A27046:533
A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our…
A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our concord, 2. the impossibility of it, on the terms of the present impositions against the accusations and storms of, viz., Mr. John Hinckley, a nameless impleader, a nameless reflector, or Speculum, &c., Mr. John Cheny's second accusation, Mr. Roger L'Strange, justice, &c., the Dialogue between the Pope and a fanatic, J. Varney's fanatic Prophecy / by Richard Baxter.A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our concord, 2. the impossibility of it, on the terms of the present impositions against the accusations and storms of, viz., Mr. John Hinckley, a nameless impleader, a nameless reflector, or Speculum, &c., Mr. John Cheny's second accusation, Mr. Roger L'Strange, justice, &c., the Dialogue between the Pope and a fanatic, J. Varney's phanatic Prophesie / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Jacob Sampson, 1681
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
§ 45. About the Covenant, 1. he falsely makes me say, that the King took it: Whereas (whether he did or not) I only say, that he was injuriously and unlawfully drawn to seem to own it and declare for it.
§ 45. About the Covenant, 1. he falsly makes me say, that the King took it: Whereas (whether he did or not) I only say, that he was injuriously and unlawfully drawn to seem to owne it and declare for it.
2. Next he aggravates this Injury: And who contradicteth him?
3. He pleadeth, That the King is not obliged ⟨p. 143⟩by it to make any alteration in the Government of the Church.
Answ. I will not examine your Reasons: The King never made me his Confessor, nor put the question to me; Why then should I make my self a Judge of it? And why must my Ministry lie on a thing beyond my knowledge? But am I sure that no Parliament-man that took that Vow is bound there in his place to endeavour a Reforming Alteration, when I am past doubt that much is needful?
He would 1. make it doubtful, Whether it was a Vow to God? I think it not worth the labour to prove it to him that doubteth of it after deliberate reading it.
2. He saith, [Any lawful endeavours are not denied.] Answ. But the Obligation to lawful endeavours are denied. Are not the words universal?
3. He saith, [The Covenant condemned as unlawful, cannot lay an Obligation.]
Answ. A Vow to God unlawfully imposed and taken, may bind to a Lawful Act.
Answ. A Vow to God unlawfully imposed and taken, may binde to a Lawful Act.
4. He calls it [unnecessary alterations against the Law of the Land.]
Answ. I suppose I shall prove some reforming alteration necessary; And it is not against Law for a Subject to petition for it, or a Parliament-man to speak for it. Yet when the man seems to me to be pleading Conscience out of the Land, he saith, [Would not this cause the Christian Religion in a short time to be exploded out of all Kingdoms?] Alas poor people! what uncertain Guides have you?
5. He concludes, that the power of Reforming ⟨p. 144⟩being in the King, the Vow was null. Answ. The Regal Power of Reforming is only in the King: To change Laws without him, is Usurpation. But Parliament-men may speak for it, and Subjects petition, and on just causes write and speak for needful Reformation: And I speak for no other.
§ 45. IV. About not taking Arms against those Commissioned by the King; He plainly professeth that we must not distinguish where the Law doth not. And if it be an unlimited Universal Negative, it will quite go beyond Mainwaring or Sibthorpe: And for all his talk, my ignorance of the Law shall suspend my Subscription. 1. King John gave up his Kingdom to the Pope: I cannot say it had been unlawful for the Kingdom to resist such as he should have Commissioned to execute it. 2. Nor such as should be Commissioned to dispossess the right Heir, and settle it on a Stranger, or an Enemy. 3. Nor such as should be Commissioned to seize on all the Subjects Estates or Lives, yea or lay Taxes contrary to Law, in cases where the Law enableth the Sheriff by the Posse Comitatus to resist. 4. Nor if any get the Broad-Seal to Commissions to seize on the King's Garrisons, Forts, Navies, Treasures, Guards, whereby a traitorous Lord-Keeper might at any time Depose the King. I have told you, that old Parliaments Popish and Protestant, and Archbishop Abbot, and Bishop Bilson, &c. were as much Nonconformists in this as I am.
§ 45. IV. About not taking Arms against those Commissioned by the King; He plainly professeth that we must not distinguish where the Law doth not. And if it be an unlimited Universal Negative, it will quite go beyond Mainwaring or Sibthorpe: And for all his talk, my ignorance of the Law shall suspend my Subscription. 1. King John gave up his Kingdom to the Pope: I cannot say it had been unlawful for the Kingdom to resist such as he should have Commissioned to execute it. 2. Nor such as should be Commissioned to dispossess the right Heir, and settle it on a Stranger, or an Enemy. 3. Nor such as should be Commissioned to seize on all the Subjects Estates or Lives, yea or lay Taxes contrary to Law, in cases where the Law enableth the Sheriff by the Posse Comitatus to resist. 4. Nor if any get the Broad-Seal to Commissions to seize on the King's Garrisons, Forts, Navies, Treasures, Guards, whereby a traiterous Lord-Keeper might at any time Depose the King. I have told you, that old Parliaments Popish and Protestant, and Archbishop Abbot, and Bishop Bilson, &c. were as much Nonconformists in this as I am.
And so much to the Impleaders Accusations of the Nonconformists, and his Reasons for the ⟨p. 145⟩justifying of their Silencing and ruin, and the Lawfulness of some of the things which they judge to them unlawful: Let the impartial Reader try and judge. The rest of my Book, which is the far greater part, he answereth by contempt and silence.
And so much to the Impleaders Accusations of the Nonconformists, and his Reasons for the ⟨p. 145⟩justifying of their Silencing and ruine, and the Lawfulness of some of the things which they judge to them unlawful: Let the impartial Reader try and judge. The rest of my Book, which is the far greater part, he answereth by contempt and silence.
CHAP. IV. Of his dealing with the Second Plea for Peace.
While we hear men, that should be our Brethren, go on to call to Magistrates for Execution of the Laws (which they have got) against us, and for want of matter of Accusation against those that they prosecute, raking up odious Criminations from the late Wars, which few of the now Silenced Ministers had any hand in; and never ceasing to tell men, that the Beginners of that War were guilty of the King's Death. After 17 or 18 years Silence, 1. I told them, That two parties of the Episcopal Conformists being the beginners, in England, it's wondered that they see not how they accuse themselves: And why do they not profess Repentance first? 2. I fully told them what are our Principles of Government and Obedience, and entreated them to show me, wherein they are disloyal or culpable. And this man is the first ⟨p. 146⟩that I find pretending to assault it, and shame lessly passeth over the Book itself, and by his silence seemeth to justify our Doctrine. And yet to show his Will, he taketh occasion again to take up the foresaid actions of the evil Civil War, as if that were any thing to the present Cause; or as if he were calling the dead to Judgment: (For we have oft offered them thanks, if they will Silence only those that had a hand in those Wars.) 2. He taketh on him to answer my Historical Preface; and therein heapeth abundance of untruths, part of which I mentioned in the second Chapter, and the rest I have so fully confuted in my Answer to Mr. Hinkley, and in an Historical Index of those affairs, that I will not waste my own and the Readers time, by saying the same things here again. And his Accusations of my Concord and Moral Prognostication, I have answered before. It is the manner of the man to name Books, and take occasion from somewhat in them, to pour out that which he most abounds with; and to try, whether men will take this for a Confutation. O miserable world! Where the very Preachers of Holiness, Love and Peace, go on to the Grave, and Judgment, and Eternity, fighting against Holiness, Love and Peace; forbidding others to worship God, (that cannot swallow all their Inventions) and not enduring their Brethren to live in Peace among them. But 'tis Letter in the World of Holy Love and Peace.
WHile we hear men, that should be our Brethren, go on to call to Magistrates for Execution of the Laws (which they have got) against us, and for want of matter of Accusation against those that they prosecute, raking up odious Criminations from the late Wars, which few of the now Silenced Ministers had any hand in; and never ceasing to tell men, that the Beginners of that War were guilty of the King's Death. After 17 or 18 years Silence, 1. I told them, That two parties of the Episcopal Conformists being the beginners, in England, it's wonder'd that they see not how they accuse themselves: And why do they not profess Repentance first? 2. I fully told them what are our Principles of Government and Obedience, and intreated them to shew me, wherein they are disloyal or culpable. And this man is the first ⟨p. 146⟩that I finde pretending to assault it, and shame lessly passeth over the Book itself, and by his silence seemeth to justifie our Doctrine. And yet to shew his Will, he taketh occasion again to take up the foresaid actions of the evil Civil War, as if that were any thing to the present Cause; or as if he were calling the dead to Judgment: (For we have oft offered them thanks, if they will Silence only those that had a hand in those Wars.) 2. He taketh on him to answer my Historical Preface; and therein heapeth abundance of untruths, part of which I mentioned in the second Chapter, and the rest I have so fully confuted in my Answer to Mr. Hinkley, and in an Historical Index of those affairs, that I will not waste my own and the Readers time, by saying the same things here again. And his Accusations of my Concord and Moral Prognostication, I have answered before. It is the manner of the man to name Books, and take occasion from somewhat in them, to pour out that which he most abounds with; and to try, whether men will take this for a Confutation. O miserable world! Where the very Preachers of Holiness, Love and Peace, go on to the Grave, and Judgment, and Eternity, fighting against Holiness, Love and Peace; forbidding others to worship God, (that cannot swallow all their Inventions) and not enduring their Brethren to live in Peace among them. But 'tis Letter in the World of Holy Love and Peace.