A27058:1182
The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended…
The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended vindicator of the primitive church, but indeed of the tympanite & tyranny of some prelates many hundred years after Christ, with a detection of the false history of Edward Lord Bishop of Cork and Ross in Ireland ... and a preface abbreviating much of Ludolphus's History of Habassta : written to show their dangerous error, who think that a general council, or college of bishops, is a supreme governor of all the Christian world ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; to which is added by another hand, a defence of a book, entitled, No evidence for diocesan churches ...The true history of councils enlarged and defended against the deceits of a pretended vindicator of the primitive church, but indeed of the tympanite & tyranny of some prelates many hundred years after Christ, with a detection of the false history of Edward Lord Bishop of Corke and Rosse in Ireland ... and a preface abbreviating much of Ludolphus's History of Habassta : written to shew their dangerous errour, who think that a general council, or colledge of bishops, is a supream governour of all the Christian world ... / by Richard Baxter ... ; to which is added by another hand, a defence of a book, entituled, No evidence for diocesan churches ...
London: printed for Tho. Parkhurst, 1682
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ans. 1. You tempt them towards it. If I ask the Butcher [Is your Meat sweet?] and he say it is indifferent, I am excusable if I think it stinks. 2. They judge by the effects: They thought that when an indifferent thing casteth out a necessary thing, it becomes naught. 3. But yet your Accusation is unfaithful: Why did you not say then, that it was not for Nonconformity that men were cast out, but for preaching against your Religion? Who were those? Was it proved? If so, what was that to the rest? Do you punish many learned moderate men for the fault of a few others that they were not concerned with? You now allege Mr. Hildersham, Ball, Bradshaw, Bath, Knewstubs, and abundance such, for being against Separation, and persuading men to come to the Common Prayer, (and many of them to kneel at the Sacrament,) and yet when you plead for their Silencing, even other mens words may serve against them.
Ans. 1. You tempt them towards it. If I ask the Butcher [Is your Meat sweet?] and he say it is indifferent, I am excusable if I think it stinks. 2. They judge by the effects: They thought that when an indifferent thing casteth out a necessary thing, it becomes naught. 3. But yet your Accusation is unfaithful: Why did you not say then, that it was not for Nonconformity that men were cast out, but for preaching against your Religion? Who were those? Was it proved? If so, what was that to the rest? Do you punish many learned moderate men for the fault of a few others that they were not concerned with? You now alledge Mr. Hildersham, Ball, Bradshaw, Baine, Knewstubs, and abundance such, for being against Separation, and persuading men to come to the Common Prayer, (and many of them to kneel at the Sacrament,) and yet when you plead for their Silencing, even other mens words may serve against them.
XVI. To conclude, in all he layeth the cause of their silence on themselves for not conforming, and yet will not tell us what we should do to help it. Would they have us Conform while we judge it as sinful as I have mentioned in my first Plea for Peace? No; they profess the contrary. Would they have us believe all to be lawful? We cannot: Our Judgments are not at our Command: What would they have us do to change? Worldly Interest makes us too willing! We study as hard as they!