Sedition or uncharitable Reviling one another: Even as I would hold occasional Communion with a Church of Lutherans, or Greeks, or Abassines, if I passed through their Countreys. Though caeteris paribus I preferred Publick Assemblies, which have the Magistrates Countenance, before Private; yet I more preferred those that have pure Worship and Discipline and powerful Preaching, before the scandalous, undisciplined, ignorant Churches, of ignorant and formal lifeless Ministers. And so far as I had my choice, my most usual Communion should be with those Assemblies that I thought the best; yet would I have occasional Communion with others, as Members of the Catholick Church, to shew my Catholick Communion with all the Body of Christ. Yea, and my ordinary Communion should be with a Church that used the Common Prayer, rather than with none, or with a worse: And the Lord's Day I would spend in Church Communion (it being principally appointed to that end), and not in any meer Family Worship, or Meetings with a few Christians occasionally which met not as a Church. This was my Resolution: But the confidence of many on the other side was as great as mine could be: And their Arguments as many (though I thought not so good): Many Books came out against hearing Common Prayer, and against hearing any of the present Parish Ministers: One said to be by Mr. Iohn Godwin, and another by one Mr.
Brown of Worcestershire (a fervent, injudicious, honest Fifth-Monarchy-man) and many more that made the Common Prayer to be no less than Idolatry. Because it was not prescribed by the Scripture, they said it is false Worship; and false Worship they said was one Species of Idolatry; by which arguing they would have made every fault in any of our Prayers or other Worship to be Idolatry: For Scripture prescribeth not any disorder or other fault in Prayer, but forbiddeth it: and so they may on the same account call it false Worship and Idolatry: But many honest People were led to depart too far from the Parish Assemblies, and from Charity and Unity it self, by such weak reasonings as these Yea, many turned Quakers, because the Quakers kept their Meetings openly, and went to Prison for it cheerfully; and because they would not join with the late imposed Ministry and Worship, which was so bad in their esteem, that their hearts rose against any Debate in which we would but question it.
Brown of Worcestershire (a fervent, injudicious, honest Fifth-Monarchy-man) and many more that made the Common Prayer to be no less than Idolatry. Because it was not prescribed by the Scripture, they said it is false Worship; and false Worship they said was one Species of Idolatry; by which arguing they would have made every fault in any of our Prayers or other Worship to be Idolutry: For Scripture prescribeth not any disorder or other fault in Prayer, but forbiddeth it: and so they may on the same account call it false Worship and Idolatry: But many honest People were led to depart too far from the Parish Assemblies, and from Charity and Unity it self, by such weak reasonings as these Yea, many turned Quakers, because the Quakers kept their Meetings openly, and went to Prison for it cheerfully; and because they would not joyn with the late imposed Ministry and Worship, which was so bad in their esteem, that their hearts rose against any Debate in which we would but question it.
When I hear men cry out against us as dangerous Schismatics, even when we deny not Communion with the conformable Parish Ministers, merely because we cease not preaching when the Magistrates and Prelates command us so to do, notwithstanding the notorious necessity of the People; it bringeth to my thoughts two remarkable Passages there met with.
When I hear men cry out against us as dangerous Schismaticks, even when we deny not Communion with the conformable Parish Ministers, meerly because we cease not preaching when the Magistrates and Prelates command us so to do, notwithstanding the notorious necessity of the People; it bringeth to my thoughts two remarkable Passages there met with.
The first of the Eastern Churches (Alexandria, Antioch, Caesars, &c.) which stuck to their old Pastors in private Meetings, and refused the new obtruded Bishops suspected of Arianism, notwithstanding the Emperor Valens his Prohibition, and his contrary Commands, and his personal violent Impedition. The like was done in Constantine's time.
The first of the Eastern Churches (Alexandria, Anti•ch, C•sares, &c.) which stuck to their old Pastors in private Meetings, and refused the new obtruded Bishops suspected of Arrianism, notwithstanding the Emperour Valens his Prohibition, and his contrary Commands, and his personal violent Impedition. The like was done in Constantine's time.
The second is of many Bishops in Africa who by Genseric•• were forbid to preach, and when they obeyed him not, their Tongues were cut out: And God by a Miracle justified their Disobedience to the King, and they spake as well as when they had their Tongues: Among many Historians who report this, I remember two credible ones, who profess that they saw and heard the men speak themselves, after the cutting out of their Tongues: One is Victor Uticensis, and as I remember the other is Aenaem Gazem.
§ 434. I confess some of those that were for Separation from the Parish Churches spake so plausibly, that it was no wonder that most of the Religious sort followed them. They said that