A27046:241
A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our…
A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our concord, 2. the impossibility of it, on the terms of the present impositions against the accusations and storms of, viz., Mr. John Hinckley, a nameless impleader, a nameless reflector, or Speculum, &c., Mr. John Cheny's second accusation, Mr. Roger L'Strange, justice, &c., the Dialogue between the Pope and a fanatic, J. Varney's fanatic Prophecy / by Richard Baxter.A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our concord, 2. the impossibility of it, on the terms of the present impositions against the accusations and storms of, viz., Mr. John Hinckley, a nameless impleader, a nameless reflector, or Speculum, &c., Mr. John Cheny's second accusation, Mr. Roger L'Strange, justice, &c., the Dialogue between the Pope and a fanatic, J. Varney's phanatic Prophesie / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Jacob Sampson, 1681
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§ 5. P. 92. A word more ad hominem of that opinion, That particular Churches are parts of the Universal, as a Troop is of an Army, or a City of a Kingdom.
This is Mr. Baxters opinion: why then do you blame the turning all the Parish-Churches into Chapels, and making them to be but parts of the Diocesan, as a Troop is of an Army, &c. who sees not that your Doctrine doth the same that you condemn, &c. If they are but parts and Members of another Church, (the Universal) then they are not Churches.—It is not unlikely but you can find somewhat to say in defence of this your self-contradicting Doctrine; but I believe it will match your wit, were it ten times more, and prove too hard for you. Look to it; if your disputations against Prelacy stand, down goes this main assertion of yours. If your disputations against Prelacy be found to have a hollow and false bottom, then you have made you work for repentance, you have greatly injured the Church of God, and particularly the Church of England, and have deceived a great many. Look what Bellarmine maketh the Pope to be to all the Pastors, Churches, and Christians through the world, That do you make this which you call the Church Universal: for you say that particular Churches, as headed by their respective Bishops and Pastors, are parts and members of another Church called the Church Universal: By which assertion you set up an Universal ⟨p. 24⟩Head or Government over all the Pastors, Churches, and Christians in the world besides Christ; and you say this is of Divine Institution; and you lay the concord of all the Churches upon it. Do but grant the Papists this one assertion, that particular Churches, as headed by their respective Pastors, are parts and members of the Universal Church, as a City is of a Kingdom, and overthrow the Popes headship over all if you can. It will follow that there must be, besides Christ, an Universal Ecclesiastical Monarch on Earth, either personal or collective, who must have the Supreme power. P. 96. But indeed you have gone beyond Bellarmine in setting up Papal Monarchy. Your other assertion sets up Atheism, by making the Holy God the Author and Founder of two essentially different Churches, or Church-Forms. According to Bellarmines assertion for the Pope, there would be Pastors, &c. But according to your assertion, all the world must be Atheists, of no Religion at all.—P. 224, 225. Your division of the Church into Universal and particular, is plainly against that Rule in Logic; Membra omnis bonae divisionis debent esse inter se opposita.