A27035:382
London: printed for Nevil Simons, 1681
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Sect. 11. 5. Lastly, The forenamed causes of our preaching much differ. 1. We saw the Kingdom (though under usurpers) engaged by Vow, Practice, and about sixteen years possession and custom, to another way; and who could expect that a Law should presently change them all, and assure them of absolution. 2. They that conformed were the more averse, to see about six thousand Ministers that had gone the other way, so suddenly change; as to declare assent and consent to a Book which they never saw. 3. The case of the Plague, the burning of the Churches, the Kings Licenses, &c. I named before, which verily made a great difference. 4. And the numbers ⟨p. 70⟩that call to us for help makes a great difference, when then they that needed them most, did not desire it. These are some differences.
Sect. 12. p. 95. He saith, There is no reason of separation because of the doctrine of our Church.] Answ. But now you have corrupted it, in the Article of Infants undoubted salvation before described, (and before by the doctrines about Prelacy, Godfathers power and duty, Impositions, &c. implied in your practical Canons) there is great cause of Nonconformity.
Sect. 12. p. 95. He saith, There is no reason of separation because of the doctrine of our Church.] Answ. But now you have corrupted it, in the Article of Infants undoubted salvation before described, (and before by the doctrines about Prelacy, Godfathers power and duty, Impositions, &c. implyed in your practical Canons) there is great cause of Nonconformity.
P. 96. Repeateth that great mistake, that [there are no alterations, in our own judgment, which make the terms of Communion harder than before.] Answ. What hope then of being understood? how far is this from truth? The terms are far harder to Ministers? and to the people they are easier in some things (as amending some translations, &c.) but it is not to them a small matter to make such a change of their Pastors, as in too many Parishes is made. The Bishop promised them at Kidderminster, when he forbade me to preach, that they should be no losers by the change: They said (and I had great reason to believe them) that the Successor knew so little of the sense of the Creed, and preached so rarely (four times a year) I am loth to tell you how, that they durst not be guilty of encouraging him in undertaking the charge of Souls, nor durst take him for their Pastor: And the great increase of buildings in London, shuts thousands now out of such Parish Churches, who could have got in heretofore; and some more differences are before implied. p. 97. As other Churches own your Churches, so do we, though not your imposed sins.
P. 96. Repeateth that great mistake, that [there are no alterations, in our own judgment, which make the terms of Communion harder than before.] Answ. What hope then of being understood? how far is this from truth? The terms are sar harder to Ministers? and to the people they are easier in some things (as amending some translations, &c.) but it is not to them a small matter to make such a change of their Pastors, as in too many Parishes is made. The Bishop promised them at Kiderminster, when he forbad me to preach, that they should be no losers by the change: They said (and I had great reason to believe them) that the Successor knew so little of the sence of the Creed, and preach'd so rarely (four times a year) I am loth to tell you how, that they durst not be guilty of encouraging him in undertaking the charge of Souls, nor durst take him for their Pastor: And the great increase of buildings in London, shuts thousands now out of such Parish Churches, who could have got in heretofore; and some more differences are before implyed. p. 97. As other Churches own your Churches, so do we, though not your imposed sins.
Sect. 13. p. I was in hope to have met with some answer to my importunate Question, [What would you have the many score thousands do, that cannot come within your Churches to hear?] But no importunity will prevail for so small a matter with inexorable men. But he saith, 1. that [this is but a pretence.] 2. And that [no man denieth that more places are desirable, &c.] Ans. 1. It is me that he is now accusing! why doth he barely say and not prove, that it's but a pretence? I never set up a Meeting place, but in St. Martins Parish, where are said to be forty thousand more than can come within the Church: And when they would not suffer me to use it, I gladly left it to the use of the Parish Minister. I preach now twice a week elsewhere, but both the places are in Neighbourhoods, where many thousands cannot hear in the Parish Churches. What if other men have other sufficient reasons (as the utter incapacity of some Ministers, or the like) doth it follow that my own case and professed reason is a mere pretence? why then did I use no public preaching, while I lived in such Villages where the people might go to Church? and why did I constantly twice a day lead them thither, though some disliked it? 2. The question is not whether more Churches ⟨p. 71⟩are desirable? But where they are not, whether many thousands must live like Atheists, without all public teaching or Divine Worship, for fear of being called Schismatics. Is not this plainly to choose damnation? If the Gospel be needless, why do we wish the Heathens had it? Why subscribe you against mens hopes of being saved in all their several Religions? If Church worship be needless, why is a Clergy to be so honoured, and maintained at so dear a rate? And why do you make such a stir with Separatists to bring them to your Churches? Can men, not blinded by interest, choose but wonder, that so many thousands in a Parish should be taken for Church Members, and live quietly, that come not to any Church, or never communicate with any, and yet that godly persons who hear and communicate with their old tried Pastors (yea with such as communicate with you) should be preached and written against as Schismatics, and judged to that which some endure. Did this Dr. think that to drop in the case of other men, when he was at a loss, would make good his charge against me, and such as I: Mr. Tombs and Mr.
Williams preached other doctrine; do I do so, and have you proved it?
But seeing he will needs bring the case to Kidderminster, whether I would suffer Mr. Tombs to gather a Congregation, I must not balk it; but advise him hereafter to keep himself at a greater distance, and not to put his own followers, who are willing enough to believe him, upon utter impossibilities: He sped better with them when he laid the scene an hundred years backward, or as far off as New England; let him know then all these things in confutation of his historical supposition. 1. That Kidderminster Parish hath but about three thousand or four thousand souls, and the Church so fit (with five Galleries) that all may hear: But his Parish is said to have twenty thousand souls, of which not four thousand can hear. 2. A considerable part of Kidderminster Parish, called Ridnal, being at Bewdly Bridge end, and two miles from Kidderminster, (and some Villages more) usually were Mr. Tombs his hearers at Bewdley, and I never blamed them. 3. After him, they were Hearers and Communicants to his Successor Mr. Oasland, and he took the Pastoral care of them (that desired any;) and I was so far from blaming him, that I greatly thanked him, and we were far from disagreeing. 4. Though Mr. Tombs and I differed in the doctrine of Infant Baptism, I gave him leave (yea and the Quakers too) in the public Church many hours together, to say all that they could for their opinions in the hearing of my Auditors, and none of them ever won one of them that I heard of, (yet the Dr. supposeth some great danger of their peoples seduction, if they hear such as I that never were accused of false Doctrine. 5. But he hath chosen an instance yet nearer our present case: Another part of Kidderminster ⟨p. 72⟩Parish is near three miles off, at a Village called Mitton; where at the Chapel I found a Curate called Mr. Turner, infamous for drunkenness, fighting, living on unlawful marriage, and for gross ignorance: (I tried him, and perceived not that he understood much of the Creed,) I sent them a worthy Preacher once a day first, and twice after, and declared my utter dissent to Mr. Turner's Ministry; yet because some of the Church of England would have him, and he would, against my will, read the Common Prayer to them once a day, I hindered them not from their choice, but they went on. 6. And the sequestered Vicar in the Town (Mr.
But seeing he will needs bring the case to Kiderminster, whether I would suffer Mr. Tombes to gather a Congregation, I must not balk it; but advise him hereafter to keep himself at a greater distance, and not to put his own followers, who are willing enough to believe him, upon utter impossibilities: He sped better with them when he laid the scene an hundred years backward, or as far off as New England; let him know then all these things in confutation of his historical supposition. 1. That Kiderminster Parish hath but about three thousand or four thousand souls, and the Church so fit (with five Galleries) that all may hear: But his Parish is said to have twenty thousand souls, of which not four thousand can hear. 2. A considerable part of Kiderminster Parish, called Ridnal, being at Bewdly Bridge end, and two miles from Kiderminster, (and some Villages more) usually were Mr. Tombes his hearers at Bewdley, and I never blamed them. 3. After him, they were Hearers and Communicants to his Successor Mr. Oasland, and he took the Pastoral care of them (that desired any;) and I was so far from blaming him, that I greatly thanked him, and we were far from disagreeing. 4. Though Mr. Tombes and I differed in the doctrine of Infant Baptism, I gave him leave (yea and the Quakers too) in the publick Church many hours together, to say all that they could for their opinions in the hearing of my Auditors, and none of them ever won one of them that I heard of, (yet the Dr. supposeth some great danger of their peoples seduction, if they hear such as I that never were accused of false Doctrine. 5. But he hath chosen an instance yet neerer our present case: Another part of Kiderminster
Dance) was generally taken to be as ignorant as he, so that when once a quarter he went into the Pulpit, his own Wife, though of the Church of England, would for shame go out of Church: Yet did I never forbid him to preach, and he oft read the Common Prayer at Sir Ralph Clares, and I suppose gave them the Sacrament. 7. I had opportunity then to have hindered all this if I would have used Magistrates: They were both by Proclamation to remove two miles off, but neither of them once removed so much as out of their houses, nor did I desire it; but we are by law driven five miles off. 8. Mr. Dance had forty pounds a year allowed him, and Mr. Turner never had a groat of his ancient Salary diminished, when another was put in, but the other paid otherwise; but we ask you nothing for assisting you. 9. I had never one hundred pounds to my self, and therefore could maintain no more help; (two Assistants I had) but have you no more to maintain Assistants? Now judge how well your historical Instances serve your turn.
Dance) was generally taken to be as ignorant as he, so that when once a quarter he went into the Pulpit, his own Wife, though of the Church of England, would for shame go out of Church: Yet did I never forbid him to preach, and he oft read the Common Prayer at Sir Ralph Clares, and I suppose gave them the Sacrament. 7. I had opportunity then to have hindred all this if I would have used Magistrates: They were both by Proclamation to remove two miles off, but neither of them once removed so much as out of their houses, nor did I desire it; but we are by law driven five miles off. 8. Mr. Dance had forty pounds a year allowed him, and Mr. Turner never had a groat of his ancient Salary diminished, when another was put in, but the other paid otherwise; but we ask you nothing for assisting you. 9. I had never one hundred pounds to my self, and therefore could maintain no more help; (two Assistants I had) but have you no more to maintain Assistants? Now judge how well your historical Instances serve your turn.
And besides the number of Souls, very many Parishes are so wide, that distance forbiddeth many to come to the public Parish Churches: Some Villages are five miles, some four, and many three miles off; and how can Families, especially Women, Children, and the aged, and especially in winter, go so far twice (or once) a day: And must all these forbear to hear, or to worship God, for fear of being counted Schismatics?
And besides the number of Souls, very many Parishes are so wide, that distance forbiddeth many to come to the publick Parish Churches: Some Villages are five miles, some four, and many three miles off; and how can Families, especially Women, Children, and the aged, and especially in winter, go so far twice (or once) a day: And must all these forbear to hear, or to worship God, for fear of being counted Schismaticks?
Because the Dr. appealeth to my self, I seriously profess that when I had a Pastoral Charge, (which was but in one place) I would have been very thankful to any one that differed no more than the Dr. and I do, that would have gathered a Congregation of such, as for number or distance could not have come into the Parish Church; and the case of distance did occasion the honest separation aforesaid, though the case of numbers did not: Yea when hundreds desired Communion according to the Common Prayer, I never offered to hinder any of them from taking it where and how they would.
Because the Dr. appealeth to my self, I seriously profess that when I had a Pastoral Charge, (which was but in one place) I would have been very thankful to any one that dissered no more than the Dr. and I do, that would have gathered a Congregation of such, as for number or distance could not have come into the Parish Church; and the case of distance did occasion the honest separation aforesaid, though the case of numbers did not: Yea when hundreds desired Communion according to the Common Prayer, I never offered to hinder any of them from taking it where and how they would.
Sect. 14. P. 99. He saith [This is Mr. Baxter's own Case—when he is pinched with the Point of Separation, thus he declares, that his hearers are ⟨p. 73⟩the same with ours; at least ten or twenty for one.—If this be true, then what such mighty help is this to our great Parishes, what colour or pretence is there from the largeness of them, that he should preach to the very same men that come to our Church.—Then how come they to be lawful when few or none of those many thousands ever come.—to speak softly this pretence is not becoming Mr. Baxters Sincerity.
Ans. what hope of Justice from such Judges? Or what hope of profiting such Readers by Dispute, as cannot answer such as this themselves. When I began to preach at St. James's the neighbours assured me, that many of the hearers had been at no Church of four years; but they were Members of the Parish-Church, and that some of them got into the Church, but rarely: and some liked it not so well as to be forward seekers. When I was driven thence, I preached a while where Mr. Wadsworth was in Southwark: There were some people that had adhered to their old ejected worthy Pastor, and some that I knew not. Since then I preach once on the Lords day in another mans Pulpit, as near St. James's as I could, and the same persons that heard me there do (many of them) come hither, and some others: of all whom I know very few, but by report. On Thursdays I preach a Lecture in another mans Pulpit to persons of whom I know not many: but report saith, that some of them join not ordinarily with the Parish Ministers, and some do, and most judge it lawful, and sometime, but seldom practise it: And those are of two sorts: some that prefer the Nonconformists Ministry, and some that finding the Parish Churches crowded, and many present are out of hearing, do seldom go thither, though they are of the Parish Churches, and dissent not from their Ministry or Worship: some say [we have no Seats and cannot stand:] some say [we cannot hear the Minister:] some say, Thousands stay away that can get no room, and will go no whither else, and when we can go elsewhere, we will not crowd in first to keep them out, that so much need Others must be out if we be in. These are your own Church-Members: they hear you sometimes, but seldom. Others that hear you constantly on the Lords days, will think that a Sermon on the week days may be needful to them whatever you think or say against it. And is it inconsistent with Sincerity here to plead the peoples necessity. It's well that our Sincerity is not to stand or fall to your judgment. Did I say that my hearers are constant hearers in your Churches?
Ans. what hope of Justice from such Judges? Or what hope of profiting such Readers by Dispute, as cannot answer such as this themselves. When I began to preach at St. James's the neighbours assured me, that many of the hearers had been at no Church of four years; but they were Members of the Parish-Church, and that some of them got into the Church, but rarely: and some liked it not so well as to be forward seekers. When I was driven thence, I preached a while where Mr. Wadsworth was in Southwark: There were some people that had adhered to their old ejected worthy Pastor, and some that I knew not. Since then I preach once on the Lords day in another mans Pulpit, as near St. James's as I could, and the same persons that heard me there do (many of them) come hither, and some others: of all whom I know very few, but by report. On Thursdays I preach a Lecture in another mans Pulpit to persons of whom I know not many: but report saith, that some of them joyn not ordinarily with the Parish Ministers, and some do, and most judge it lawful, and sometime, but seldom practise it: And those are of two sorts: some that prefer the Nonconformists Ministry, and some that finding the Parish Churches crowded, and many present are out of hearing, do seldom go thither, though they are of the Parish Churches, and dissent not from their Ministry or Worship: some say [we have no Seats and cannot stand:] some say [we cannot hear the Minister:] some say, Thousands stay away that can get no room, and will go no whither else, and when we can go elsewhere, we will not crowd in first to keep them out, that so much need Others must be out if we be in. These are your own Church-Members: they hear you sometimes, but seldom. Others that hear you constantly on the Lords days, will think that a Sermon on the week days may be needful to them whatever you think or say against it. And is it inconsistent with Sincerity here to plead the peoples necessity. It's well that our Sincerity is not to stand or fall to your judgment. Did I say that my hearers are constant hearers in your Churches?
Can you persuade the World, while you deny not that half or a quarter of your own Parish cannot hear you (much less many greater Parishes) that if some of them do but sometimes crowd in, perhaps once in many months or weeks, by coming with the first, and do but dwell in the Parish and own you, that they have no need to hear or worship God ⟨p. 74⟩publicly all the rest of the year, and to pretend such need becometh not Sincerity.
Can you perswade the World, while you deny not that half or a quarter of your own Parish cannot hear you (much less many greater Parishes) that if some of them do but sometimes crowd in, perhaps once in many months or weeks, by coming with the first, and do but dwell in the Parish and own you, that they have no need to hear or worship God ⟨p. 74⟩publickly all the rest of the year, and to pretend such need becometh not Sincerity.
2. And as to those that meet in lesser Parishes, you thought not meet to take notice of my answer, assigning many Reasons, which I will not repeat, any further than to tell you. 1. That many Churches there are unbuilt. 2. Many come from the greater Parishes to them: and some have other Reasons.
Sect. 15. P. 102. He saith [Mr. Baxter hath a whole Chapter (Plea p. 141.) of Reasons against the Communion of Laymen with our Church.] Answ. You are unhappy in History, though it be your strength. There's not a word to prove it unlawful for Laymen to have Communion with your Churches, but only the Matter of Fact named, which is supposed to the Controversy; But it being cunningly worded by you, it may be by [Reasons against Communion with our Churches,] you meant but as I did (Reasons for Nonconformity in those particular Acts:) But do you not your self all-along suppose and plead, that though we conform not, yet we should hold Communion with you. Why call you then the Reasons of Nonconformity, Reasons against Communion.
Sect. 15. P. 102. He saith [Mr. Baxter hath a whole Chapter (Plea p. 141.) of Reasons against the Communion of Laymen with our Church.] Answ. You are unhappy in History, though it be your strength. There's not a word to prove it unlawful for Laymen to have Communion with your Churches, but only the Matter of Fact named, which is supposed to the Controversie; But it being cunningly worded by you, it may be by [Reasons against Communion with our Churches,] you meant but as I did (Reasons for Nonconformity in those particular Acts:) But do you not your self all-along suppose and plead, that though we conform not, yet we should hold Communion with you. Why call you then the Reasons of Nonconformity, Reasons against Communion.
Sect. 16. P. 103. He adds [in the same Books he saith, it is Schismatical in a Church to deny Baptism without the transient Sign of the Cross, or for want of God-fathers, &c. or to deny Communion to such who scruple kneeling. Now if the Church be Schismatical, then those who separate in these things are not.
Sect. 16. P. 103. He adds [in the same Books he saith, it is Schismatical in a Church to deny Baptism without the transient Sign of the Cross, or for want of God-fathers, &c. or to deny Communion to such who scruple kneeling. Now if the Church be Schismatical, then those who seperate in these things are not.
Answ. 1. Say you so! Then we are not only quit, but further quit than we can own our selves. I undertake to prove that it may be Schism to separate from a Church that is guilty of some Schismatical Acts and Impositions. And it needs no proof, but the plain History, and their Accusations of one another; that there are few, if any Churches on Earth that are not guilty of somewhat that is Schismatical, in East, West, North or South, in Afric, Asia, Europe or America; Greeks, Muscovites, Jacobites, Abassines, Nestorians, Armenians, Georgians, Mengrelians, Circassians, Papists, Lutherans, Calvinists, Prelaticalls, Presbyterians, Independents, Anabaptists, &c. And must we separate from them all.
Answ. 1. Say you so! Then we are not only quit, but further quit than we can own our selves. I undertake to prove that it may be Schism to separate from a Church that is guilty of some Schismatical Acts and Impositions. And it needs no proof, but the plain History, and their Accusations of one another; that there are few, if any Churches on Earth that are not guilty of somewhat that is Schismatical, in East, VVest, North or South, in Africk, Asia, Europe or America; Greeks, Muscovites, Jacobites, Abassines, Nestorians, Armenians, Georgians, Mengrelians, Circassians, Papists, Lutherans, Calvinists, Prelaticalls, Presbyterians, Independants, Anabaptists, &c. And must we separate from them all.
Sect. 13. p. I was in hope to have met with some answer to my importunate Question, [What would you have the many score thousands do, that cannot come within your Churches to hear?] But no importunity will prevail for so small a matter with inexorable men. But he saith, 1. that [this is but a pretence.] 2. And that [no man denyeth that more places are desirable, &c.] Ans. 1. It is me that he is now accusing! why doth he barely say and not prove, that it's but a pretence? I never set up a Meeting place, but in St. Martins Parish, where are said to be forty thousand more than can come within the Church: And when they would not suffer me to use it, I gladly left it to the use of the Parish Minister. I preach now twice a week elsewhere, but both the places are in Neighbourhoods, where many thousands cannot hear in the Parish Churches. What if other men have other sufficient reasons (as the utter incapacity of some Ministers, or the like) doth it follow that my own case and prosessed reason is a meer pretence? why then did I use no publick preaching, while I lived in such Villages where the people might go to Church? and why did I constantly twice a day lead them thither, though some disliked it? 2. The question is not whether more Churches ⟨p. 71⟩are desirable? But where they are not, whether many thousands must live like Atheists, without all publick teaching or Divine Worship, for fear of being called Schismaticks. Is not this plainly to chuse damnation? If the Gospel be needless, why do we wish the Heathens had it? Why subscribe you against mens hopes of being saved in all their several Religions? If Church worship be needless, why is a Clergy to be so honoured, and maintained at so dear a rate? Aud why do you make such a stir with Separatists to bring them to your Churches? Can men, not blinded by interest, chuse but wonder, that so many thousands in a Parish should be taken for Church Members, and live quietly, that come not to any Church, or never communicate with any, and yet that godly persons who hear and communicate with their old tryed Pastors (yea with such as communicate with you) should be preach'd and written against as Schismaticks, and judged to that which some endure. Did this Dr. think that to drop in the case of other men, when he was at a loss, would make good his charge against me, and such as I: Mr. Tombes and Mr.