Schism detected in both extremes, or, Two sorts of sinful separation the first part…Schism detected in both extreams, or, Two sorts of sinful separation the first part…
Schism detected in both extremes, or, Two sorts of sinful separation the first part detecteth the schismatical principles of a resolver of three cases about church-communion, the second part confuteth the separation pleaded for in a book famed to be written by Mr. Raphson.Schism detected in both extreams, or, Two sorts of sinful separation the first part detecteth the schismatical principles of a resolver of three cases about church-communion, the second part confuteth the separation pleaded for in a book famed to be written by Mr. Raphson.
Richard Baxter 1615–1691London: printed for Tho. Parkhurst, 1684
[5], 58, [4], 18 p. · 37k words · Wing B1396 · ESTC R16323
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
5. The proof of all this is by this Argument; Worship not institute, is not lawful; but kneeling in receipt of Bread and Wine, is Worship not instituted by Christ: therefore not lawful; therefore ⟨p. 2⟩
not pleasing, p. 160, 161. To which, by way of Motive, he addeth, p. 275. How many once in the separation, are returned back to the Vomit they once cast up, and wallow in the mire of a worldly worship? &c. Is compliance in Idol-Temples, going to Dan and Bethel, bowing to Baal, sitting, or drinking with the superstitious in acts of religious adoration, a witness for, or against defection? Are you turned as silly sheep (that once were called shepherds), to bleat after other shepherds, that Christ never sent, nor bid you go after them, &c. Looks it not like a declining of the Camp of Christ, the work of the Gospel, and setting your face towards Babel, &c.? Is scandal of no weight with you, &c.? How dare you venture your souls to sit under Means that he says shall not profit you; and which is worse, lies under his curse?
. with more such. Either this Writer knoweth how ill he dealeth with his Reader, or not: If he do, it's a double fault: if not (which I think), it's a doleful case, that every well meaning man, that can but be confident in his ignorance and error, and father it on God, should become such a snare to them that cannot see through his Pretences, and should himself suffer for sinning, and call it the Cause of God, and condemn all that sin not as confidently as he; and hereby harden his afflicters, by showing them his weakness, and impenitently justifying his sin.
5. The proof of all this is by this Argument; Worship not institute, is not lawful; but kneeling in receipt of Bread and Wine, is Worship not instituted by Christ: therefore not lawful; therefore ⟨p. 2⟩not pleasing, p. 160, 161. To which, by way of Motive, he addeth, p. 275. How many once in the separation, are returned back to the Vomit they once cast up, and wallow in the mire of a worldly worship? &c. Is compliance in Idol-Temples, going to Dan and Bethel, bowing to Baal, sitting, or drinking with the superstitious inacts of religious adoration, a witness for, or against defection? Are you turned as silly sheep (that once were called shepherds), to bleat after other shepherds, that Christ never sent, nor bid you go after them, &c. Looks it not like a declining of the Camp of Christ, the work of the Gospel, and setting your face towards Babel, &c.? Is scandal of no weight with you, &c.? How dare you venture your souls to sit under Means that he says shall not profit you; and which is worse, lies under his curse? Jer. 23. 32. Mal. 1. 14. with more such. Either this Writer knoweth how ill he dealeth with his Reader, or not: If he do, it's a double fault: if not (which I think), it's a doleful case, that every wellmeaning man, that can but be confident in his ignorance and error, and father it on God, should become such a snare to them that cannot see through his Pretences, and should himself suffer for sinning, and call it the Cause of God, and condemn all that sin not as confidently as he; and hereby harden his afflicters, by shewing them his weakness, and impenitently justifying his sin.
If he would not have ensnared his Reader, he should first have opened the meaning of the words of his Question, that they might know how much of the Dispute is material, and how much only about words. 2. And then he should have so proved his assertion and accusation, as might satisfy a good Conscience in a matter wherein God, the Church, and Souls, are so much concerned; and not have poured out Accusations by way of Motives, upon unproved and false suppositions.
If he would not have ensnared his Reader, he should first have opened the meaning of the words of his Question, that they might know how much of the Dispute is material, and how much only about words. 2. And then he should have so proved his assertion and accusation, as might satisfie a good Conscience in a matter wherein God, the Church, and Souls, are so much concerned; and not have poured out Accusations by way of Motives, upon unproved and false suppositions.
His Major is, [Worship not instituted, is not lawful] Ans. 1. The word [Worship] in general, signifieth, 1. Any thing done in honour to another; and so all our obedience to God is Worship: It is to his glory that we must do all. I suppose that this he meaneth not. 2. Any immediate act or expression of the honour and reverence of the heart. If this be not it that he meaneth by Worship, I know not what he meaneth.
Of such Worship there are two sorts: One sort is made necessary, statedly, by God's commanding it in particular. To this no man must add the like, or from it diminish any thing so commanded, either pretending God's authority, or his own. The other sort is but the subordinate ordering of the former, and is but the manner of doing it. This God doth not institute in particular, but only give man a general Rule, how to choose it himself; which is, That all be done in love, and to edification, decently and in order.
Either this latter sort is to be called Worship, or not: If it be, then it falls under his opposition: If not, then, 1. He must give us a definition of Worship, which shall exclude it; and so Worship must be somewhat else than the direct or immediate acting or expressing honour to God: And then who knows what he meaneth by it? 2. And then when we plead for mens making none but this, he should to avoid deceit, confess that the Controversy is only of the Name (whether Modes and Circumstances of God's instituted Worship, may be called Worship), and not at all of the Thing (whether it be lawful or not): This had been like a Christian Teacher.
Either this latter sort is to be called Worship, or not: If it be, then it falls under his opposition: If not, then, 1. He must give us a definition of Worship, which shall exclude it; and so Worship must be somewhat else than the direct or immediate acting or expressing honour to God: And then who knows what he meaneth by it? 2. And then when we plead for mens making none but this, he should to avoid deceit, confess that the Controversie is only of the Name (whether Modes and Circumstances of God's instituted Worship, may be called Worship), and not at all of the Thing (whether it be lawful or not): This had been like a Christian Teacher.
Now I answer, 1. to his first Proposition: 1. Worship which is neither instituted particularly, nor in the general, appointing man how to choose it, is unlawful, 2. And to invent worship without God's allowance, contrary, or of the same kind, as if he had not done his part, is unlawful. 3. But for man to choose and use such worship as is but the right ordering of God's Institutions, is commanded by him, and a Duty; and therefore not unlawful.
2. As to his Minor, or Second Proposition, I answer, Kneeling at the Sacrament, and communicating with Parish Churches that have tolerable Ministers, are not instituted of God in particular, but the Genus of them is instituted, and we commanded to choose our selves, according to God's general Rules, to the best of our understanding: and so they are our Duty, and not unlawful.
2. As to his Minor, or Second Proposition, I answer, Kneeling at the Sacrament, and communicating with Parish Churches that have tollerable Ministers, are not instituted of God in particular, but the Genus of them is instituted, and we commanded to choose our selves, according to God's general Rules, to the best of our understanding: and so they are our Duty, and not unlawful.
First, God hath Instituted, that our Minds Worship him, in believing, and receiving all his Gospel Revelations, and trusting them; and in desiring all things Petitioned in the Lords Prayer, and in consenting to all commanded in the Scriptures; and in Dedicating our selves to him cordially in Baptism, and renewing it in the Lords Supper, in commemoration of Christ's Death, till he comes. He hath Instituted the Corporal Expressions of all these; That we confess Christ in all the necessary Articles of Faith; That we ask the Petitions of the Lords Prayer; That we perform the Commands of the Decalogue towards God, and all others in the Scripture. These are the Instituted Worship which none must alter.
First, God hath Instituted, that our Minds Worship him, in believing, and receiving all his Gospel Revelations, and trusting them; and in desiring all things Petitioned in the Lords Prayer, and in consenting to all commanded in the Scriptures; and in Dedicating our selves to him cordially in Baptism, and renewing it in the Lords Supper, in commemoration of Christ's Death, till he comes. He hath Instituted the Corporal Expresions of all these; That we confess Christ in all the necessary Articles of Faith; That we ask the Petitions of the Lords Prayer; That we perform the Commands of the Decalogue towards God, and all others in the Scripture. These are the Instituted Worship which none must alter.
Secondly, The Manner and Ordering which is the Second sort (which I leave every one to call Worship, or not, when they have defined Worship) which man may, and must choose himself, without any Particular Institution of God, contain such Acts as these.
Secondly, The Manner and Ordering which is the Second sort (which I leave every one to call Worship, or not, when they have defined Worship) which man may, and must chuse himself, without any Particular Institution of God, contain such Acts as these.
England
Pastor at Kidderminster and prolific nonconformist author.