A27045:286
The successive visibility of the church of which the Protestants are the soundest members…
The successive visibility of the church of which the Protestants are the soundest members I. defended against the opposition of Mr. William Johnson, II. proved by many arguments / by Richard Baxter ; whereunto is added 1. an account of my judgement to Mr. J. how far heretics are or are not in the church, 2. Mr. Js. explication of the most used terms, with my queries thereupon, and his answer and my reply, 3. an appendix about successive ordination, 4. letters between me and T.S., a papist, with a narrative of the success.The successive visibility of the church of which the Protestants are the soundest members I. defended against the opposition of Mr. William Johnson, II. proved by many arguments / by Richard Baxter ; whereunto is added 1. an account of my judgement to Mr. J. how far hereticks are or are not in the church, 2. Mr. Js. explication of the most used terms, with my queries thereupon, and his answer and my reply, 3. an appendix about successive ordination, 4. letters between me and T.S., a papist, with a narrative of the success.
London: printed by R.W. for Nevil Simmons, 1660
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In your Margin you add that [Concerning S. Athanasius being judged, and rightly, by P. Julius, Chamier acknowledgeth the matter of fact to be so: but against all antiquity pretends that judgment to have been unjust.] Reply. Take it not ill Sir I beseech you, if I awake your conscience, to tell me, how you dare write so many untruths, which you knew, or might know, I could quickly manifest. Both parts of your saying of Chamier p. 497, are untrue. 1. The matter of fact is it that he denieth: He proveth to you from Sozomen's words, that Athanasius did make no appeal to a Judge, but only fled for help to a friend: He shows you that Julius did not play the Judge, but the helper of the spoiled, and that it was not an act of Judgement. 2. He therefore accuseth him not of wrong judging, but only mentioneth his not hearing the accused, to show that he did not play the part of a Judge, but a friend, as Chrysostom ⟨p. 147⟩did by some that fled to him. I pray answer his reasons.
In your Margin you adde that [Concerning S. Athanasius being judged, and rightly, by P. Julius, Chamier acknowledgeth the matter of fact to be so: but against all antiquity pretends that judgment to have been unjust.] Reply. Take it not ill Sir I beseech you, if I awake your conscience, to tell me, how you dare write so many untruths, which you knew, or might know, I could quickly manifest. Both parts of your saying of Chamier p. 497, are untrue. 1. The matter of fact is it that he denieth: He proveth to you from Sozomens words, that Athanasius did make no appeal to a Judge, but only fled for help to a friend: He shews you that Iulius did not play the Judge, but the helper of the spoiled, and that it was not an act of Judgement. 2. He therefore accuseth him not of wrong judgeing, but only mentioneth his not hearing the accused, to shew that he did not play the part of a Judge, but a friend, as Chrysostome ⟨p. 147⟩did by some that fled to him. I pray answer his reasons.
And for what you say again in your Margin of Theodoret; I say again, that he appealeth to the Bishop of Rome for help; as a person who with the Western Bishops might sway much against his adversaries, but not as to an Universal Governor or Judge: no not as to the Universal Judge of the Church Imperial; much less of all the Catholic Churches.