A27011:21
Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason,…
Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason, the Holy Scripture, the tradition and present judgment of the far greatest part of the Universal Church; in the point of transubstantiation; in answer to a book called A rational discourse of transubstantiation.Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason, the Holy Scripture, the tradition and present judgment of the far greatst part of the Universal Church; in the point of transubstantiation; in answer to a book called A rational discourse of transubstantiation.
S.l. : s.n., 1676
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
1. For one Body to be turned into another pre-existent, by apposition, (the Form of the changed Body ceasing, but not the Matter;) and yet that the pre-existent Body should not be increased by the apposition, this is a Contradiction. As in Numbers, for two to be added to ten, and yet the Number be still but ten, is a Contradiction: So for all the Bread that is Consecrated to lose only its Form, and the Matter to be changed into the Body of Christ, by apposition, and yet Christs Body to be no bigger, is a Contradiction; unless some pre-existent part of Christs Body vanish, and it be diminished by loss, as much as it receiveth by apposition.
You say, that by Concoction we our selves turn Bread and Wine into Flesh and Blood daily: But note, that the Form only of the Bread and Wine ceaseth, and the Matter receiveth a new Form in us, and by apposition increaseth our Flesh and Blood; and that our bulk increaseth not alway, is because some parts vanish, as others are added; ⟨p. 7⟩and being in a continual Flux or Mutation, we have little, if any, of the same Flesh and Blood this Year, that we had the last, or a few Years ago. And doth Christ's Body thus change, and receive addition and diminution? or, doth it grow bigger at the pleasure of the Priest?
2. If you say that this is not your ordinary belief, but that the very Matter, as well as Form of the Bread and Wine ceaseth; I add, that it is a Contradiction, that the very Matter should cease to be, and yet be changed into another Body. The ceasing of Matter is Annihilation: And to say that it is annihilated, and yet changed into another thing, is a Contradiction: As Matter is denominated from the Form, when the Form ceaseth, the Matter ceaseth to be the Matter of that Form; but unless annihilated it is still the Matter of another Form. For one Body to be annihilated, and another to take its place, is not for the one to be changed into the other. Annihilating and Transubstantiating are Contradictory.