A27046:79
A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our…
A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our concord, 2. the impossibility of it, on the terms of the present impositions against the accusations and storms of, viz., Mr. John Hinckley, a nameless impleader, a nameless reflector, or Speculum, &c., Mr. John Cheny's second accusation, Mr. Roger L'Strange, justice, &c., the Dialogue between the Pope and a fanatic, J. Varney's fanatic Prophecy / by Richard Baxter.A third defence of the cause of peace proving 1. the need of our concord, 2. the impossibility of it, on the terms of the present impositions against the accusations and storms of, viz., Mr. John Hinckley, a nameless impleader, a nameless reflector, or Speculum, &c., Mr. John Cheny's second accusation, Mr. Roger L'Strange, justice, &c., the Dialogue between the Pope and a fanatic, J. Varney's phanatic Prophesie / by Richard Baxter.
London: printed for Jacob Sampson, 1681
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
You add, [What was good in it we were obliged to by a former Covenant.] Answ. And what then? Is that another Doctrine, that Conformists must preach, That [no Vow or Oath obligeth you to any good that you were obliged to before.] Oh dreadful! The Jesuits Morals would abhor such a Doctrine: If there may be new Vows to the same thing, there may be new or additional Obligations to the same thing; else all the following Vows are no Vows. What if the Oath of Allegiance be thrice taken? Doth it oblige only the first time? Then if a man be at Baptism obliged to Christianity, no after Vows at the Lords Supper, or other time, are obligatory. Sir, be not angry with me for telling you, that Non-conformists have somewhat in them, that will not permit them to take these for indifferent things: And that the diminution of your ⟨p. 47⟩glory and mens temptation to separation from you, hath too much occasion and colour from your selves.
You add, [The worst of Heretics maintain some Truths.] Answ. And quid inde? Suppose, so the Covenant hath some good? Our question is not, whether we are bound to the bad, but to the good: And will you say, that I must receive no truth which a Heretic holdeth; or am bound by it to no good, which is contained in a Vow that hath evil with it.
You add, [The worst of Hereticks maintain some Truths.] Answ. And quid inde? Suppose, so the Covenant hath some good? Our question is not, whether we are bound to the bad, but to the good: And will you say, that I must receive no truth which a Heretick holdeth; or am bound by it to no good, which is contained in a Vow that hath evil with it.
§. 12, 13, 14. Will any thing convince you of an Error or Sin, if the visibility of my words and yours, and my reminding you of your visible misreport will not do it? but still when you see your words and mine, and hear of your mistake; you will yet go on, yea and falsely add, that [In one breath I say I did, and I did not retract them.] This practice, and your fore-going Doctrine well agree: When I had asked you [Whether it be all one to say I had expunged all that you accuse me of (or charge me with) and that I expunged all that you pervert] (or falsely took occasion from for a visible slander.) This is no stop to you, nor worthy of any Answer; but you go on: Yea when you tell me the Page you meant, and see that there is no such thing there as you mentioned; yet all this (nor my many Writings against that same Opinion) are nothing at all to stop your Calumny. I am not justifying what I expunged; but if it were faulty, must it needs contain a Doctrine which it never mentioned, which I openly wrote against. This dealing is enough to tell me, to what purpose a Disputation of Conformity with you would prove,