A27011:71
Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason,…
Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason, the Holy Scripture, the tradition and present judgment of the far greatest part of the Universal Church; in the point of transubstantiation; in answer to a book called A rational discourse of transubstantiation.Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason, the Holy Scripture, the tradition and present judgment of the far greatst part of the Universal Church; in the point of transubstantiation; in answer to a book called A rational discourse of transubstantiation.
S.l. : s.n., 1676
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. If you grant that a Pope and General Council are Fallible about Duty and Sin, even in deposing Princes, and dissolving their Subjects Oaths of fidelity, how shall we know that they are Infallible in matters of Faith? He that is deceived in saying, Thou must obey the Ten Commandments, may be deceived in saying, Thou shalt believe the Creed: If we cannot be sure by the Churches Proposal that God is to be loved; how shall we that way be sure that he is to be believed, and that the Scripture is his Word. And if the Pope may excommunicate and depose Princes, and change Dominions by error; how can I be sure that he may not say by error, that this Bread is no Bread, and this Wine is no Wine.
2. If you grant that a Pope and General Council are Fallible about Duty and Sin, even in deposing Princes, and dissolving their Subjects Oaths of fidelity, how shall we know that they are Infallible in matters of Faith? He that is deceived in saying, Thou must obey the Ten Commandments, may be deceived in saying, Thou shalt believe the Creed: If we cannot be sure by the Churches Proposal that God is to be loved; how shall we that way be sure that he is to be believed, and that the Scripture is his Word. And if the Pope may excommunicate and depose Princes, and change Dominions by errour; how can I be sure that he may not say by errour, that this Bread is no Bread, and this Wine is no Wine.
3. Is it only matter of Faith, and not matter of Fact that you have by sure Tradition? Is not matter of Fact (as Christ's Birth, Death, Resurrection, and Ascension) also matter of Faith? And is not this in question a matter of Fact, viz. Whether, de facto, the Apostles told the first Converts, that Bread after Consecration was no Bread, and that this was the meaning of Christ's words [This is my Body] which you assert? And it's matter of Practice that Men must receive it in this sense. But if the Council may be deceived in this, and make such Laws for ruining Princes and Nations, which yet they were never taught by their Fore-fathers; why may not the same Men say [Bread is no Bread] without being taught it by their Fore-fathers.
3. Is it only matter of Faith, and not matter of Fact that you have by sure Tradition? Is not matter of Fact (as Christ's Birth, Death, Resurrection, and Ascention) also matter of Faith? And is not this in question a matter of Fact, viz. Whether, de facto, the Apostles told the first Converts, that Bread after Consecration was no Bread, and that this was the meaning of Christ's words [This is my Body] which you assert? And it's matter of Practice that Men must receive it in this sense. But if the Council may be deceived in this, and make such Laws for ruining Princes and Nations, which yet they were never taught by their Fore-fathers; why may not the same Men say [Bread is no Bread] without being taught it by their Fore-fathers.