A27046:367
A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our…
A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our concord, 2. the impossibility of it, on the terms of the present impositions against the accusations and storms of, viz., Mr. John Hinckley, a nameless impleader, a nameless reflector, or Speculum, &c., Mr. John Cheny's second accusation, Mr. Roger L'Strange, justice, &c., the Dialogue between the Pope and a fanatic, J. Varney's fanatic Prophecy / by Richard Baxter.A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our concord, 2. the impossibility of it, on the terms of the present impositions against the accusations and storms of, viz., Mr. John Hinckley, a nameless impleader, a nameless reflector, or Speculum, &c., Mr. John Cheny's second accusation, Mr. Roger L'Strange, justice, &c., the Dialogue between the Pope and a fanatic, J. Varney's phanatic Prophesie / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Jacob Sampson, 1681
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Answ. Had he not mentioned weak Eyes, you might wonder that he saw not how he here confuteth his own falsehood: when in the words cited I profess to give but the Historical Narrative of our Case and Judgment, and not the Arguments or Reasons for it: But he thinketh, [If the History be given in answer to him that demanded the ⟨p. 92⟩Reasons, then the History containeth those Reasons;] Negatur Sequela: The matter of Fact must go first. The Bishop demanded of me an account of our Non-conformity. This is the beginning of an Answer. The Reasons may come next.
Answ. Had he not mentioned weak Eyes, you might wonder that he saw not how he here confuteth his own falshood: when in the words cited I profess to give but the Historical Narrative of our Case and Judgment, and not the Arguments or Reasons for it: But he thinketh, [If the History be given in answer to him that demanded the ⟨p. 92⟩Reasons, then the History containeth those Reasons;] Negatur Sequela: The matter of Fact must go first. The Bishop demanded of me an account of our Non-conformity. This is the beginning of an Answer. The Reasons may come next.
§ 9. Impl. [And if he may be believed, they are not only Mr. Baxter's Reasons, (m. 6.) but of many others (m. 7.) for p. 3. it is said [We that publish this here, give an account of our own judgment, how far we hold it lawful or unlawful to gather or separate from Churches, or to differ from what is established by Authority.
Answ. The man knoweth not the difference between giving an account of our judgment in Thesi, and in Hypothesi. If I tell you in what cases I hold it lawful or unlawful to separate from Churches, or how far humane Power may go (as I have done in the second Plea) is that to tell what I take for sin in our Conformity, and the Reasons of it? What if I show how far Lying is unlawful? Doth that say that Conformity is Lying, &c.