And what Schism and Bloodshed was occasioned by the first and second Council at Ephesus: yea, what streams of Blood, Desolation, Schism, and many Ages deplorable enmity and confusion were caused by the Council of Calcedon, I need tell no one that hath read ⟨p. 58⟩Church History. It is true indeed, that the Nestorians and Eutychians were condemned in these, and the M• nothelites in many following: But whether mutual understanding might not have made a better end, I appeal to a Thousand years experience, and to the nature of the Heresies there condemned, which seem to be much formed in and by ambiguous words, which a good Explication might have better healed, than Anathema's and Bloodshed. Of this I spake before (and often.) The Nestorians said, that Mary was not to be called the Mother of God, but of Christ. The Orthodox said the contrary: when the Orthodox never meant that she begat the Godhead, 1and the Nestorians never denied that she begat him that is God. Where then is the difference but in words, one speaking of the Abstract (Deity) which the other never meant?
And what Schism and Bloodshed was occasioned by the first and second Council at Ephesus: yea, what streams of Blood, Desolation, Schism, and many Ages deplorable enmity and confusion were caused by the Council of Calcedon, I need tell no one that hath read ⟨p. 58⟩Church History. It is true indeed, that the Nestorians and Eutychians were condemned in these, and the M• nothelites in many following: But whether mutual understanding might not have made a better end, I appeal to a Thousand years experience, and to the nature of the Heresies there condemned, which seem to be much formed in and by ambiguous words, which a good Explication might have better healed, than Anathema's and Bloodshed. Of this I spake before (and often.) The Nestorians said, that Mary was not to be called the Mother of God, but of Christ. The Orthodox said the contrary: when the Orthodox never meant that she begat the Godhead, 1and the Nestorians never denied that she begate him that is God. Where then is the difference but in words, one speaking of the Abstract (Deity) which the other never meant?
- 1Of this more before.