A27015:666
The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholic religion against popery proving…The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholike religion against popery proving…
The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholic religion against popery proving that popery is against the Holy Scriptures, the unity of the catholic church, the consent of the ancient doctors, the plainest reason, and common judgment of sense it self / by Richard Baxter.The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholike religion against popery proving that popery is against the Holy Scriptures, the unity of the catholike church, the consent of the antient doctors, the plainest reason, and common judgment of sense it self / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed by Abraham Miller for Thomas Underhill, 1657
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. The plea of the Romanists for their Popes infallibility is, that he is the successor of Peter. But the Bishop of Antioch might as well pretend to be the successor of Peter, and yet he pretendeth not to infallibility: Therefore, &c. That History which telleth us that Peter was Bishop of Rome, doth tell us that he was Bishop of Antioch also; yea and that he was Bishop of Antioch before he was Bishop of Rome, so that Antioch is undoubtedly the ancienter Church. What reason then can the Papists give why the Bishop of Antioch might not as well plead that he is Peters successor, as the Bishop of Rome? Unless they could prove that Peter did by his last Will and Testament bequeath the honour of succession, and the privileges of infallibility to Rome only; which they have not yet (that I can find) been so bold as to go about to prove. Otherwise, if one must needs be preferred, why should not the eldest, unless they be disinherited, and the younger hath the blessing, which must be proved. Whence is it but from the honour of their Antiquity that Antioch, Jerusalem, Alexandria, and Rome should be preferred as Patriarchates before all other Churches? And if Antiquity be a good reason for that, then why should not Jerusalem and Antioch on the same account be preferred before Rome, seeing its beyond all doubt that they were both the more ancient Churches, and Antioch the more ancient seat of Peter, in the judgement of them that make him Bishop of either. So that its clear that other Churches have as much or more to say for infallibility then Rome, who yet make no pretence to it.
2. The plea of the Romanists for their Popes infallibility is, that he is the successor of Peter. But the Bishop of Antioch might as well pretend to be the successor of Peter, and yet he pretendeth not to infallibility: Therefore, &c. That History which telleth us that Peter was Bishop of Rome, doth tell us that he was Bishop of Antioch also; yea and that he was Bishop of Antioch before he was Bishop of Rome, so that Antioch is undoubtedly the ancienter Church. What reason then can the Papists give why the Bishop of Antioch might not as well plead that he is Peters successor, as the Bishop of Rome? Unless they could prove that Peter did by his last Will and Testament bequeath the honor of succession, and the priviledges of infallibility to Rome onely; which they have not yet (that I can find) been so bold as to go about to prove. Otherwise, if one must needs be preferred, why should not the eldest, unless they be disinherited, and the younger hath the blessing, which must be proved. Whence is it but from the honor of their Antiquity that Antioch, Hierusalem, Alexandria, and Rome should be preferred as Patriarchates before all other Churches? And if Antiquity be a good reason for that, then why should not Jerusalem and Antioch on the same account be preferred before Rome, seeing its beyond all doubt that they were both the more ancient Churches, and Antioch the more ancient seat of Peter, in the judgement of them that make him Bishop of either. So that its clear that other Churches have as much or more to say for infallibility then Rome, who yet make no prentence to it.