A27015:601
The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholic religion against popery proving…The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholike religion against popery proving…
The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholic religion against popery proving that popery is against the Holy Scriptures, the unity of the catholic church, the consent of the ancient doctors, the plainest reason, and common judgment of sense it self / by Richard Baxter.The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholike religion against popery proving that popery is against the Holy Scriptures, the unity of the catholike church, the consent of the antient doctors, the plainest reason, and common judgment of sense it self / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed by Abraham Miller for Thomas Underhill, 1657
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The judgement of the Pope and his pretended General Council is directly contradictory to the apprehension or judgement of common sense: therefore if common sense be infallible, the Pope and his Council are fallible.
The consequent is unquestionable; the Antecedent I prove by this known Instance.
Common sense takes it to be bread and Wine that remaineth after the words of consecration: The Pope and his Council say, it is not Bread nor Wine that remains after the words of consecration: therefore the judgement of the Pope and his Council is directly contradictory to the apprehension of common sense.
For the first, I appeal to the senses of all men that ever received the Eucharist. Whether seeing, feeling, smelling, and tasting, do not as plainly take it to be Bread and Wine, as they do any other Bread or Wine at their own tables? and whether they can see or taste, or smell, or feel, any difference to give them the least cause of doubting? I am sure I have the judgement of thousands and millions on my side, which in a matter of sense among sound men, is certainly enough. And if the Papists are so mad as to tell me, that it is otherwise with their senses; and will seriously profess that their eyes, and taste, &c. do not take these for Bread and Wine, but perceive that they are not, I will take them for shameless liars, or madmen; and I suppose no man in his senses will blame me for so doing. Well I its pa doubt that all our senses tell us its Bread and Wine, as confidently as they tell us any thing is such. And it is certain that the Pope and his Council tell us it is not Bread and Wine: If our eyes be infallible that