A27015:627
The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholic religion against popery proving…The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholike religion against popery proving…
The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholic religion against popery proving that popery is against the Holy Scriptures, the unity of the catholic church, the consent of the ancient doctors, the plainest reason, and common judgment of sense it self / by Richard Baxter.The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholike religion against popery proving that popery is against the Holy Scriptures, the unity of the catholike church, the consent of the antient doctors, the plainest reason, and common judgment of sense it self / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed by Abraham Miller for Thomas Underhill, 1657
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Where observe 1. That even learned men, yea General Councils, and the Church may be uncertain which is the true Pope. Its worth the enquiring then, whether they be not uncertain that the Roman succession is interrupted; and uncertain at that time whether God had any word? or what was the sense of it? and whether it was certain to them that the Church failed not, when they had no certainty of the head? and whether their head and so their Church were then visible or invisible, when they could so hardly be known? And note, that Bellarmine doth disclaim the Come-popes with this John 23. and saith elsewhere, that it was most likely that this was the true Pope. They have brought their glorious head, Church and infallibility to a fair pass!
Where observe 1. That even learned men, yea General Councils, and the Church may be uncertain which is the true Pope. Its worth the enquiring then, whether they be not uncertain that the Romane succession is interrupted; and uncertain at that time whether God had any word? or what was the sence of it? and whether it was certain to them that the Church failed not, when they had no certainty of the head? and whether their head and so their Church were then visible or invisible, when they could so hardly be known? And note, that Bellarmine doth disclaim the Com-popes with this John 23. and saith elsewhere, that it was most likely that this was the true Pope. They have brought their glorious head, Church and infallibility to a fair pass!
Besides this, the General Council at Basil did shortly after depose Pope Eugenius the forth, declaring him to be [A rebel against the holy Canons, a notorious disturber and scandalizer of the peace and unity of the Church, a Simonist, and a perjured wretch, incorrigible, a schismatic and an obstinate heretic] *To this Bellarmine ⟨p. 256⟩hath not a word to say, but only that the Council did him wrong, and at Lansanna undid their acts. And thus he is content to grant that 1. A General Council may err (which he maintaineth) 2. And that a Pope may be a heretic and to be deposed in the judgement of a General Council? And are the Papists forced to yield us thus much? I would fain know then from Bellarmine or any Papists surviving him, whether that General Councils do err in faith, and be Heretics or not, for that their judgement? If they do so err, then where is the visibility of their Church with the rest of its privileges which they so boast of, when its Representative body, a General Council are Heretics, as thinking the Pope to be fallible? But if they erred not de fide, or were no heretics. 1. Then its seems the Popes infallibility is no fundamental. 2. Then it seems we are no heretics neither, for denying that which General Councils of Papists (pretended by them to be General) have denied. 3 Nay why should they be angry with men for erring such an error (as they account it) which their own general Councils may one after another err.