A27011:75
Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason,…
Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason, the Holy Scripture, the tradition and present judgment of the far greatest part of the Universal Church; in the point of transubstantiation; in answer to a book called A rational discourse of transubstantiation.Roman tradition examined, as it is urged as infallible against all mens senses, reason, the Holy Scripture, the tradition and present judgment of the far greatst part of the Universal Church; in the point of transubstantiation; in answer to a book called A rational discourse of transubstantiation.
S.l. : s.n., 1676
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
V. And why might not an Arian have argued as you do, when they had their General Councils, and the World groaned to find it self turned Arian, faith a Father? Might they not at Ariminum and Firmium have said, How can we believe it, unless our Fathers had it from the Apostles? And I suppose you know (else Sondius will tell you) that the Arians pretend as confidently to Tradition as the Papists do. And your own Dionys. Petavius hath cited so great a Number of the ancientest Fathers and Writers, who speak words too plainly savouring of, or favouring Arianism, as will tell any Man that their pretence is not without such a colour of proof, as is as plausible as any you can bring for the Tradition of Transubstantiation at the least.
V. And why might not an Arrian have argued as you do, when they had their General Councils, and the World groaned to find it self turned Arrian, faith a Father? Might they not at Ariminum and Firmium have said, How can we believe it, unless our Fathers had it from the Apostles? And I suppose you know (else Sondius will tell you) that the Arrians pretend as confidently to Tradition as the Papists do. And your own Dionys. Petavius hath cited so great a Number of the antientest Fathers and Writers, who speak words too plainly savouring of, or favouring Arrianism, as will tell any Man that their pretense is not without such a colour of proof, as is as plausible as any you can bring for the Tradition of Transubstantiation at the least.
VI. I pray you tell us which way was Transubstantiation delivered down from the Apostles? By Writing, or without-book, by Word alone? If by Writing, are not those Writings yet extant? And cannot we read them as well as you? You tell us that all the Writings of the ninth, or tenth Age show it (which is false.) But if the Writings of the first eight hundred years showed not the ⟨p. 30⟩same thing to them, how did they know it? If by bare words, can you make your self believe that bare words, and Memory, will as surely convey down from Age to Age, the Mysteries of Faith, as Written Records will do? Do you not daily find, that if Men are but to repeat a Sermon, yea a few Sentences, how apt they are to alter, or omit, or add some words which alter the whole sense? I seldom hear a Sermon reported, but somewhat of it is mis-reported! yea, we can scarce have a matter of Fact reported without great diversity and mis-reports; which makes the common reports of Persons, and Things, in City and Country, to be so full of falsehood, and uncertainty. Mens Memories are slippery, and the alteration of a word, may make the matter another thing. Send but your Servant to do a message, or business for you, by bare word and memory; and at another time Write him down all that he shall say, or do; and try which way will occasion more mistake! Why do you keep your Bonds, Bills, Covenants, Leases, Deeds, and Testaments in Writing else, and do not trust them to Mens Memories? Why are our Laws Written, and Court Records kept, if Memory will keep them better? Had we no Books, or Records, one Lawyer would say one thing, and another, another thing; and there would be nothing but uncertainty and confusion. Why do so many Preachers use Sermon Notes? Why do you cause all your Mass, even the Hoc est Corpus meum to be read out of a Book, and trust not your Mass-Priests to repeat them by Memory? Besides, that Men Write more deliberately, and accurately, than usually they speak; and their sense is easilier tried, and reviewed. Where Mens Life and Death lieth on it, Physicians will hardly trust their Memories with all their Remedies, nor send one to the Apothecaries without