A27015:769
The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholic religion against popery proving…The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholike religion against popery proving…
The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholic religion against popery proving that popery is against the Holy Scriptures, the unity of the catholic church, the consent of the ancient doctors, the plainest reason, and common judgment of sense it self / by Richard Baxter.The safe religion, or, Three disputations for the reformed catholike religion against popery proving that popery is against the Holy Scriptures, the unity of the catholike church, the consent of the antient doctors, the plainest reason, and common judgment of sense it self / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed by Abraham Miller for Thomas Underhill, 1657
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. 1. But by what Authority doth Bellarmine confine Gregory's words to some Councils, which he speaks in general of all that he had seen or might do resolving to avoid all hereafter. 2. Here note that Bellarmine confesseth that Councils may err; and then where is the French Religion? 3. I would fain know where was the Churches infallibility, and power of judging of matters of faith in Nazianzens days? If there were no lawful General Councils, nor could be, then it was not in them; therefore it must be either in the people (and how shall we gather the world together to consult with them) or else as Bellarmine will say, in the Pope alone, or in the Roman Clergy with him.1 I hear not yet that they are very forward to prove that the Roman Clergy in particular are Infallible (though Bellarmine hath given us his bold conjectures of that) It must needs be therefore that at that time all the Churches infallible judicial power, and so the foundation of our faith must be resolved into the Pope alone; and so the faith of all the world must then be resolved into the credit of the word of a single and silly man. I know the Italian faction will not abhor this at any time; but then they should for shame speak out and deal plainly with the world, and not talk of the whole Church and all the Church, when they mean but one man. 4. And I would fain know of any friend of Bellarmines, how far the universal ⟨p. 323⟩Church was visible at that time, when all Councils were bad, and none could be lawful? The visibility was not in a Council to represent the whole: and the laity are not much noted when Councils go wrong, •o that the Church was visible only in one man, or • few particular persons, according to the Papists common reckoning, who judge by the Pastors visibility: Yea the Church of Rome it self was invisible •hen and divers times when their Bishop was a Heretic. If therefore they will say either that the Church was visible in one man, or in the Laity of many parts oppressed by the Clergy and Magistracy and they have nothing more to say) then we will •ay as much of the visibility of our Church before Luther, and more too. 5. Its confessed here also that •ot only a Council, but the greater number (by ery many) of the Bishops of the Church may be heretics or err in faith. 6. And then the Church may lye in the smaller oppressed part: and why then may not the most err now?